Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Shop Interference Problem

Posts

Shop Interference Problem

#1

Shop Interference Problem

William Duffield

I have a friend who is having problems with his air cleaner remote control. The AC and its RC are by Jet. His shop lights are fluorescents with electronic ballasts. When the lights are off, the RC works fine, but when the lights are on, he has to bring the RC within a foot of the RC sensor on the AC to make it work. It is a new unit, and he has replaced the batteries in the remote. Any ideas? Don't RCs usually signal in infrared?

Re: Shop Interference Problem

#2

Re: Shop Interference Problem

John K Jordan

I have remote controls that are radio and others infrared. I think my Jet air cleaner is IR since I got it work from behind by bouncing the signal off a flat surface.

Could the light from the bulbs be shining on an IR sensor and overwhelming it? If so, perhaps try taping a cardboard shade around the sensor.

JKJ

Re: Shop Interference Problem

#3

Re: Shop Interference Problem

walta

If your remote operates on radio frequencies (RF) the problem could be the electronic ballasts in the lamps do not have filtering circuits installed. It is legal save some money by eliminating the filters and labeling the ballast for “commercial use only”.

Some florescent lamps can emit enough infer red (IR) light to overpower remote controls.

The best way to identify an IR remote is to look at the remote with a cell phone camera while it is transmitting. The phone will display the IR light your eyes can’t see.

I say a free display at Lowes that would ID RF remotes.

Walt

Re: Shop Interference Problem

#4

Re: Shop Interference Problem

Tony - Memphis

Well, the other obvious thing is the Ir LED sticking out the front! Most Ir these days is plenty strong. I use my cheapie X10 (RF) stuff in a shop with lots of cheap flourescent lighting. (The X10 AC line signals do get "eaten" by a neon sign ballast!). Check the obvious..batteries, line of sight, dirt on the Ir emmiter or receiver if it is Ir, etc. Once in a while, I have to power cycle the "system" to get things to work again. Commonly after a thunderstorm. No such issue swith Zwave though - much better. We have 100k+ scanners here at work (well, all over the world), and you wouldn't beelive how many get sent in for repair with the complaint of "won't scan" and they are found to have dirty scan windows!

Let us know what you find out. I'm curious.

Tony

Re: Shop Interference Problem

#5

Re: Shop Interference Problem

John McGaw

It would be useful to know exactly what sort of remote control we are giving opinions about. All that I can find explicitly called out by Jet is the advantage of their RF control and how it eliminates the need for line-of-sight. Is this a separate control device which is powering a conventional dust collector which sucks chips and dust from regular woodworking machinery or is it the Jet 'white box' unit which sucks up ambient dust from the air in the shop? The separate unit is definitely an RF unit while the wonderfully done Jet manual is not clear about what sort of control the latter unit uses.

As for troubleshooting, a good starting point would be to power up just one lighting fixture at a time to see if any possible interference is isolated there. If it is then it might be something as simple as fixing or replacing that -- electronic ballasts generate insanely high voltages at high frequencies and could cause all sort of mischief. Oh, are all of the fixtures properly grounded? You could get into trouble with that tool. If interference is being carried on one side of the typical North American power system, it might work to move either the lights or the collector to the other phase. If that is not possible then RF filtering, common-mode ferrites, etc might be of some help. Just wild guesses of course, not knowing what you're actually dealing with.

With IR remotes, it is certainly possible that the high-frequency pulsing of the bulbs could scramble communications if they are stronger at the receiver than the competing controller. That could be hard to fix without making the control useless for its intended purpose.

Re: Shop Interference Problem

#6

Re: Shop Interference Problem

Bill Howatt

I think John has a good idea about selectively powering up the lamps. It could be the one(s) nearest the receiver are most of the problem. They are generating enough RF garbage to swamp the remote's signal. This assumes the remote control system is RF. If the system is IR then you could try to shield the receiver's sensor from stray infra-red.

Bill

Re: Shop Interference Problem

#7

Re: Shop Interference Problem

John K Jordan

http://forums.slimdevices.com/archive/index.php/t-36270.html

https://supportforums.cisco.com/discussion/12510111/it-true-fluorescent-light-can-cause-wireless-interference

JKJ