Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

How to drill out a broken dowel?

Posts

How to drill out a broken dowel?

#1

How to drill out a broken dowel?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hi all.

My FIL fell yesterday and he tried to catch himself by grabbing one of the posts on his bed. Didn't work out so well for him nor the bed post...

He got an ugly gash on his head. Can't help with that, but I thought I might be able to fix the broken post.

The post is in sections. I have one that is about 18" long. It has a 1/2" round mortise on one end and a 1/2" tenon/dowel on the other. This dowel is what snapped of. So I have this round post/spindle with a 1/2" dowel snapped off of the end. How can I cleanly drill out, or somehow remove, the broken dowel.

Seems like it should be pretty simple, but I want to drill straight in, or down, to get the broken dowel out. Thinking about using my lathe somehow, or maybe the drill press. Not sure how I could secure the spindle/post on the drill press though.

Just looking for some ideas.

Thanks!

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#2

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

John in NM

I would try a forstner bit and a cordless drill. Forstners are a bit easier to see if you're starting plumb.

If dry fit shows it's less than square to the end of the post, you can shave a bit off the dowel and use some 5 min epoxy to fill the gap.

Alternatively, if you have a floor model drill press, you can turn the table to 90 degrees (vertical) and make up a large V-block kinda jig, then carefully shim the leg plumb in the V-block. Lotsa work though.

EDIT:

Completely OT, but I'm thinking of it -- did I ever ask where are you in the Cleveland area? My wife lived in Shaker Heights (as a kid) before her mom moved to Las Vegas. She's headed that way in a week or so to visit her stepmother.

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#3

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

Stuart Johnson

Drill the proper size hole through a 2x4. Center it over the dowel to use as a guide. I think this will keep your drill from wandering.

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#4

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

AZ in Colorado Springs

Ditto to what Stuart wrote. Perhaps you can get some stock the same size and attach a couple of pieces of plywood to oveelap the guide and the part you're drilling to keep the guide registered while you drill.

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#5

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

TomD

The times I have successfully done it I used a horizontal milling machine. A router/milling bit will cut better than a drill bit. Some of those will wander even in the mill. So the woodworking machine equivalents of horizontal milling machines are things like overarm routers, slot mortisers, router jigs, something mocked up on a lathe could work. You can hand feed a 4 flute milling cutter into a lathe chuck if you mock up a table at the right height. If you have high speed or 2 flute cutters you need the parts in a vice or fixture. It is a challenging cut not least of which because the dowels are often harder than the wood we commonly use to make furniture.

Speaking of milling machines, horizontals often come up for 200-500 dollars, or even free. For the shop that must have everything they will allow you to do a lot more than many tools that cost a lot more. Any reasonable quality old US Iron will make the build quality of Festool look silly.

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#6

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

Barry Irby

Good Ideas so far.

I like the guide block made of 2 x4. Don't know how much surface area you have on the end of the work piece, but you could put a couple of slender screws off to the side of the hole to hold it still. If the end of the work piece is slender, you could trun a cup to fit over it with a hole in the center.

You could use a lamp auger if you have one on your lathe. Need a hollow tailstcok to do that and if you had all that you would have already done it.

You could chuck a scrap block in the head stock of the lathe and use a drill bit in the tailstock to drill a hole for the dowel in the "good" end of the workpiece. Insert/glue in a short piece of dowel or turn one onto the block if you prefer. Back off the tailstock and jamb the work piece home and then use the bit in the tail stock to drill the hole. You may want to whittle out the broken dowel a little to give you a firm start. Turn the lathe on very slow or turn it by hand to drill the hole. A forstner bit would be good here.

Or, you could drill a hole in a scrap clamped to the table of your DP, Inset a dowel, lower the table, Install the workpiece and drill out the top, again, clean out the hole and use a forstner bit. The only "trick" to this would be to lower the table, keeping the dowel plumb with the chuck. Maybe a steel rod or even a straight dowel would help with this unless your DP has a guid on the table.

Let us know how it goes. (and for the head wound, Duct Tape. Or better yet, Super Glue.) Hope he does well. I got my scar in a sword fight.

