Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

How to keep Sugar Maple white?

Posts

How to keep Sugar Maple white?

#1

How to keep Sugar Maple white?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I am shortly to embark on a kitchen re-build. That will involved new doors and drawer fronts. All bar one of the carcases can remain.

We are considering using Hard (Sugar) Maple because the figure is gentle and the wood is light in colour. I would like to keep it that way. I have not used Maple before, and hear that it can yellow over time. What finish will prevent this, or it is just not going to be doable?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: How to keep Sugar Maple white?

#2

Re: How to keep Sugar Maple white?

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

My DIL had the same request for a bathroom vanity I made. Although nothing will prevent the yellowing forever, I used a water based polyurethane finish. Specifically Varathane Diamond Floor Finish. It has remained nearly the same color.

Lee

Re: How to keep Sugar Maple white?

#3

Agree...

John in NM

Use a WB poly, just a few coats. Wood will stay light in color.

I have also seen maple venneer plywood get rust spots from WB poly - no idea where the steel particles were coming from but it was a real problem... presumably somewhere in the veneer manufacture. A coat of shellac first would have cured it, but I didn't know that back then.

Shellac might also keep it light in color. I have a tool handle I turned years ago and shellaced and it's about the same (though honestly I don't look at it with an eye to color much if ever - I can take a pic though if it will help).

Re: How to keep Sugar Maple white?

#4

Ellis Walentine

Couple things

Ellis Walentine

Hi Derek,

I think you'll enjoy working with hard maple. It takes a remarkable polish but can be somewhat difficult to plane, depending on how straight-grained your boards are. Also, the color of hard maple tends to be quite variable, often with darker heartwood, so you'll have to select carefully for all "white" boards. I usually prefer to use soft maple, which works a little easier and offers a greater selection of white color and often dramatic figure. Either way, maple is a good choice for that particular aesthetic you're after.

If you finish it with water-white lacquer or water-based polyurethane, as mentioned above, it will stay a tannish color for a longer time, although not really what I'd call white. If you want white, consider bleaching the finished faces with two-part bleach and then following up with your water white lacquer. I once built a dining table of white ash and bleached it this way. The white color remains to this day, over 30 years later.

Ellis

Re: How to keep Sugar Maple white?

#5

Re: Question, Ellis, and a comment

Hank Knight

Ellis,

I like your idea of bleaching maple white. Does curly maple keep its chatoyance after bleaching? I imagine that would be quite spectacular if the lacquer brings out the chatoyance after bleaching. I just finished a curly maple chest of drawers and have a fair amount of the stuff left over. I may give this a try.

With respect to your suggestion that Derek consider soft maple, I agree that it's nice to work, much nicer than hard maple. However, much of the soft maple I've used has a very bland, almost grayish appearance that I don't care for. I always end up staining it.

Hank

Re: How to keep Sugar Maple white?

#6

Ellis Walentine

Tellya the truth...

Ellis Walentine

...I have not checked into the chatoyance issue with maple. The ash that I bleached had a bit of figure and it came through fine. This would be an interesting exercise.

Regarding soft maple, some of the finest fiddleback and curly maple I'e used has been soft maple. For sure it's hit or miss, and soft maple is as often used as a secondary or even paint grade wood.

Ellis

Re: How to keep Sugar Maple white?

#7

Re: Thanks

Hank Knight

I may give it a try and report back.

Re: How to keep Sugar Maple white?

#8

Re: How to keep Sugar Maple white?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Lee. I looked up Varathane Diamond Floor Finish, and it is available in Australia. It looks promising.

How long ago did you use it on the bathroom cabinet?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: How to keep Sugar Maple white?

#9

Re: Tellya the truth...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Ellis.

The reason I am looking at hard maple is that the figure is quieter than soft maple. I cannot find an alternative to maple in Oz.

The kitchen fronts are currently Tasmanian Oak, which is a light wood and, when quarter sawn, is quite plain but coarse grained (Tassie Oak is a eucalyptus but works like European Oak). This is an armoire I built several years ago ..


As it can be seen, it tends to go a dark straw colour. Should I expect the same from Hard Maple? Tassie Oak is the only real alternative to Hard Maple (which needs to be imported) in colour, but lacks the latter's potential for finish.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: How to keep Sugar Maple white?

#10

Re: Tellya the truth...

