What Reeally is an "In The Wood Finish"
don stephan
This is a sincere question, not intended to cause battle lines but . . .
Often I've seen the term "in the wood finish" but never a definition. This morning I came across "Think Finish First" by Jeff Jewitt in Fine Woodworking #141 (March/April 2000) pages 58-63 which inspired finally posting this thread.
From the article "Both linseed and tung oils are penetrating finishes, which means they penetrate the fibers of the wood and harden. . . . These oils are usually not built up with enough coats to form a surface film, like that of varnish or lacquer, because the film is too soft."
When linseed oil was more popular as a finish, application instructions often included something like "once a day for a week, once a week for a month, once a month for a year, once a enough year for life." Some people may never have applied enough coats to do so, but with enough applications linseed oil and tung oil can build to make a cured film on top of the wood. The first coat still penetrated into the wood, but when it builds to include a cured film on top of the wood, is it no longer an "in the wood finish?"
I don't have experience with poly finishes, but I have used P&L 38 alkyd varnish often the last few years, both as an oil-varnish blend mixed with mineral spirits and boiled linseed oil, and as a wiping varnish thinned 50-50 with mineral spirits. Applied as a wiping varnish, the varnish "warms" or darkens the wood almost as much as straight boiled linseed oil, and I can't feel a tactile difference on the wood between one coat of each after a couple days, maybe after two or three coats of each. Certainly, after 4 or 5 coats of this wiping varnish mix, I can feel a building film, but the pores of oak and ash certainly are not fully filled, perhaps not even the pores of a finer wood like Bradford pear.
Later in the article "Oil and oil-based varnish, solvent-based lacquer and shellac all deepen the color of the wood and increase surface luster the most. The finishes wet the cells of the wood, penetrating into the surface. Other film finishes - notably water-based finishes and some catalyzed lacquers - tend to lie on the surface. By not penetrating it as much, they make the wood appear lighter in color."
Some comments I've seen and heard over the years seem to suggest that only [boiled] linseed oil, tung oil, and commercial products such as Tung Oil Finish and Danish Oil can produce an "in the wood" finish. But if, as said in the article by a well respected finish authority, oil, oil-based varnish, and shellac all penetrate the wood, then is an "in the wood" finish dependent not only on the finish itself but also the final thickness of the finish?
Why is this worth a thread? Becoming a better woodworker is a life-long education and skill development pursuit, and it would be nice to think readers of this and other forums pay attention to and learn from what is posted. It would also be nice to think becoming a better woodworker depends on learning to evaluate information and apply learning rather than simply memorize summary statements that may or may not present a complete picture. If there is more to determining whether a finish is "in the wood" should additional explanation be included so that a novice reading a post really understands the meaning of "in the wood?"
I'm starting this thread because I do not have a clear understanding of what makes an "in the wood finish" and would like to continue learning and becoming a better woodworker.



