Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Wood Allergies

Posts

Wood Allergies

#1

Wood Allergies

Jon Percy

I started on a queen sized bed frame built in the arts & crafts style. In an effort to make it different from the norm I decided to use Brazilian Lacewood. Although the wood is a bit challenging things were going well until I woke up one Monday morning after working on the project for a month's worth of weekends (I am an amateur) with a rash on my neck, inside of my elbows and on my wrists. It seemed like a mild case of poison ivy.

The next weekend I was back in my shop and that Saturday night the rash returned, worse than before. It got to the point that I couldn't even walk into the shop without reacting to the sawdust in the shop.

I hired a professional crew to come in and completely clean out the shop. They removed the dust and used an ammonia based cleaning solution on everything. Things are better but I still react mildly when spending time in the shop. Obviously, no more work with that Lacewood!

I am curious if others have had adverse reactions to the woods they have worked with and what they did to sanitize their shop.

Re: Wood Allergies

#2

Re: Wood Allergies

John McGaw

I haven't heard of reactions to that particular wood but it is possible to have adverse reactions to any wood -- all it takes is for the body to become sensitized to the foreign proteins. I had a friend in Alaska become sensitized to 'aromatic cedar' which is actually juniper; he started putting up wainscotting in his basement using a stash of this wood and in short order couldn't go down the stairs without choking.

Most of the bad reactions I've heard of have been to exotics usually classified as "rosewood" and I had a bad reaction to one of them, a purplish South American variety, that left me gasping for air. Something as innocuous as mango wood (and mangoes of course) will prove troublesome since the tree is a relative to poison ivy. If you want to have a serious reaction, and most people seem to be sensitive to this, you need only get close to real Japanese lacquer which is actually tree sap just loaded with urushiol, the secret weapon that makes poison ivy so nasty.

When in doubt, wear a mask, cover up, and control the dust.

Re: Wood Allergies

#3

Re: Wood Allergies

Jon Percy

Thanks, John. Have you heard of any good strategies for detoxing a shop?

Re: Wood Allergies

#4

Re: Wood Allergies

John K Jordan

Yikes, I'm sorry to hear that. No respiratory problems? I've known a couple of people in the last few years become sensitized to wood dust and got asthma-like symptoms. They had to give up wood. One got interested in metal working.

I get a rash from eastern red cedar if the fine dust stays on my skin such as inside my elbows or under a watch when I used to wear a watch. Blowing the dust off and washing up after working helped. I wear long sleeves and a respirator when working with cocobolo which is well known to cause problems from the dust on skin and in the lungs.

I've had both of these issues for many years but so far they are not a problem and have not gotten worse. I do read that wood allergies can get progressively worse with continued exposure. You might be especially careful with breathing protection since a progression to respiratory issues could be a game stopper.

If your issue is with skin only, I wonder if long sleeves plus some kind of skin lotion would help. Or a drying powder? The issues I mentioned were always on skin that might have been slightly damp. In fact, now that I think of it, I haven't had an issue in my new shop with AC and lower humidity in the summer. ???

Perhaps consult with a dermatologist?

I saw some paper lab jackets used at my dentist's office with gentle elastic at the wrists and neck and I bought some from Amazon. These are light weight, not hot, and keep dust off my wrists, arms and neck.

JKJ

Re: Wood Allergies

#5

Re: Wood Allergies

John McGaw

I wouldn't know where to start with detoxing -- anybody who has seen my shop would agree. Problem is that dust could be anywhere. If you have rough concrete surfaces then sealing them might help but only if that is the source and determining that would be difficult. Is there a chance that the dust might be hiding in your DC filter and blowing it out around the atmosphere? Ducts? Hidden in machinery? I've never had any confidence in ambient air filters but I guess if one was large enough and powerful enough to change the shop air frequently and had really good HEPA filters then that might be a course of action. Dunno, really...

Re: Wood Allergies

#6

Re: Wood Allergies

jcousins

i had a slmilar xperience with makore - did several projects without a problem then suddenly even 1 cut on the table saw made my eyes water and my sinuses clamp down. did not detox the shop but can't use makore - which is a shame - it's a beautiful wood and finishes wonderfully.

jerry

Re: Wood Allergies

#7

Re: Wood Allergies

Dick Coers

I was thinking it's in the dust collector system as well, but you didn't give any details about your shop. Did the clean up crew also use a shop vac? Non HEPA filter vacs will continue to recirculate the really fine dust every time they are used. Since your symptoms seem related only to skin, consider using a barrier cream, but more importantly, do a hard scrubbing shower after being in the shop to clean it up. You'll likely have worse reactions every time as your body is getting more sensitive to the allergyn.

Re: Wood Allergies

#8

Re: Wood Allergies

William Duffield

I worked in a shop where everyone eventually developed a sensitivity to white lauan plywood. Every time we ran sheets of it through the table saw, everyone started coughing. Of course, it could have been the glue that was irritating us.

Sensitivity can also occur with the first exposure. I had a customer who was a professional woodworker. She once started on a project using a wood which was new to her, zebrano or Microberlinia brazzavillensis. The first day she cut it, she had a severe dermatological reaction. Her face swelled up so much she couldn't open her eyes.