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#7

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

William Duffield

The problem is keeping the bit centered. The lathe will do this for you, using the technique originally developed for drilling out rifle bores. You need to turn the post while holding the drill stationary, and centered. Mount a scroll chuck in the headstock. Grip the post in the scroll chuck. A steady rest would be useful, but not necessary. Mount a brad point or Forstner bit in the tail stock. If you don't have a bit of the proper diameter with a Morse taper, mount a Jacob's chuck or keyless chuck in the tailstock and mount the bit in the chuck. Bring the tailstock up to the post, and center the point of the drill bit on the center of the post. Turn the lathe on at a very slow speed. Advance the tailstock.

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#8

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Joe, I would use a plunge router with a upcut spiral bit.

The problem is that a drill bit will wander as it strikes a tapered end. This will occur regardless of whether the bit is held in a drill press or through a 4x2 or a dowel guide. It is necessary for the bit to cut away the taper rather than drill into it.

Once the remnant of the dowel has been squared off, then you have the choice of finishing with a drill bit if the hole is too deep for the router bit.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#9

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

John McGaw

The success of this method will depend on the surface area available -- keeping a 2X4 perpendicular to the stock can be a problem if it is small. I've done this a couple of times using a plywood block but I always had enough room to screw the block in place on the stock being drilled. There are probably a dozen ways to do the job including just winging it with a really good brad point bit having long spurs. In this case getting really accurate center point laid out would be the first and most difficult step.

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#10

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

Ralph Lipeles

I've done it many times over the years when I was repairing/restoring antique furniture. First, drill in the center of the dowel stub with a 1/4" drill. Then replace the bit with a 3/8" bit and redrill the hole. Now you will have about 1/6" of wood all around that has to be removed. I use an 1/8" chisel or Exacto knife to remove the remaining wood. If you've done a good job, the removal is now done. if too much wood is left, use a 1/2" diameter bit to remove the rest.

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#11

How large diameter post where the dowel fits?

Gary Smyth

Did the post snap at the dowel or did it take part of the post with it? A picture would be helpful. You don't need big machinery to do this. In fact, the set up time and higher speeds could make things more difficult. Use what is there rather than drilling fresh 1/2 holes. Can you saw off the dowel stubs flush to the post? If so that should give you a flat base to do the remainder of the work.

1. Cut off dowel stubs as close as possible to get a flat surface on the post-- do not mess with the outer diameter edges of the post.

2. As Ralph said, start small with a much smaller diameter drill bit as centered as possible on the dowel. A small diameter bit will enable room for error and correction. Drill down into the post as straight as possible to the depth if the dowel and progressively move the bits up in size until you get near the original edge of the dowel hole.

3. When you get closer to the edge use a exacto blade to carefully scrape to the edge of the hole to remove the last portions of dowel and dried glue. You can then wrap the next size smaller dowel with abrasive and hand clean up the hole.

4. If that doesn't get all of the wood splinters and glue out, take a 1/2" bit out of the drill and HAND turn to ream the hole. The ream will want to follow the original hole if it is carefully inserted. The key is to keep it as inline as possible too the original hole (which we know is correct for this post) to enable both sides of a new 1/2" dowel to slide in and mate up with the other post.

5. Do both posts in a similar way.

6. Keep as close to the original holes as possible on both post ends, but you may also want the make the hole a tiny bit over 1/2" so that when you put in a new dowel you have some (slight) wiggle room to mate up the two sections exactly.

7. Use an appropriate glue that can bridge any slight gaps keeping in mind any glue excess and the match of the color of the post exterior.

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#12

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

John C Lucas

Havent read the other responses. What i have done in cases like that where im not repairing a valuabke antique is to drill a hole in both pieces larger than section of all thread rod. I then epoxy the all thread into both holes. Then its just a matter of aligning both parts and clamping until the epoxy cures. If you drill the holes larvd enough it makes it easy to align. If you use a thick enough all thread rod the joint is very strong. Sometimes you may need to thicken the epoxy or create dams from tape or clay.

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#13

Forstner bit

Andrew F in Australia

Hi Joe,

Only read Ralph's reply here, which would probably also work, providing that the 1/4" drill didn't follow the early growth in the dowel and wander off track.

My immediate thought was a forstner bit - I've done that in a drill press multiple times, and because they're guided by the outside of the drill, they don't follow the early growth and cause difficulties.

