How to tell if Waterlox is good?
Barry Irby
I have a quart can of Waterlox I bought and never used. Its at least five years old. I want to finish a coffee table with it. How can I tell if it is good?
PS, Is there a date code?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
How to tell if Waterlox is good?
Barry Irby
I have a quart can of Waterlox I bought and never used. Its at least five years old. I want to finish a coffee table with it. How can I tell if it is good?
PS, Is there a date code?
Re: How to tell if Waterlox is good?
w. tindall
does it pour out of the can? if so good to use
Re: How to tell if Waterlox is good?
John in NM
Open the can, have some clean jars on hand for decanting and storing in smaller quantities.
If its good it will pour (I'm assuming this is their original sealer/finish) and be a thin, dark brown liquid. If it is bad it will be dark brown jelly.
Probably you could shake the can without opening and tell if its any good.
I've had good results storing Waterlox in jars for years after opening a can. The trick is to fill the jars right up to minimize air in it, and then use it up once its eventually opened. Not so hard for furniture projects, but almost impossible for the gunstocks and grips I used to make - I was always throwing out the last 1/2 to 1/4 of the smallest jars I regularly had.
I've only used their original sealer/finish and their marine finish. The marine finish does not seem to be as prone to gelling as the original, but it is pretty thick stuff and doesn't make the thin, smooth, glossy coat that the original does
Re: How to tell if Waterlox is good?
William Duffield
Shake the can. If you can feel it slosh, it's still good. If it doesn't slosh, if it feels like shaking Maple or Karo syrup, it's going bad.
Re: How to tell if Waterlox is good?
Justin Szeliga
I tried using propane from an old blowtorch as a cheap substitute for nitrogen to keep the oxygen off my Waterlox but it wasn't a very good idea. The propane would dissolve into the varnish & the can would crush from the pressure drop.
Re: How to tell if Waterlox is good?
William Duffield
If you want to crush the can to squeeze out the polymerizing oxygen, it's a lot easier, less expensive, and more controlled to use a bench vise instead of an inert or reactive gas. 
Re: How to tell if Waterlox is good?
Ellis Walentine
As others have said, fill small bottles to the very top and it'll keep for a long time. My father (RIP) put up some small containers of Waterlox and carefully dated them, back in 1985. The varnish is as good as new thirty years later. I also have a partial can that a buddy bought around the late 70s -- the old orange-and-white can, from when it was still called Waterlox "Transparent." The varnish still sloshes around in there, so I'm sure it's good. I'm saving it for something special, as the more recent iterations of Waterlox have changed the formula tremendously, though they've retained most of the drying and handling characteristics of the original.
Baby food jars are my go-to storage containers for opened cans of Waterlox.
Ellis
PS A side note: Although I am still a Waterlox fan and used it extensively for decades, I'm so put off by the price nowadays that I have switched over to General Finishes Seal-A-Cell for my wiping varnish jobs. It isn't quite as amber as Waterlox and doesn't dry as fast, but it is an excellent finish where wiping varnish is called for.