Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

The shrinking WWing Magazines

Posts

The shrinking WWing Magazines

#1

The shrinking WWing Magazines

charlie belden

So I'm packing up a bunch of old WWing magazines

Fine Woodworking

Woodworker West

Woodworkers Journal

American Woodworker

Furniture (British)

Woodwork

Popular Woodworking

Woodsmith

Wood

Practical Woodworking

Tradtional Woodworking

The Woodworker

Woodworking

Woodworkers Journal

Workbench

Shop Notes

Woodcraft Magazine

Been a while since I bought a WWing magazine. How many of the ones on this list are still around?

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#2

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

Dave's Not Here

A Google search for woodworking magazines should give you the answer you're looking for.

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#3

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

Larry Edinger

Over Half.

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#4

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

Bill Howatt

Which, incidentally, is the same mechanism that has caused the shrinkage.

Bill

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#5

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

Larry

What do you mean by that?

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#6

The access...

Brian Roberts

to info via the internet has caused the loss of print media.

Don't you think that's what he meant?

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#7

Re: The access...

Bill Howatt

That's exactly what I meant. People want to know how to make a joint, item, finish, etc so just fire up Google or its equivalent as recommended to find which magazines are still around. You even can find videos, some admittedly of dubious quality, demonstrating the process.

I used to subscribe to various magazines but don't anymore. Part of the problem was going through them looking for something I thought I'd seen a while ago and not finding it or finding it wasn't what I remembered.

All of print media is feeling the pinch.

of course there is still value in a printed magazine it just means they aren't as relevant as they used to be and the future is not in their favor.

Bill

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#8

Re: The access...

Larry

I get all my magazine in printed form. I don't read them online, but that's just me.

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#9

Re: The access...

AZ in Colorado Springs

No, that's not just you. It's at least both of us. (I do get a great deal out of woodcentral on line, but not magazines on line.) My observation about the printed magazines is that they seem to closely follow each other, so I have let most of my subscriptions lapse.

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#10

TV shows vs Movies

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I still subscribe to FWW and PopWood. If I was to let one go, it would be FWW. Either the level the articles are aimed at has changed, or I have. I think both.

One has a choice these days of paper or download, to turn real pages or to swipe the screen. When I read in bed I prefer a "real" magazine. It is a luxuriant experience to fold a page back, wack the magazine on the bedclothes to get the desired crease in the page, and then scrunch it at the ideal angle to read. There is a tactile feel missing from an iPad. For some reason my wife objects to the sound of pages being tuned, since I appear to do this this too energetically for her. :)

I have FWW and PW on my iPad. I especially love delving into the older FWW mags for the articles. I do not think that they are written any better than the current offerings - they are certainly not as well illustrated - but there is a sense of the classic about them. These are the articles I learned from. They are like old friends. I read and re-read them. Having the archives on my iPad is simply the best companion on long plane trips, which I do a few times each year.

I love forums such as WoodCentral, but reading a good magazine article or a book is a different experience, and they cannot be compared. Reading a forum is like watching one episode of a TV series. You need to return to watch what happens next. Reading a magazine is like watching a movie, where you get to see it start and how it ends. Videos are different again. I much prefer to watch someone demonstrate a technique than read about it. However, it is not always possible to find the time to do so, and it is a more solitary activity if others in the family do not share your passion for watching a secret dovetail joint being slowly pared into shape. I will keep buying mags as long as the articles are interesting and informative.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#11

Re: TV shows vs Movies

Larry

I like to older FFW when they had Articles on how to build Tools. Like one time they had a Article on how to build a wide belt sander.

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#12

Re: TV shows vs Movies

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Larry, I wonder why they do not do articles like that any more? I suspect it is because the readership has changed. No longer does one have to do as much DIY with machines as it is possible to simply go out and purchase what you need, and there are enough articles on restoring vintage versions. Perhaps the readership today lack the patience, the frustration tolerance, to take the time to build like that. It is increasingly a world of instant gratification, with a throw away mentality. It would be good to reverse this trend. Guys like Chris Schwarz appear to be trying.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#13

Re: TV shows vs Movies

CharlieL

There are getting to be less people that can afford to retire and have the free time on their hands for hobbies. Plus it appears to be a Walmart and Harbor Freight society. This country has been less then kind to blue collar workers. Made in the USA doesn't seem to mean much anymore. What a shame.

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#14

Re: TV shows vs Movies

TomD

"Larry, I wonder why they do not do articles like that any more? I suspect it is because the readership has changed."

I think it does beg the question of whomever made that stuff in the first place. I found those articles fascinating, and wished I could make those tools. Then along came the Dollar Store tools from Taiwan, and there was no point, though their decision to copy really heavy in physical weight machinery is still open to challenge. But you have to ask yourself who could make say the table saw, who needed a table saw, and to boot was a master machinist, with a full woodshop. I had a low paying job at the time, and I could not have taken the time off from work to track down the guy who would have made the metal parts. It would have cost me from, my scant 2 weeks of vacation. It was designed by a guy who was a college wood shop guy, or something. You could make one at MIT I guess in a proto lab.

"It is increasingly a world of instant gratification, with a throw away mentality. It would be good to reverse this trend."