A

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#14

Re: write yourself out of it

TomD

I have this saying, "write yourself out of it", when one of the kids can't get the right word, or factoid, and are stumped with an essay, I tell them to think of a different way of doing it rather than grinding on the information or special wording they are lacking.

In this case, probably the most effective way to deal with the issue would be to not replace the dowel. The likelihood of precision success is pretty low, is there some completely different method? The obvious one would be hardware bonding (see recent discussion of bed hardware). Without knowledge of the exact parts, one likely outcome is a bunch of oversized holes, so you could start with that as the objective, and make getting where you need to go easier then hardware bond a threaded stud, and it won't break next time. But in other circumstances, you could do something like a floating wooden tenon, etc...

Another option would be to use a small drill to make a pilot hole and then a speedbore. Speedbores are those paddle shaped bits that are pretty rough work drill bits, but they are actually excellent at cuting away endgrain.

I think this is the kind of task where in the absence of a perfect solution mocking up a few scraps you can test your techniques and tools on might be ideal.

Depending on a lot of things, one option is to use a steamer to get steam in, and break the bond, then use a screw, or whatever, to pull it out. If you want some info on steaming strategies, look up steaming apart a martin guitar neck joint.

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#15

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

No, I don't recall you asking, but I am on the other side of Cleveland. Lakewood.

Funny you mention Shaker Heights... ask your wife if she remembers the tv show "The Morning Exchange" with Fred Griffith. When I was a kid his family lived in Lakewood across the street from me. His son and I were good friends. In the early'ish 70's they moved to Shaker Heights. So, I would take a bus to downtown Cleveland, then a train out to Shaker Heights. Sometimes we would meet downtown at the Terminal Tower building and just hang out. I was 10 or 12 years old at the time. What were my parents thinking! Letting a 10 year old kid do that. :D Guess times were a litter safer. I sure as heck wouldn't have let my kids do that when they were that age. Anyway, a couple weeks ago, he and his sisters came to Cleveland (Lakewood and Shaker Heights) for a visit. Hadn't seen them since the mid 70's.

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#16

Thank you all for the great ideas!


Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#17

Re: How large diameter post where the dowel fits?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"Did the post snap at the dowel or did it take part of the post with it?"

It snapped at the dowel, so there is part of the broken dowel sticking out of the spindle. No damage to the spindle.

Thanks.

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#18

Re: write yourself out of it

William Duffield

Another method I've used successfully, if replacing a real dowel (not a turned mortise and tenon) and the adhesive was not steam reversible, was to cut off and drill out the dowel pieces and adhesive oversized, glue in and trim off flush the two halves of the dowel, block up the two pieces of the post perfectly aligned on a flat work surface, slide them apart, cut two new mortises with a Domino, indexing off the work surface, not the Domino fence, and glue the two pieces of the post together with a Domino tenon.

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#19

Before you drill

John Foster

Before you drill, check out how well the broken piece is glued in. Drill a small pilot hole as close to centred as possible in the broken dowel. Take a #10 wood screw and screw it through the dowel. Remove the wood screw and grind off the point and then re thread it into the hole in the dowel. When the blunted end hits the bottom of the hole, if the glue bond is not that strong, the turning screw will "jack" the broken dowel out of the hole.

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#20

What I did...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hi all.

Just thought I'd post a couple pics showing what I ended up doing.

I just used my lathe. Not much to it. I was stressing about ruining the spindle and overthinking it. :b

Worked out well. New dowel was a perfect fit.

Thanks again for the suggestions and help.

Drilling


Drilled


Dowel in


Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#21

late to the party

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Probably someone else described removing a dowel but in case not.....

I find them typically superficially glued. Much of the glue surface is end grain. I free hand drill out about 3/4 of the dowel and pick the rest out with a small chisel, screwdriver or whatever is handy. The bond between dowel and the rest is typically weak and can be fractured with a bit of prying.

Re: How to drill out a broken dowel?

#22

That works great

John in NM

Didn't realize you had a steady rest for the lathe - too easy!

I always forget about these jigs for wood lathes, guess I'm just not tuned to turning. I've used them often enough with metal lathes though.

(My wife left for a Cleveland visit this morning, so wave if you see a plane fly over mid afternoon :D )