Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

Posts

Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

#1

Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

Brian Holcombe

Good morning! The butler's desk is nearing completion, but there are a few details left to finish, the primary one which has been lingering in my mind for quite a while is the stay for the desktop. While historical examples leave it out, I've been nervous that the desk could be damaged by opening it and letting it flop down without the supporting drawer extended.

In order to counter that I've begun building a stay out of 360 brass using a Bridgeport mill and some basic hand tools.

https://brianholcombewoodworker.com/2016/08/25/adventures-in-making-hardware/

Click the above link to see the full story.




Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

#2

Nice!!

John K Jordan

Brian, Thanks for posting this. I read the complete story. The ability to make my own new and repair parts (and enough space in the new shop!) finally led me to get a mill and metal lathe. I ended up with two of each but that's another story...

I don't quite understand how the mechanism will work in the desk but I'll stay tuned to your blog. Please post here again when you update.

Brass is wonderful to work with. I browse the local metals recycling place and occasionally find good brass at scrap prices. Otherwise I usually buy from Online Metals. What do you use for a finish on brass?

Aluminum is a lot cheaper and great for many things. The recycler keeps a small dumpster for aluminum chunks and I go diving there regularly. A friend of mine started anodizing his aluminum parts and they look fantastic - I plan to learn how to do that.

Do you ever use thin parallels to align stock in the vise for milling? It seems that would be quicker and more accurate than using a dial indicator on the top but I never tried that method myself. The parallels also insure the machined top face will end up parallel to the bottom. I do align the vise first with a dial test indicator.

JKJ

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

#3

Re: Nice!!

Brian Holcombe

Thanks John!

...That would require having parallel bars :D My machine shop setup is fairly basic at this point since it is at my father's shop.

We've been talking about moving it to my house, which will allow me more control over the setup and allow me to horde tools which is what I'm best at, but my wife is not thrilled at the idea of my having both the garage and basement to myself.

At the moment what I do is cut a reference face then clamp off that reference face where possible.

Scrap brass is a good idea, for this project which is a commissioned piece I thought it best to stick with new material. I've also been kicking around the idea of using copper, but knowing that I'll need to basically make every part.

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

#4

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's D

Gary Smyth

Beautiful work. Access to the correct machinery and the talent to use them is a goal I’m sure we all hope to achieve. Done the right way. Your work is exceptional. Congrats.

I’m not in the group that has that access (I only wish), but for some workers perhaps an alternative that could serve in some applications. When not finding the perfect hardware but needing a stay to keep a top from opening too far or dropping beyond a desired limit, like a small display case or jewelry box where the screws for hinges are small and close to an edge, I use chain necklaces. They were designed to look good, and it can be a pleasant surprise when opening the container. I also use earing parts, broach hinges and pins, and wood, metal and mineral beads. Sometimes there even is gold in them. End attachment can be a problem, but are more easily fashioned than to mill your own from solid stock. Jewelry components are called "findings" and catalogs abound. Something that works can nearly always be found. Flea markets have dozens of choices for chains, some as long as 36”, fairly heavy, and rarely over $3 each.

Some planning needs done to keep the chain from chafing the internal sides of a container, testing needs to be done to be sure the collapsed chain doesn’t kink or knot up when opening, and a loose chain needs to have a place to go when the lid is closed, but for light weight use, it’s a fix.

Inexpensive, lots of choices, can be elegant in a sort of way, a stop chain may help solve a problem if you can’t find a stay in a catalog or make one custom.

I much prefer the custom though!


Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

#5

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's D

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Gary!

You offer a fine solution, but one that I thought about but ultimately decided against. There were many considerations and one of them being that not only would the chain need to be strong enough to prevent damage in the event that the desk were flopped open, but also that the screws would remain intact. I feel that two screws spanning 2.5" with a mounting point located in the center would allow that event to happen without damage. Also on the inside of the case the mortise will help to prevent such damage there.

Also I was concerned that it would get caught between the door and case, damaging both of them.

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

#6

1st & Goal

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Brian,

With such a nice piece of hardware I'd anticipate that the user will dispense with the drawer support. In that scenario using a single stop will torque the door/desk and stress the hinges unless you make two (2) of those braces, one on each side.

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

#7

Re: 1st & Goal

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This is a tiny door.

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

#8

Define Tiny

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

It comprises more than 60% of the front of the desk and will carry weight when in use.

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

#9

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's D

William Duffield

That vise is probably worth more than all the machine tools in my shop :D

It's one thing to vacuum sawdust out of your shop's carpet, but quite another to clean up metal chips. :D

Back in the "good old days," fancy drop front desks were equipped with a coupling between the drop front and the loafers, so when the front is opened the loafers automatically extend, and when the door is closed, the loafers retract. I can't find a plan for it right now, but I'm sure I've seen one somewhere, and I'll keep looking. The advantage is that the support hardware doesn't support the weight of the door, books, typewriter, etc. There aren't many old desk fronts that have not been repaired due to either someone not pulling out the loafers or overloading the support hardware.

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

#10

Re: 1st & Goal

Brian Holcombe

The deterrent from using two is that it will disrupt normal use, such as if one were to use the sliding tray for a mouse, for instance.

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

#11

Re: 1st & Goal

Brian Holcombe

What it lacks in size, it makes up in confidence.

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

#12

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's D

Brian Holcombe

Hah, I do love that vise.

Thank you, William, if you do come across some info on the loafers I'd love to take a look at that.

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

#13

Top Edge

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

of the support drawer needs felt (or soft vinyl) bumper spots to prevent damage line in the face of the door by rubbing and vibration.

;)

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

#14

Re: Top Edge

Brian Holcombe

Absolutely, i've been planning something for that. :D

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

#15

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's D

Brian Holcombe

I found photos of the mechanism. Maybe there are two spellings but they seemed to be commonly referred to as lopers?

The mechanism is slick, but I need the drawer to be able to be manually extended to the full opening when so desired, a mechanism which operates along with the desktop would be a nice addition but too impractical to include at this stage.

The fact that I have a solo stay in mind combined with the drawer immediately underneath should encourage proper use and I know the end user will in fact always use the desk properly so I'm already building in redundancy for use of a second uninformed user on down the line. I'm leaving them some breadcrumbs already. :D

I came across one historic example that had lived for 200+ years and probably 5 years or so being fondled by the public, it had zero redundancies and remained undamaged so it was encouraging that there is a general sense of how to approach this type of desk.

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

#16

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's D

William Duffield

I should have suspected I had something wrong when Google showed me a page full of shoes. :D

And, I should have gone back and reanalyzed your design before I even made the suggestion. I had forgotten that you were using the drawer for support instead of building in separate lopers that move independently from the drawer.

Figuring out the linkage required, including attachment points and arm lengths, would not be a trivial problem. I would approach it with a full size drawing and a beam compass (or maybe two).

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's Desk

#17

Re: Adventures in Making Hardware - The Butler's D

Brian Holcombe

It's a cool way to do it so I will certainly keep that in mind for future projects, and appreciate that you brought it up.