I think there are more people doing this stuff than ever in the history of time, but there just aren't magazines that cater to it. Those articles in the early FWW were written by heavyweight guys. Now the average article in FWW looks like a youtube video on dial-up, with a lot of pictures. The guys that write that stuff these days, don't even know the back issues.

"Guys like Chris Schwarz appear to be trying."

Depends on perspective, he is heavily into the dumbing down of the legacy from the 70s, but dumbing up from the Handy Family as was in the Pop Mechanics of the day. I guess we couldn't keep Scott Landis interested for ever.

If you want machines, then the guy is Matthias Wandel.

https://www.youtube.com/user/Matthiaswandel

Not the inheritor of the FWW "Fine" mantle but he makes stuff you can make without a machine shop, so that is a step forward. He is so basic, and so fast. The background shows. He is ballsy too, the drill driven scaffold is the kind of thing when you mix the shop with the outdoorsman, it seems to me.

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#15

Re: TV shows vs Movies *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tom

We are all familiar with the Black & Decker Workmate, which was the brainchild of Ron Hickman. This entered production in 1973. Hands up all those here who do not have a Workmate, or a copy.

The mid 70's seem to have been a time when there was this creative thinking going on. Fine Woodworking Magazine started in 1975 (when the articles of the machines in question were included in the publications).

In 1975 George Lewin, then a 25-year old journalist living in Melbourne, invented the original Triton saw bench, while struggling with his first woodwork project since schooldays, a coffee table.


The Triton, which is still available today (and now produced in the UK, no longer Australia), and uses a circular saw and a router to create a tablesaw/router table/cut-off saw.

30+ years ago, that is what I aspired to. I think that my mindset at the time was directed more towards basic handyman tools that could be modified or adapted for use in building furniture or renovating the home. I could not afford one at the time, and so my first "tablesaw" was a circular saw screwed through a few layers of MDF, and a shopmade fence. I was happy as Larry (see below).

Over the years I have been fortunate to afford decent powertools. My "inventive" urges have been transferred to handtools, and I have built enough of every conceivable type - saws, a wide range of planes, chisels - to equip a shop. I do this from an urge to create. However there are many who continue the tradition of building tools since they would not accept buying them on principle. The spirit lives on.

Regards from Perth

Derek


Happy as Larry

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#16

Re: The access...

Bill Howatt

I was thinking more of Googling around to find out how to do/make something rather than reading a whole magazine online.

I've never been a person to take an plan from a magazine to build it. But, for example, I might want to find out how to make a mortise and tenon joint or what is the best way to apply a finish.

As for online magazine reading, I suspect the younger generations will have fewer problems with it. After looking at a phone screen all day, a 24" monitor would look quite legible.

Bill

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#17

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

Bob Lang

The publishing industry, both for books and magazines has seen a tremendous impact from the growth of the internet and Amazon. It is now tough to find anyone in the industry who places any value on the quality of the content within a book or magazine or who even knows the difference between good information and fluff.

When Fine Woodworking first appeared, the market was driven by information, books and magazine articles were written by folks with real world experience, and the editors had both woodworking and editorial experience. The early years of Fine and American Woodworker produced great content because there wasn't much difference between the audience and the content producers.

But that early success has been followed by a long, steady and downward spiral. The focus changed from providing an audience with good information to repeating what sold. In the publishing industry people with knowledge of the craft weren't as valuable as people with knowledge of the "business". Unfortunately for those of us in the audience most of the business decisions that were made favor a formulaic commodity approach and publishers and editors believe that their formula is sacred. They don't realize that the "formula" was valuable content that was relevant to the audience.

The growth of the internet made print publications less relevant and less of a value to the audience. Amazon made tons of previously hard to find information readily available at low cost. The publishing industry's response was to stick to the formula and cut costs, and those decisions have led to books and magazines becoming even less relevant and less of a value to the end user. Along the way, the distance between the people running things and the audience has grown larger and larger. The few remaining magazines are poor imitations of their former selves, run by people who they are good at following the formula and passing along orders from above, not because they are knowledgeable about the craft.

Woodworking magazines were at their best when they were produced by people deeply involved in woodworking. That isn't the case today. Perhaps the worst part of this is that knowledgeable people aren't writing down what they know and sharing it with the coming generation.

Bob Lang

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#18

Re: The shrinking WWneting Magazines

Hal

Amen! Case in point..Popular

Amen! Case in point..PopularWW. Was an excellent magazine when the likes of Bob Lang and Glen Huey (and for awhile later on Chuck Bender) were writing. And Christopher Schwarz for that matter. The rather abrupt departure of the first three never mentioned although one can hardly doubt the reason was $$. I was looking thru some back issues just yesterday and noted 96 pages..now it's typically around 52 I think and my current issue had 2 articles that were basically a repeat of subjects a few years back. Yes, we woodworkers do have memories. Hal

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#19

Re: The shrinking WWneting Magazines

Bob Lang

Are you saying you're not happy with the "smaller, more convenient package"?

Bob Lang

Re: The shrinking WWing Magazines

#20

Re: The shrinking WWneting Magazines

Hal

The new compact easy to handle version is just fine considering the present state of the magazine. Don't know what they would find to fill up another 40 pages.