Finish Notes
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
Hi Derek,
Couple comments on your finish options.
Ellis mentioned water-white solvent lacquer but I've not used it so no help there. I have, however, used a lot of waterborne finishes, both lacquers and polys.
Waterbornes, being water "based", will have a tendency to raise the grain on your wood surface, whether planed, scraped, or sanded. It's beneficial to seal the surface first with an NGR sealer like fresh-mixed shellac or a solvent-based sanding sealer that will prevent the water in the top coat from puckering the wood fibers.
I prefer using Ultra-pale (bleached) shellac in a 3/4lb cut as my sealer/tie coat. This is also important if you've added any colorant to the wood as waterborne finishes will tend to lift a bit of color off the surface and can run into adhesion issues if an oil stain is used. Bits of pigment, including dye particles, pulled into the clear waterborne coating will look muddy and kill the visual depth of the finish. The sealer coat prevents this problem, and will actually increase the visual depth of the top coat.
Given the very high quality of your work, I suggest you look for a higher end finish. The Varathane brand is ok, but can't compare with General Finish's pro lines like Enduro or HP Poly. These finishes are, however, made for spray application but can, with a bit of practice, be hand applied, and are capable of 100% burn-in like solvent lacquer.
HTH