Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Joiner/Planer Purchase

Posts

Joiner/Planer Purchase

#1

Joiner/Planer Purchase

Paul Leuba

I am in need of a planer and a joiner to complete my complement of equipment.

My shop is relatively small on the second floor of a double garage, so in addition to space limitations, I have a limitation on total weight I can put on the floor. I am a hobbyist woodworker who would make generally light to medium use of the planer and joiner.

These constraints have led me to consider a joiner/planer combination machine, and in particular, I am considering the Rikon 25-010H because of its light weight. (approx. 147 lbs.)

I would appreciate feedback from members who have experience with this model, or specific information that would be helpful to me in this decision.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

#2

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

Hank Knight

Paul,

I have used combination jointer/planers for years. My current one is a 12" Hammer A3-31. I love it; it is a total workhorse. That said, I can't say enough good things about the little Inca 570 I had for 25 years. They are no longer made, but they have a very loyal following. They are light weight, simple to operate and very accurate. My Inca gave me a better surface than my Hammer. IIRC, the Inca's capacity is 10 1/4", plenty for most hobby work. The 570 has the Tersa quick change cutter head that makes blade changes a snap. If you're looking for a light weight combo machine with good capacity, look for an Inca 570. They're great little machines.

Hank

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

#3

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Second the Hammer A3-31. Built like a tank.

Mine is fitted with the digital gauge (to measure thickness). It is amazingly accurate.

I also have the spiral blades. Get them! They leave a superb finish, even into the grain, and last and last. Easy to maintain the carbide bits. And quiet. Did I mention quiet?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

#4

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase *LINK*

Keith Newton

Hey Paul, I have no experience with this tool, but went to Amazon to take a look at it, and read the reviews at the bottom of the page. There are some pretty negative reviews which I would suggest you read, if you scroll down in the link below. Plus it only appears to me to be a jointer, not a combo.

My advice is to get the Makita 1806B, plus a separate thickness planer. The Makita can clamp in a bench vice for planing or edging smaller work, but can be hand held to work the surface of much larger surfacing.


https://www.amazon.com/Rikon-25-010-Planer-Jointer-10-Inch/dp/B003GXFZBM

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

#5

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

Denny

Another alternative is to get a benchtop planer and a jointer plane. This approach takes up less room, less weight, lower cost. I've been using a Lee Valley Veritas bevel-up jointer as my only jointer for years. I use it exclusively for edge-jointing.

When I need to flatten boards I get one side flat with a jack plane and then run the board through the planer.

I realize this approach isn't for everyone, but it has worked well for me.

Denny

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

#6

Re: Hammer Question

Hank Knight

Derek, did the spiral blades on your A3-31 come from Hammer, I.E., are they OEM Hammer blades? My machine was built before Hammer redesigned the A3-31 to accommodate its proprietary spiral cutterhead. Mine has straight knives. I'm still thinking about retrofitting mine with a Byrd cutterhead, but Hammer discouracged me from trying to do that myself. I'm in a little bit of a quandry about it.

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

#7

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

Paul Leuba

Thank you for that link, Keith. Your correct in that a number of those comments give me concern about the overall quality of the machine. Yet, there are several overall favorable reviews. I suspect the difference may be in the nature of the work being done with the machine. The "light duty" users seem pleased, but the more demanding user with experience with high quality equipment is very unhappy with it.

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

#8

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

Paul Leuba

Thanks Denny, for the suggestion to use a jack plane for flattening one side and then using a benchtop planner for the finish work. This is an appealing option to me because I do not anticipate a high volume of board feet to mill. I'm leaning in this direction.

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

#9

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

Denny

Paul, there are two more things I should point out:

I like the Veritas bevel-up jointer plane for edge jointing especially because their optional jointer fence makes 90 degree finished edges much easier for me to accomplish.

Thing two, when flattening long boards, I use a planer sled to get the first side flat. There are several approaches to building and using a planer sled, I think you can choose whichever one you like.

Denny

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

#10

Re: Hammer Question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Hank

Mine are the OEM Hammer spiral blades. I purchased the machine with them ready installed about 3 years ago. This was a more expensive option as the spiral heads were an optional extra and not an alternative. I just bit the bullet as I had heard good reports and did not fancy having to go through the process of rebuilding the machine at a later date.

I am extremely happy with the machine. Superb performance. Very quiet - literally can talk over it when working.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

#11

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Paul

If you are willing to use handplanes - keeping in mind that I am predominantly a handtool woodworker - but are looking for one machine to aid in the process, I would still suggest a jointer before a planer. This is even more so if you have a bandsaw.

Why?

Because it is easier to work from a reference side that is flat and true. This is the work of a jointer. Once done, it is a lesser task to thickness the board. Either one marks the circumference and planes to the lines, or one uses a bandsaw to re-saw to the line and then finish off with a handplane. Jointing on a lunchbox planer is slow and very noisy.

I guess that it comes down to what condition the wood is that you use. If mildly cupped and twisted, a jointer is going to save time and effort. If it is pretty flat, then a handplane is often just as easy to use.

The advantage of a combo machine lies with the width of the jointer. My Hammer is 12". It is rare that I need to prepare hardwood that is wider than this. Further, my bandsaw (Hammer 4400) has a re-saw of 11 1/2", so they match well for capacity. It makes sense to me to get a jointer/planer about the same width as the re-saw of the bandsaw. A wider planer, therefore, is unnecessary.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

#12

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

Paul Leuba

Thank you for the comments Derek. I am leaning toward using a jack plane for the initial flattening of boards. However, it seems to me that it would be better to use a bench top planer for flatening the second side and reaching final thickness, rather than first using a joiner to flatten side one followed by a hand plane for flatening side two and final thicknessing. By augmenting the planer with a sled, when needed, a considerable degree of utility can be obtained from the planer that is not available from a joiner.

I also recognize that your comment regarding the condition of the wood with respect to cupping and twisting is a key factor in the choice. With this in mind, when using the jack plane followed by a planner, it is important to select wood that is pretty straight.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

#13

Re: Joiner/Planer Purchase

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Paul

Further to this, if you are willing to use handplanes and seek out fairly straight/flat boards, another technique is to joint the edges only when making panels. One would glue the boards together, and only then flatten and thickness.

Often there is no need to thickness boards. Rather flatten one side on a jointer, joint the edges, and glue the boards together into a panel. I have made tables with irregular thickness boards, and as long at the circumference is coplanar, you have no difficulty attaching the legs/stretchers. There is no need to have a flat table bottom if it cannot be seen. The same may be said for panels inside cabinets.



Regards from Perth

Derek