Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Time for a new shop vac...recommendations?

Posts

Time for a new shop vac...recommendations?

#1

Time for a new shop vac...recommendations?

Grant Smith

My old Genie shop vac that I purchased back in the late eighties while stationed in the Philippines has finally bitten the dust. The motor is screaming at me like it is crying uncle. Tired of its loudness anyway. Time for a new one.

I mostly don't like the new ones available. Ones I see have the following flaws:

-Short hose and/or non-standard hose (There's one good thing about standards: If you don't like one, there are plenty of others to choose from).

-Unnecessarily loud.

-No seal around the top of the drum resulting in more noise and less suction

-Cheap build quality, tippiness, no place to wind cord and hose.

-Over hyped motor ratings (There's 1.5hp in the average 15A outlet, not 6 like some vacuums claim by using HP at stall)

-Tiny wheels that won't roll or swivel easily

So my search begins for a worthy candidate. I decided to begin here in the virtual realm for recommendations. Life is too short to make all of your own mistakes. I do already have a Fein Turbo II which is currently used exclusively for dust pickup from my sanders. Looking here for the utility machine for general cleanup and occasional wet use. HEPA capable will be a prerequisite. I am not averse to spending appropriately for quality and the promise of longevity.

Recommendations?

Thanks in advance,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Time for a new shop vac...recommendations?

#2

Re: Time for a new shop vac...recommendations?

Barry Irby

This will be interesting for me also. I really can't help but I want some advice also.

I had a Sears monster that screamed like a banshee and lasted about thirty years. A friend gave me a decrepit Rigid that I put through the ER and used it until somebody stole it in the Great Tool Robbery. I replaced it with another Rigid. (Slow learner). I also had a ShopVac door buster special from Lowes. (right when you thought it couldn't get worse...) It died young.

I'm still using the Rigid and have added one of the accessory switches that turns it on and off with the tool and have adapted it to my Auction Bargain Festools and I am liking the switch. Just can't bring myself to spring for a Fien or Festool or....

You have a Fien, why not another????

Re: Time for a new shop vac...recommendations?

#3

Re: Time for a new shop vac...recommendations?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Grant

For several years I have had the Fein Dustex 25. This is mid range in expensiveness. It is powerful and rated as the quietest vacuum when I purchased it. Importantly, it has variable suction and automatic on-off for a router or sander. When I bought it, it did not come with a Hepa filter, which I added. I gather this is now standard.

My dislikes with the machine are the shape, which is roundish and makes it harder to park. It is also much noisier than I had expected, but not as loud as those that cost less. You still need hearing protection but the neighbours and family will not hear it.

About a year ago, the electronics board on the Fein decided to blow up, and the repair bill was about half the price of a new machine. So I chose instead to get a new machine (see ... two reviews for the price of one! :) )

The new machine is a Festool CT26E. This is at the expensive end of the range. It is worth it to me. What a great machine! Silent, very powerful, automatic on-off, and variable speed. Hepa filter. And compact. I have added the long-life cloth vacuum bag, which replaces the paper bag.

Dislikes: the expensive hoses. It comes standard with a 27mm diameter hose, which works well with my Elu routers. I think I would have preferred a 36mm hose, which is standard on the Fein. I did add a 50mm hose to connect it to a Dust Commander. The Festool hoses are, however, anti-static.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Time for a new shop vac...recommendations?

#4

Re: Time for a new shop vac...recommendations?

CharlieL

I have a older WAP brand shop vac. Alto I believe is the brand name now. It is fairly quiet, has a auto electrical outlet, and for pneumatic also, and has a place for cord storage. The vacuum shape is square. It's been a good unit.

Re: Time for a new shop vac...recommendations?

#5

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Time for a new shop vac...recommendations?

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

The Ridgid 16 Gallon really sucks, but it's really noisy, too.

My preference is the Fein Turbo II or Turbo III. They're pricey, but they perform great, are about as quiet as a vac can be, and are variable speed for use with sanders, etc.

I wore out a Turbo II (it took 20 years!), and now have a Turbo III.

Re: Time for a new shop vac...recommendations?

#6

Festool

Jerry Gibbs

My friend is giddy about his Festool vac. Never thought I would see him excited about a vacuum cleaner. His shop has never been this clean for this long either.

Re: Time for a new shop vac...recommendations?

#7

Re: Festool

John Veerkamp

Second Festool

Re: Time for a new shop vac...recommendations?

#8

Re: Festool

William Duffield

Ditto! If you care about your lungs and your ears, not to mention the number of wasted steps you will save while connecting and disconnecting and moving around the vac and tools (electric and hoses), Festool CTs make a lot of sense.

Re: Time for a new shop vac...recommendations?

#9

Re: Time for a new shop vac...recommendations?

William Duffield

There are advantages to the Fein Turbos' round shape and wheel positions. It makes it a lot easier to pull around the shop by the cord or hose without it getting hung up on everything it gets near.

Regarding wheels, whatever vac you are considering, try it out. If its wheels won't roll over its own power cord, without tugging or lifting, reject it.

A shop vac that trips and falls over, or gets hung up at every corner, or whose hose is so stiff it swings the light-weight, top-heavy vac around is useless.

I've used the automatic mode switch on the Fein and Festools. They are both very convenient. I also have one of the third party controls that you plug into the wall and plug both the shopvac and the tool into. That setup is much less convenient to use, to the point of extreme annoyance and inefficiency, compared to the Fein and Festool.

Compared to the other screamers out there, both the Fein and Festool are very quiet. The Fein might be a little quieter. The Festools have higher air flow values (135 CFM, IIRC).

Oneida makes a Dust Deputy (cyclone) designed specifically to fit the Festool CTs. It latches to the top of the CT, or to the top of a Systainer that is in turn latched to the top of the CT. This is almost as mobile as the CT by itself, and reduces the dust bag cost to easily manageable values. With the Fein or other clumsy shop vacs, you need to carry the cyclone (attached to the top of a 5 gallon can) around separately, usually while tethered to the vac and the tool. This requires three hands, or a shop-built cart to hold both.

Using the Festool CTs with Festool tools, especially if you are using multiple tools on the same job, with the dust connection and the power connection at the same place, is much more convenient that other systems (or lack of systems) where the connections may be half the way across the shop from each other.