Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Finishing/Loose tenon build?????

Posts

Finishing/Loose tenon build?????

#1

Finishing/Loose tenon build?????

Barry Irby

I built my son a MSM coffee table out of walnut off the family farm. The frame is very light, built legs about 1" by 1 1/14" and rails that are about two inches wide for the top rails and 1 1/4" for the mid rails. I assembled it with loose tenons that were 7/8" wide by 3/8 by 2". My first build with loose tenons.

I finished the frame with wipe on Waterlox. The problem is there was some squeeze out of Titebond glue and a lot of clean up. Now that it is finished, it occurred to me I could have finished all the pieces first and then assembled it and it would have been MUCH easier to clean up the squeeze out. It would have been easy to keep the finish out of the mortises. It seems to me that if I had kept the mortises clean and the tenons free of finish it would have had almost no impact on the strength. Do I have this right? When do you finish the parts? (It was something of a PITA to wipe on finish on the frame.)

Re: Finishing/Loose tenon build?????

#2

Re: Finishing/Loose tenon build?????

paul in AZ

MSM?? Main stream media?

Re: Finishing/Loose tenon build?????

#3

Re: Finishing/Loose tenon build?????

William Duffield

Mid-Century Modern :( :( :(

Re: Finishing/Loose tenon build?????

#4

Prefinish works just fine

Dick Coers

I even do it with spray finishes. I mask off where I don't want the clear finish, then finish away! It always works fine IF all the parts can be dry fit to perfection, since there will be no tweaking parts for the final glue up.

Re: Finishing/Loose tenon build?????

#5

Re: Finishing/Loose tenon build?????

TomD

Another option is to do what they do in furniture factories and small shops and that is use hide glue. You can use hot or cold. Looks like these guys are using hot, in luthier bottles, system. They are using milled tenons but the final assembly is similar. One good thing about hide for loose tenons is you can just as easily remove excess when making up tenoned stock halves for further future assembly, if required.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ug3Tsn45Ao0

You put some stainless bolts in the glue bottles to help keep the glue fluid after it leaves the heater. But the bottles might be cold hide glue, both work.

Hide glue cleans up with water; by peeling at the right temp; by scraping or sanding, and it doesn't clog; or with alcohol.

Re: Finishing/Loose tenon build?????

#6

Re: Finishing/Loose tenon build?????

David Bair

I always apply finish before assembly. As you note it makes clean-up easier but it also makes sanding and finishing easier; you can do every surface laying flat. There are no runs and you can apply a heavier coating without finish buildup in all the corners.

Re: Finishing/Loose tenon build?????

#7

Thanks, some good ideas.....

Barry Irby

As usual Wood Central comes through with some good ideas. I like the idea of using hide glue. I have some and did not think of it.

I am always in the steep part of the learning curve. Either doing something I never did before or doing it again after so long I forgot most of what I knew. And you are right about laying the pieces flat to avoid runs. It was easy to build up nice thicker coats on the top, but the frame was a different animal,.

Re: Finishing/Loose tenon build?????

#8

Re: Finishing/Loose tenon build?????

EdSnow

Are you not cleaning your glue joints immediately after completing the clamping component of the glue up? A simple toothbrush and water will do little but raise the grain while also removing all the glue squeeze out while still wet/soft tack. Usually follow up with a damp rag to remove any beaded water. Coming from a serious volume production environment this is the method used, hide glue is mostly reserved for those concerned with historical accuracy, a preservationist, or an instrument stringed instrument maker of one sort or another. It is a fine and strong adhesive with its place just more a hassle than needed for 90% of objects.

Nothing wrong with pre-finishing when possible, my personal preference is that it be used for secondary or inner surfaces only.

Re: Finishing/Loose tenon build?????

#9

This thing had.....

Barry Irby

Four legs with four rails intersecting each, and with four sides on each rails that's a lot of little inside corners to clean out. And I managed to get glue on my fingers and spread some of it around willy nilly. Beyond that, I have apparently recently gone glue blind and can no longer see glue stuck all over everything. You are correct, I should have cleaned up better, and have in the past, but this time with band clamps wrapped around it I did not do as good a job as I should have. I did clean it up later at an increase of effort, but I got it well enough, I was just seeking a better/easier/more reliable method.

Re: Finishing/Loose tenon build?????

#10

Re: Finishing/Loose tenon build?????

David Bair

Titebond makes a liquid hide glue that's as easy to use as regular Titebond. Hide glue can be reversed fairly easily for mistakes and repairs. What sells it to me is that it allows a very long open time for those complex glue-ups.