Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

Posts

Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#1

Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

Matt

I'm thinking of building a wooden case for my telescope, in the same style as those old cases you see scientific instruments from the 1800s to 1930s. I was thinking of using cherry, but I am not sure if it would be hard enough to be durable. I guess those old cases are from mahogany from what I've been told?

Anyway, does anyone have any suggestions on this? Is cherry hard enough? If not, what would you suggest? Oak? Mahogany?

Thanks,

Matt

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#2

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

John in NM

Any hardwood should be durable enough. Personally I would go with mahogany with brass corners, etc. but cherry would look great too.

Another option, if you expect it to see some hard travels, is plywood (like baltic birch) covered with either canvas or leather.

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#3

Cherry is much harder than mahogany

Dick Coers

But not as stable. Q-sawn cherry has a fleck pattern in it, but a more stable cut than flat sawn.

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#4

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

John McGaw

Cherry would work but I believe that mahogany is the traditional wood for such things. Old microscope boxes seem to have favored mahogany over anything else I've seen. Brass corners and hardware would add a lot to the appearance.

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#5

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I expect mahogany was used because of its exceptional stability.

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#6

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

Matt

Thanks, guys! I guess Mahogany it is.

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#7

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

Keith Newton

Good luck on finding any good mahogany. My suppliers say they can't get Genuine Mahogany, and all the African was about 50% reaction wood, which is.very unstable, so I went with Sapele.

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#8

I agree on the poor quality mahogany

Dick Coers

You really need a good dealer to get good quality. You might also consider walnut, rift sawn walnut looks a lot like mahogany in a few years.

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#9

Re: I agree on the poor quality mahogany

Tony - Memphis

I have purchased quite a bit of mahogany from Woodworker's Source in AZ and had very good luck with it. They have sales from time to time and I buy a few boards when they are on sale. They have had Honduran and African. Another good substitute is makore. I made some chairs out of that and lots of other things from the cut-offs and leftover. Nice stuff. Sapele is nice too - it too is referred to as African mahogany.

Tony

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#10

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

Gary Smyth

What is important is the instrument. Build the exterior like a brick outhouse and the interior with custom fit sections that limit movement of the instrument. Build interior braces oversize. Then pad with as thick, dense industrial wool felt as you can find. One source is Acoustical Surfaces Inc. in Chaska, MN. Not inexpensive, but has worked for me. Foam will do the job but can scratch and I hate the screech when it moves. If the telescope has truly fine optics, cover them with a metal cap or shroud and fit in its case so that the scope does not move, period. Allow for, and pad adjustment knobs and if you have a counterweight and starlock timer lock them down tight.

When the original case is damaged beyond saving I have made cases for instruments I’ve collected. They are working boxes. No matter how careful you are, if you move them regularly they will get dinged. I’ve learned by trial and error. Sometime there is no good option, but I try to keep the top of the box without obstruction so they can have stuff placed on top of the case (or used as a seat) but that can not be avoided with some configurations.

I've tried Mahogany but while it looks great (and matches the original case) it gets dinged too. Most of my instrument boxes are oak mostly because it’s available here in Western PA. I stain them (I like the teak shade). Spend money on the interior and security. I use non magnetic piano hinges, British campaign style handles when I can find them and decent brass latches. Leather belting can be used as a secure and cheap lid lock,, but when wet not so good and it will crack over time. On really expensive instruments I’ll go with dovetails, but often box joints will do nicely. Samples of levels and compasses. NOTE: Side padding is removed for photo


Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#11

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Nice Gary..

can you add a picture or two of the padding and the box with the padding in it?

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#12

Padding

Gary Smyth

Sorry, I can't show pictures with the padding inside as the pictures were taken for insurance purposes months ago and the instruments are in a different location not easily accessible from here. Using the wood sections as braces the felt pieces are fitted like camera lenses in foam in hard cases. Keep the wool dry!

Also. not seen in the earlier photos. the dry compasses have a gimbal lock which keeps the moving parts locked/steady when not used. They also have a fitted wood base slightly smaller than the inside dimensions of the box. The compass fits into or is screwed onto this base to prevent lateral movement. The padding is extra protection.

The padding I can show. It is 1/2", 1/4", and 3/16" thickness and comes in 36" wide rolls sold by the yard. Some is also from American Felt and Filter, New Windsor, N.Y.. White is available as is the grey (in some thicknesses and densities). The padding is heavy felt easily cut with a sharp utility blade or industrial scissors. I also use a roller cutter used by quilters. Make sure there is a good backing to protect whatever is underneath when cutting. The felt can be double or triple stacked and sticks to itself with friction. I fit it snug, but not packed for fear of bending fine threaded adjustment screws. The felt gets a slightly conforming fit by its own weight over time. Pieces can be cut 1/2" wide with no problem to fit as buffers as necessary.


Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#13

Re: Padding

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Thanks for the info and pictures.

I have two telescopes:

- A modern Celestron SCT in a large plastic tool case with wheels - that setup is just fine and it works great. No need to build a case for that though i considered it for a while.

