Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

RIDGID 14 in. Band Saw Model No. BS14002

Posts

RIDGID 14 in. Band Saw Model No. BS14002

#1

RIDGID 14 in. Band Saw Model No. BS14002

Doug Wolf

This is my second broken UPPER SHAFT/HINGE WHEEL ASM on my RIDGID 14 in. Band Saw Model No. BS14002 that I bought in 2007. It broke the first time in 2009 and Rigid replaced the part and it just broke again and they are shipping me another replacement part. I'm glad I got the lifetime warranty when I registered it. I'm only running a 3/8" blade and it's not over tensioned. I use my 20" Grizzly for the heavy duty cutting.

2009

2016

My question is: Am I the only one with this problem as a I searched the forum and didn't find any mention of it.

I'm thinking of another 14" band saw to replace this one. Any suggestions?

Re: RIDGID 14 in. Band Saw Model No. BS14002

#2

Re: RIDGID 14 in. Band Saw Model No. BS14002

Dick Coers

You may not think you are over tensioning it, but you sure are exceeding what it was designed for. I think the engineers and you have different theories of blade tensioning numbers.

Re: RIDGID 14 in. Band Saw Model No. BS14002

#3

Broken Casting Picture

Doug Wolf

Thanks for your suggestion Dick, but after seeing both broken castings I'm leaning toward inferior metal in the casting.



There are some large voids or air bubbles in the casting.

I saw on Amazon reviews that 3 reviewers out of 6 had the same part break.

Re: RIDGID 14 in. Band Saw Model No. BS14002

#4

Kneale Brownson

Obviously junk casting.  Not unexpected.

Kneale Brownson

Consider the source.

Re: RIDGID 14 in. Band Saw Model No. BS14002

#5

Poor Degassing

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

at the foundry, and looks like an incomplete melt. Good casting should have reasonably even crystallization; not those chunks in your picture.

Ask'em to send you two so you don't have to wait for a replacement when the current replacement breaks.

Poor quality control

Re: RIDGID 14 in. Band Saw Model No. BS14002

#6

Re: RIDGID 14 in. Band Saw Model No. BS14002

John K Jordan

Doug,

That is a weak part in several brands of bandsaw. I have a 14" Delta and that bracket didn't break but deformed. Jet had similar problems.

Iturra Design sells, or at least did sell, replacement tensioning brackets that are much stronger. I bought one for the Delta. I also bought a stronger spring and some other upgrade parts from them.

I don't know if Iturra is still around since they don't have an internet site (or at least didn't last time I checked.) The way to deal with them is call and order by phone or get their catalog.

If you replace that one and it still doesn't hold up and can't find one it wouldn't be out of the question to machine one or have one machined from solid steel.

JKJ

Re: RIDGID 14 in. Band Saw Model No. BS14002

#7

Cheap machines need cheap parts

Dick Coers

They have to meet a price point somehow!

I'd still suggest that a lot of people using a Rigid bandsaw are not using a 3/8" blade tensioned correctly. I'd wager a lot of 1/8" and 1/4" for cutting out craft items.

Caterpillar tried some engine heads at a casting supplier in China. Early heads had some hard spots that ruined tooling. On a company visit to discuss the issue, our representative was taken through the foundry. He actually saw them cleaning up the foundry, and scooping the garbage into the ladle. Glass coke bottles and all. It was easy to figure out the hard spots after that, but the supplier was not used.

Re: RIDGID 14 in. Band Saw Model No. BS14002

#8

Re: RIDGID 14 in. Band Saw Model No. BS14002

Tony - Memphis

Wow! That's pretty bad! I used to be in the race car parts business. We saw a few issues with our castings (lots of xrays), but never anything quite like that! Hydrogen embriddlement was an interesting one though...we had rocker arms breaking on the shelf after they were packaged - sounded like popcorn! Wonder if there is room there to beef up the replacement part? Could maybe sandwich the casting with steel?

As for suggestions, I have been using a Jet for many years and have never had any issues or complaints. I'm a pretty casual user though, so I have not really put it through its paces I guess. I do tend to overtighten everything and i have not seen any issues yet. I used to de-tension, but I haven't lately. I don't like the guides though. Very sloppy. I make due with them adding shims to cool blocks and such. It will resaw pretty well and is easy to steer, blade stays centered, etc.

Tony

Re: RIDGID 14 in. Band Saw Model No. BS14002

#9

Re: RIDGID 14 in. Band Saw Model No. BS14002

AZ in Colorado Springs

I have a rigid 14" bandsaw (not sure the model number), bought in 2009. I had that same part break once, after several years of use. I use mostly 3/8" or 1/4" blades. Cost around $55 for the part, I think.