Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

How can I tell cedar from PT pine?

Posts

How can I tell cedar from PT pine?

#1

How can I tell cedar from PT pine?

Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)

I got some pickets from an old weathered fence but I don't know if it's Cedar or PT Pine. If it's Cedar I can clean it up and use it in the shop or burn the pieces I can't use. If it's PT I'll just have to dump it. Is there any way to tell the difference?

Re: How can I tell cedar from PT pine?

#2

Cut n' Sniff

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Cedar is soft, cuts easily, and smells like pencils.

Treated pine doesn't. ;)

Re: How can I tell cedar from PT pine?

#3

Re: Cut n' Sniff

Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)

I'll give that a try. I always hated the smell of pencil shavings when emptying the sharpener. Must be the graphite though because cedar does smell pretty good when I cut it in the shop.

Re: How can I tell cedar from PT pine?

#4

Re: Cut n' Sniff

John K Jordan

A clean cut on a transverse surface (crosscut) should show more distinct bands of early and latewood on southern yellow pine (often used for pressure treated wood).

Eastern Red Cedar

http://www.wood-database.com/wp-content/uploads/aromatic-red-cedar-endgrain.jpg

Southern yellow pine: virginia pine

http://www.wood-database.com/wp-content/uploads/virginia-pine-endgrain.jpg

ERC can be easily shaved with a sharp knife. Once you get past the weathered surface SYP is harder and won't cut so smoothly.

Also, ERC, besides the pleasant aromatic smell, should have a reddish color inside even if old.

How old do you guess the fence is? Did it rot below the ground?

Fences were also commonly made from black locust, osage orange, and american chestnut. Locust and osage will last a long time but PT will often rot away below ground before long. If the wood is very hard, it might be locust or osage. The red heart of cedar seems to last a long time in the ground. My barn is probably 80-100 years old and the posts made from cedar trees are still solid.

JKJ