- An old telescope passed down through the family about six? generations:



I don't really know much about it other than I've been told I had an ancestor who was a clipper ship captain and this was his scope. My grandfather gave it to me when i was ten.

I've been dissatisfied keeping it in a felt bag stored in a safe for a long time so your pictures certainly provide me with some ideas.

Thanks again.

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#14

Something special..

Gary Smyth

I don’t believe that I have ever seen a nine section nesting spyglass. A seven section is reasonably hard to find. Obviously, yours won’t collapse completely owing to what is probably lead solder wrapping two sections. Someone early on pulled too hard and yanked it out of its slip. They repaired just enough to have it work but required adjustments with the other sections to keep it in focus, You ought to research that glass. There has to be a name on it somewhere. (eyepiece?-lens edge?) It is unique enough to have it appraised and if worthwhile ask if you have the soldered sections restored so the glass fully collapses what happens to any value.

That said, a box with a built in cradle with a concave padded semicircle to nestle the spyglass diameter should be not too difficult. A tall lid with a partition with a matching (padded) semicircle silhouette mating with the bottom cradle can” lock” it down when the lid is closed. Find good latches to keep it closed.

If you have a surveying/microscope/telescope instrument repair facility available you might be able to find end caps in one of their repair bins. They may also have old hook and screw or round cam lock latches.

Nice instrument. Congrats.

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#15

Re: Something special..

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Hey Gary,

thanks for your comments. Actually the first picture is with it completed collapsed. There is an unusual section where it slides out more like an extension vs collapsing like the rest of the scope.

Though it's not apparent from the first picture, the front element is in line with the front of the first section (where the brass end cap would cover it). I used to think the same as you and then after some careful checking with it disassembled, it's clear that is how it is.

I'll take some more pictures tonight to show it.

I do have a bit of info about the repairs. My mom told me that my great-great uncle repaired it with silver/lead solder and then gave to my grandfather. My grandfather was annoyed about the repairs since he knew how to repair it correctly.

I have long planned on getting it restored - better cleaning than what I've done in the past, having a new end cap made, etc. I'll have to check in to your suggestion about a repair shop. The biggest issue is that the front element has some scratches on the outside (most certainly a result of the missing cap leaving it unprotected) that cause visible artifacts. You can still see through it decently in daylight. At night, it's not too good (modern lens tech is amazing).

As for a name, there is nothing or perhaps it was on the end cap or in one of the areas repaired. I need to dig some more on its history in a more thorough manner. My mom could only tell me so much.

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#16

Re: Something special..

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Here's one with the section extendec.


Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#17

Before I leave this spyglass

Gary Smyth

https://www.google.com/#q=antique+expanding+spyglass+images

Try this link to look at some others. I see none with as many sections as yours. Note a couple of the images show cases --leather seems to be standard. Some support long spyglasses.

Also, the eyepieces and ends sometimes had a pop up slide to protect their ends. If it turns out that the glass is of value other than just family, it can be left alone or a lens can be buffed out or replaced. Edmund Optics makes quite a few "standard" lenses (catalog) if you can find a repair facility. Make sure of value before work. Don't "ruin" a true antique. Clippers ran from the 1840's through 1860's as prime years.

Good luck.

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#18

Re: Before I leave this spyglass

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Thanks again for all the info Gary. I'll make one final comment about it then shut up :) - the eyepiece cover is intact and works fine (Eyepiece is in great shape).

take care

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#19

OT - T-Scope Parts

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Hey, Gary.

I inherited Mom's Mayflower 814. I built a custom case with nested elements and all felt padded but one of the knobs (specifically the elevation gear knob) is missing. You have any sources where I could get a replacement knob and retaining screw?

TIA

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#20

You're in prime territory *LINK*

Gary Smyth

I have no one specific, but you ought to be able to find someone fairly easily to talk with in the NJ-NY area. Two came up with minimal search. Info below from their post.

Teeter's Telescopes, LLC. | Custom Built Telescopes | Rockaway, NJ

www.teeterstelescopes.com/

Since 2002, Teeter's Telescopes has been custom building telescopes for customers both locally and across the globe. Services also include repairs and ...

‎Products · ‎TT / Journey TravelScope · ‎TT / Solid Tube Series

High Point Scientific: Telescopes | Eyepieces & Telescope Accessories

www.highpointscientific.com/

High Point Scientific is a leading retailer of quality telescopes and accessories for beginner, intermediate, and advanced astronomers alike. Celestron, Meade ...

‎Used Telescopes · ‎Telescope Eyepieces · ‎CCD Camera · ‎Telescopes

These ought to be able to guide you better than me. Failing that B&H photo in NY city and Meade and Celestron manufacturers have customer service that may be willing to help (may, not will). If you know the thread pitch a gunsmith ought to be able to make what you want.

I'm really not a go-to person on this stuff. Searching for "telescope repair" New York on a browser will get you a start, You might have many phone calls or emails pending in the near future. The "cloudy nights" FORUM may also help.


http://www.cloudynights.com/page/index.html

Re: Cherry or mahogany for telescope case?

#21

Thanks!