Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Bed bolt questions

Posts

Bed bolt questions

#1

Bed bolt questions

Barry Irby

Been building beds for my grand daughters. Struggling over bed bolts design.

I see them at Lee Valley that are essentially large barrel bolts. A 3/4" cylinder of steel threaded cross wise to accept the bolt that holds the rails to the foot board. You drill a hole in the rail, and another hole for the bolt perpendicular to it and the bolt pulls the end tight to the rail. What gives me pause about the design is the fact that the barrel bolt part might split the rail because of the wedging action of the cylinder in the hole. Would it be possible to split the rail by over tightening the bolt? Would moving the bed or rolling around in it split the rail?

I would rather have a flat surface to pull against.

Re: Bed bolt questions

#2

Re: Bed bolt questions

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I have always used a 6" bolt, usually 1/4", and a hex nut with a flat washer. None of the eight beds I've made have ever had a problem, spanning more than thirty years.

Re: Bed bolt questions

#3

Re: Bed bolt questions

Ralph Lipeles

I find that square head nuts seat better in the wood rails then the hex head ones.

Re: Bed bolt questions

#4

No wedging action can occur

Dick Coers

You basically have full contact all around the steel cylinder. There is no point to start the fiber separation. I've used the round cylinders, and square nuts, both work just fine.

Re: Bed bolt questions

#5

Two types bolts and brackets

Gary Smyth

I have several beds mostly hand me downs from the fifties or earlier. Two have traditional bed bolts and brass covers for the holes. Two have bed hook wedge brackets.

None have failed in moving them either in the room or moving cross country. The brackets are easier to install and easier to set up, but neither style has ever failed in my use.




Re: Bed bolt questions

#6

Depends on how often you'll move them

Wayland

I recently put together a milled-painted-and-drilled bunk bed kit for my granddaughters that my daughter bought online. The rail to head/foot board bolts were simple Allen-headed lag screws into the end grain of the rails. They are large enough to hold well, and there is no danger of splitting. But I suppose the holes could get enlarged if the beds were disassembled and moved too many times. Getting the tightening torque on the bolts just right seems like it would be important, though. You don't want the rails to split nor the bolts to loosen when the kids start using the top bunk as a trampoline.

Hope this helps.

Wayland

Re: Bed bolt questions

#7

Re: The right answer

TomD

Can be to use hardware bonding. Pretty simple, if you are interested I can describe the process, but I have described it many times and I doubt anyone tried it. Basic process is to bond your bolt into an oversized hole with epoxy. The oversized hole is key for several reasons. Say you bond a half inch threaded stud into a 3/4" hole a few inches deep. It has incredible withdrawal strength. When they first tried this in wood due to a lock accident they ended up hanging a huge yacht from one cleat, the 4 bolts held in the glue. This is how those huge cantilevered blades are held on windmills. Once you do it, the stud (threaded rod) is an organic part of the beam. The result is perfectly aligned bolts that just scoot through the holes in your verticals, far easier to assemble. Use your favorite nut on the outboard end. Cheap, fast, excellent accuracy, no skill, better look and alignment, but you can't get people to try it.

Re: Bed bolt questions

#8

I tried it.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

On your advice, I attached the legs (spindles, really) of a very weirdly designed table for a friend 5-6 years ago. There simply was no other way to do it. It hasn't come back for fixing, so I assume it worked.

Re: Bed bolt questions

#9

Re: Bed bolt questions

TomD

I think the structural answer is 3 fold.

First the size of bolts and all the rest is overkill for a bed rail. I don't doubt you could probably put them together with drywall screws or lags. Heck I just built a deck/extention and the whole tonnage was held to the ledger with a dozen special screws.

If you get a fit where the barrel, slides through the hole without a hammer, a nice finger fit, the hole is oversized and it will mean the barrel basically concentrates its force on the endgrain/0 axis, so no splitting. If the thing then shrunk like a vise around the barrel, that would be less good... But for the most part you are loading end grain. The hole is a much less of a stress riser on the joint as you get feathering all the way around to the tangent points.

While in theory the squared off hardware option sounds better... Referring to 1 above it will doubtless work also, as the loads are probably not so bad. However, in the real world, the hardware used is probably of poor quality and will require more force to keep engaged, may not load the endgrain evenly, or anywhere near where one expects, and the feathering in of the mortise is pretty abrupt with a lot of loss of crossgrain continuity all in the same reference. There might be some discussion if both sets of hardware were machined and similar in section, but captured hardware nuts are very cheap low quality and fit hardware, and may exert splinting loads through the bolt simply because of uneven bearing.

Free additional points are that major loads are probably in shear at the point of intersection with the hardware not being that critical. A shear stop like a dowel or tenon works great; On my workbench that used captured nuts (hate them) it merely required enough force to snug the joint, once it zeroed out it was like a rock; Lee Valley has been selling them for decades; Hardware bonding is better in every way.

Re: Bed bolt questions

#10

Re: I tried it.

TomD

Great to hear Bruce. I know I pick up a lot from the forums. I think it is a lot to ask to have people try new stuff, particularly without a video. Years ago I did a bench that used the LV metal legs. I was rocky at the time and intended to switch them out when I could put in the shop time. I then made a table out of that base. In doing all this I shortened the beam, a really hefty beam, and I kept that hunk and the studs and jig around for like ten years thinking I would use it somehow, then tossed it, probably a few hours before Youtube went online :) Wish I still had it, because it is pretty convincing when you see how great the results are. Of course I have several benches but the thing I always assume with knock down furniture is that it never gets knocked down, not if you are past University age...

Re: Bed bolt questions

#11

Re: The right answer

Barry Irby

I considered bonding in the bolts. I built a bed for my son in the Army and assumed it would get moved and rough handled many times. I was concerned the bolts protruding would get either bent or the threads damaged to the point it would be difficult to get the nuts started. (He's not handy and cleaning up the threads would be baffling to him) For his bed, I made bolts that retracted into the rail for shipping, held retracted by a magnet and a barrel bolt inside the legs. There was a Tee slot for tightening and a pocket for the wrench, also held in with magnets. Nothing to loose except the wrench which is easily replaceable. This time I was looking for something simpler to do.

I kind of like the idea, simple and nothing to loose except a handful of nuts and washers, easy to replace. The bolts would have to protrude about 1 1/2". Do you think they would survive shipping?