Re: Wood Allergies

#9

Re: Wood Allergies

Barry Irby

Do some research on the Web. Check out the Forest Products Laboratory and EPA. I used to have a chart that listed various woods and their "potency". Some were minor irritants, some dermatological, some respiratory and can be deadly. I looked in my book marks and can't find the chart. It was not all that useful because so many woods are sold under many made up names and we may not know its scientific name.

It generally does not get better. You don't develop an immunity. You become more and more sensitive. I think the advice about the HEPA vac is correct. My DC exhausts outside the shop so I don't have to worry much about the fines floating around.

Re: Wood Allergies

#10

Re: Wood Allergies

Jon Percy

Thanks for the barrier cream advice. What is that and are there some generally available brands? BTW, the crew did use a shop vac to clean out much of the dust in the shop. I also replaced the bags on my dust collector and the filters on my AC and on my Jet air filtrator. Has anyone had any luck with a cure from the medical community?

Re: Wood Allergies

#11

Re: Wood Allergies

Hank Knight

Barry is right, once a person develops an allergic sensitivity to a sensitizer like a specific kind of wood, it doesn't get better; it only gets worse with continued exposure. I started having severe sinus headaches after using power tools like saws and planers. I don't think it was a wood allergy, because it happened every time, regardless of the kind of wood I was working with. I decided to install a good dust collector and did my research to decide what to buy. I bought and installed a Clear Vue cyclone because, at the time, it had the best numbers for capturing the fine dust particles that are the real health problem for woodworkers. It did the trick. I no longer get headaches when I use my power tools - BIG relief!

I found in my research that a properly designed cyclone does a much more efficient job at capturing fine dust particles than the common bag-type dust collectors that many hobbyest use. Some of those actually do a good job of dispensing the fine dust back into the workshop atmosphere after separating and capturing the big chips, which do not pose a health risk.

If the OP has an advanced sensitivity to a particular wood species, I don't know that it's possible to detox his workshop completely without using extraordinary means. The slightest contact with the sensitizer will produce an allergic reaction, so the problem will remain unless he removes ALL the dust or encapsulates it in a manner that will prevent his coming into contact with it. Short of that, the place I would begin to make my workshop habitable and functional again is the dust collection system. I would make sure it was part of the solution rather than part of the problem.

Re: Wood Allergies

#12

Barrier cream

Dick Coers

You can buy barrier cream on line of course, but check your local auto supply, commercial house paint store, and for maybe a less robust cream, the cosmetic counter. I used to put it on my hands before working on the car. Any grease I got on my hands washed off very easily. Some house painters use it so the paint cleans off more easily.

Long sleeve shirts buttoned at the neck, or tyvek overalls will also help you for a while. Quite often, mixing sweat and dust kick up the reaction. So keeping the dust out of the folds in you skin will help.

If all you had were stock bags on your dust collector, throw them away and get new 1 micro bags. The pores of those old bags are filled with that dust and every time you turn on the dust collector and they pop open, you just filled the shop with the dust you are sensitive to again! Hopefully you have some windows in your shop, open them all, put in a big as* window fan, and have someone else go through you shop with an leaf blower about 10 times. You still have that dust everywhere if the place was only cleaned with a cheap shop vac!!!!!!

Re: Wood Allergies

#13

Re: Wood Allergies

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

If you have any doubts about a wood, take a Band-Aid, put some knife scrapings of the wood on the pad, put it on your arm. Leave it for a couple of days, redness under the pad, YOU ARE sensitive!

Re: Wood Allergies

#14

Re: Wood Allergies

Brian Holcombe

I've all but stopped using rosewoods outside of handful of simple projects using small bits of lumber.

I pretty much won't use cocobolo...at all.

No sense in taking on projects using lumber that will eventually cause me to not be able to work.

I am using Honduran mahogany at the moment and probably never will again, beautiful lumber but the same issue with it as some other woods in that it is an irritant for me.

I use a HEPA vac, and FWIW after getting a heartache everyday for a month or two I pinpointed the issue being that I needed to change the filter much more often than I had been.

My basement shop needs to be kept extremely clean because the dust has no where to escape to. I am also an idiot for keeping a rug in the shop, but it is nice on the furniture (no damage when moving things around in the shop).

Re: Wood Allergies

#15

Exotics only

CJ in MPLS

I've not had problems with north american hardwoods (oak, ash, maple, etc.), but rosewood/cocobolo will definitely get my nose running and make my eyes water. Wenge is really bad for me. So much so that I have an unfinished box in the shop this is more than 10 years old. Runny nose, coughing, red eyes . . . I'm actually a bit concerned about what might happen if I ever get stupid enough to mess with that box. On a related note, why the hell would an otherwise rational (in my opinion) person keep something like this around for so long?

Re: Wood Allergies

#16

You think the South American woodworkers

Dick Coers

will react to North American hardwoods? LOL I suspect those rain forest hardwoods have developed those toxins to remain alive with all the insects and fungi in that kind of climate.

Re: Wood Allergies

#17

Re: Wood Allergies *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Hi Jon,

Sorry to hear of your experience with lacewood.

While this is not much help to your situation others might find it useful.

Bob in NJ


http://www.wood-database.com/wood-articles/wood-allergies-and-toxicity/