Looking at a post and frame garage, roughly 30x60 with an 8' porch on one side, fully insulated with heated floors, 5" slab, one 16' door and three 10' doors on one side, and one 16' door on the river side (actually a big picture window out to the river). Bids coming in near $70 per square foot. Seems way high to me but I haven't built anything in a number of years.
...I'm thinking about it in the not too distant future. I guess the best way to vet your bids is to get some competitive offers. And, of course, the square foot price can vary a lot by the amenities and level of finish you're specifying.
If that is all sprayed on foam insulation, that is a high ticket item. Or are they framing up an interior wall to add fiberglas? Also all those doors will really add up. I don't think it is out of line.
Post and frame? I'm not exactly sure what that is. For my shop I built something I thought was called post and beam - 6x6 posts with double 2x10 beams around the top, trusses above, then filled in the (non load bearing) walls with 2x6 studs. Insulated with fiberglass, 1/2" osb plus 1/2" smartside outside plus 1/2" ply inside walls and ceilings, 1/2" osb, paper, and galvalum steel roof. I welded up an excess of rebar and poured 4" and 6" slab depending on the part on the building. Three indusrtial insulated roll-up doors, 3 steel double and 2 steel man exterior doors, several windows. Central HVAC for heat and cooling, good lighting inside and out.
If this building is somewhat equivalant to your plans my experience with the costs might be useful.
I have no idea what labor costs are. Since I did it all myself except for the concrete pour and the roof I had almost no labor cost. I did everything from the dirt work to forming for concrete to hauling materials, to the carpentry, to the wiring, both underground and building. (The building is about 1500 sq ft.)
I didn't keep up with every dollar but the best I can figure (from what I had saved up ahead of time) the total cost was about $30 a square foot. Since I did almost everything myself this represented only the material costs.
I spent over a year working all day nearly every day and then more time spread out over the next couple of years. Building this shop was SO much work that I can believe hiring it out would be at least double the material costs. In fact an architect friend looked at it and said it might have even cost 3 times what I spent.
It was a creative challenge to keep costs down and I can imagine a contractor would not go to those extremes, instead just hiring sub-contractors for everything like digging the trench for the wiring and installing the HVAC, passing those costs. Also, I shopped around and negotiated for deals on the lumber and hardware and I suspect the contractor would not take the time.
BTW, some advantges of building it myself besides lower cost were getting exactly what I wanted, no added costs for "change orders", no material waste, and I'm left with all the construction tools. The disadvantage is working with a crew of one (me) took a loooong time. The old adage "faster, better, cheaper: pick two" seems to hold here.
I see you are near Chicago if you are going to heat and cool this shop for more than a few years, it will be less costly to build a 2x structure once you add 5 year of utilities to the construction costs.
Understand pole building keep water out but do little to keep the cold outside air out.
I built my 24' x 40' shop about 8 years ago , with porch trusses, rolling doors on tracks, and a rear overhang for fire wood. But with a full poured concrete foundation. it cost me about $40,000 Canadian for the contractor. Then I did the insulation, interior lining and heat myself, I forget what that cost me. Considering you are talking U.S. Dollars, it sounds a bit high, but for a complete job and depending on the level of finish, it may not be too high. My brother-in-law just blew through $300,000 Canadian on a 3 car garage with a guest suite above it, all the costly upgrades included.
If I was going to have a proper slab, roof, details, etc... I would just stick frame the whole thing with 2x6s. Seems like there are all these supposedly cheaper, or more environmentally or self build friendly approaches to building, and they basically come down to different ways to doing the walls, which is the easiest, fastest, cheapest, and best aspect to 2xs in the first place. The problem with poles is that people think they are going to be cheap, but with the exception of some pretty unique architectural, or environmental uses, they are assumed to be cheap in the other sense. So you have a hyphenated building. Why not just have a building when it is all over.
HH is a guy I have had a few chats with on boats over the years. He has a creative mind, but this came through the mailbox the other day. Now I can see poles there.
http://epoxyworks.com/index.php/tag/hugh-horton/
Friends put up a house on telephone poles a while back. The poles are enormous, actually pressure treated to immersion levels, 40 bucks each, and they are about 40 feet long, they did a pole foundation for a few hundred, but once they were airborn the rest was studs.