Hank Knight

Derek,

As others have said, hard maple darkens over time and takes on an amber cast. Still, it remains much lighter than most of the common hardwoods here in the U.S. Oil based finishes foster the amber coloration. Water based finishes, a little less so. Early water based finishes tended to impart a little bluish cast to the coloration that looked terrible on maple, and people avoided using it for that reason. The finish manufacturers have corrected that and now water based finishes produce a much truer color. For a comparison, here is a recent photograph of an unfinished hard maple panel glue-up on my hard maple 10 year old bench top that was finished with tung oil. You can see that the bench top has aged to a light amber or straw color while the new maple panel is much lighter. The bench top would almost certainly be lighter had I finishd it with a water based finish.

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Chest%20of%20Drawers/image_zpsb8ocqz5g.jpeg.html][/URL]

Also, if you end up ordering hard maple for your project and you want "quiet" grain, be sure to communicate that to your supplier. Some hard maple can have very busy figure and it is much sought after by woodworkers.

Hank

Re: How to keep Sugar Maple white?

#11

Thanks Hank ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

.. I showed the photo to Lynndy and she liked both - the before and the after. The matured colouring is very similar to what we currently have.

That helped a lot.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: How to keep Sugar Maple white?

#12

Re: White Maple

Doug Wolf

Derek, Here's a picture of some Maple turned in 2011. The two pieces in the back were finished on the lathe with a mixture of 50% Sanding sealer and 50% Lacquer thinner. The piece in the foreground was finished with Watco Danish Oil "Natural" color. The pieces have stayed close to the same color for 5 years maybe just a hint of darkening on the Watco piece. The Sanding sealer mixture was wiped on with the lathe turning and then smoothed with a Scotchbrite pad and buffed with White Diamond and waxed. The outside of the large one is still the same color as the inside. No change.




Re: How to keep Sugar Maple white?

#13

Re: White Maple

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks for this Doug.

A question: I've never used sanding sealer before, mainly because it has not occurred to me to do so. What happens if one handplanes the surface (as I always do)? Will the surface from handplaning be burnished and resist the mixture you suggest?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: How to keep Sugar Maple white?

#14

Burnishing Maple

Doug Wolf

Derek, I'm the last person to ask about "hand" planning, I'm more of a "power" planning guy.

But I can speak about burnishing maple. Usually, well almost always, when I finish a piece on the lathe, I sand to 400 or 600 grit. Then I use Scotchbrite pads to burnish the surface. I start with a green colored pad which is about 4/0, then a gray pad then end with a white pad which is "non-abrasive". The lathe is running about 2000 rpm, depending on the diameter of the piece. When I take it off the lathe the surface is burnished but takes the finish well. I usually use Watco Danish Oil and it will raise the grain on the first coat so I knock it down with the white pad after it dries and recoat with Watco in a couple days.

For the finish using 50/50 sanding sealer I follow the same burnishing technique and apply the sealer with a paper towel rotating the lathe by hand. It dries in a few minutes and then I start with the gray pad to remove any build up on the surface and buff the finish left on the wood. I'm told that the sanding sealer is just lacquer with a higher amount of solids, but I don't know that for sure.

For finishing cabinets or other projects by hand you would have to experiment with the process. The sanding sealer does fill the pores of the wood, which is what its made for before a lacquer topcoat.

Re: How to keep Sugar Maple white?

#15

Finish Notes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Hi Derek,

Couple comments on your finish options.

Ellis mentioned water-white solvent lacquer but I've not used it so no help there. I have, however, used a lot of waterborne finishes, both lacquers and polys.

Waterbornes, being water "based", will have a tendency to raise the grain on your wood surface, whether planed, scraped, or sanded. It's beneficial to seal the surface first with an NGR sealer like fresh-mixed shellac or a solvent-based sanding sealer that will prevent the water in the top coat from puckering the wood fibers.

I prefer using Ultra-pale (bleached) shellac in a 3/4lb cut as my sealer/tie coat. This is also important if you've added any colorant to the wood as waterborne finishes will tend to lift a bit of color off the surface and can run into adhesion issues if an oil stain is used. Bits of pigment, including dye particles, pulled into the clear waterborne coating will look muddy and kill the visual depth of the finish. The sealer coat prevents this problem, and will actually increase the visual depth of the top coat.

Given the very high quality of your work, I suggest you look for a higher end finish. The Varathane brand is ok, but can't compare with General Finish's pro lines like Enduro or HP Poly. These finishes are, however, made for spray application but can, with a bit of practice, be hand applied, and are capable of 100% burn-in like solvent lacquer.

HTH

Re: How to keep Sugar Maple white?

#16

Re: Tellya the truth...

ian neuhaus

my kitchen was done in hard maple about 18 years ago. Th panels have matured to a colour close to that of Hank's bench.

Re: How to keep Sugar Maple white?

#18

North American Hard Maple