Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Roasted PPBs

Posts

Roasted PPBs

#1

Roasted PPBs

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

When last we visited our guy he had sprayed his buggy maple with Timbor and set it out in full sun wrapped in black plastic.

Then the bears (black furry type, not pistol-packin') decided to investigate what (like gharbague) might be inside the big black bag and shredded the wrap. So rewrapped in clear 7 mil and wait.

Two months in the summer sun appears to have done quite well as boards were pulled out this morning with several dozen dead beetles toes-up along their lengths.

The slab, 9/4x30"x8', will be left out for a while longer.

Re: Roasted PPBs

#2

You sure those didn't die after laying eggs?


Re: Roasted PPBs

#3

Without

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

running the wood through a kiln program at 185°, there is no way to be absolutely sure.

But conditions in the wrap reached 125° (measured 1" into the endgrain) on a number of days and my exterminator "opines" that the heat forced them all to the surface where the borates killed them. In examining the stack there was no new frass or boring powder piles.

Re: Roasted PPBs

#4

Ellis Walentine

Sounds like an article

Ellis Walentine

I wonder what the minimum time would be to kill the bugs using your method?

Ellis

Re: Roasted PPBs

#5

Curious

Dick Coers

How did the get to the surface with no new boring holes or frass? By all accounts and recommendations, the wood didn't get hot enough to sterilize it. I'd be cautious!

Re: Roasted PPBs

#6

Re: Curious

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Since they were on the top surface of the boards and there are both entry and exit holes in evidence, I surmise that they chewed their way out which would not result in a pile of powder like what would show at entry points. In exit mode their dust would pack the tunnel behind them.

Re: Roasted PPBs

#7

And all that while they are being baked? LOL

Dick Coers

They must have thought the wood have been moved to Death Valley!

Re: Roasted PPBs

#8

Are you sure about that?

Keith Newton

I don't think that is how it works. The adult beetles don't chew into the wood.

When they mate, the female lays her eggs in tiny checks smaller than you could see naked, so when they hatch, the larva goes to work creating all the tunnels. From what I've read, they can last from 1~2 months to 1~2 years before the adults exit and look for a mate. The mating is outside of the wood.

Re: Roasted PPBs

#9

Re: Roasted PPBs

Don Evans

To prove further: You need a control, that would require testing a board that was NOT sprayed and see if get the same results. If yes then it was the heat allone NO spray needed.

IMO there should have been frays no matter how they exit. If they came out of top, as the board layed, then maybe none out yet, but turning the board would dump it out or some of it.

I'm very cautious of board that I bring into the shop for PPB's even though I don't have any wet wood for them to move too. I would like to know how others feel about that. I do have AC in shop and I spray around bottom of walls once a month with Home Defence.

What do others do?

Don

Re: Roasted PPBs

#10

Doubt they even have PPBs in Death Valley.  lol


Re: Roasted PPBs

#11

Re: Are you sure about that?

John K Jordan

The adults must chew out of the wood. Years ago I had the rare "pleasure" of watching a PPB chew an exit hole and come out of the wood. What are the chances?

I had a shelf near my lathe with some 2" walnut squares from a guy who had stored them outside. I heard a quiet "scritch..scritch..scritch" sound and started looking for the source. As I was looking and listening, I watched a little hole appear on the walnut end grain and a bug came out. I decided to move these pieces of wood out of the shop!

Another time I was cutting maple when a flock of little bugs flew out of the woods right towards me, landed on the chunks, and started to chew into the wood. It was amazing how quick they could chew a hole into that wood. As I brushed them off some were already half way into the wood! I quickly sprayed those pieces with what I had on hand and got them indoors. I guess the smell of fresh maple on the breeze was a strong attraction.

JKJ

Re: Roasted PPBs

#12

That's the Problem

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

An "Article" would invite WCer's to do the same, and, in deference to Dick, there's no guarantee that the wood is clear of the infestation.

I chose TIMBOR at 15% of the cost of Bora-Care, it being the same stuff but without the glycol penetrant so this "program" was clearly an "on-the-cheap" kind of effort.

The plastic DIY solar kiln would only work, if at all, in the summer; much better in Phoenix, not so much in Bemidji.

This effort was not for anyone looking to use the wood in the short term. It's been out in the sun for a solid two months with me trotting out with the instant-read thermometer to check temps.

If I'd had someone close and friendly with an operating kiln, that would have been the route to go.

Re: Roasted PPBs

#13

Re: Roasted PPBs

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't recall the start of this adventure. If it is just one piece of wood the effort seems extreme and risky. Wrapped in plastic and in the sun I would have been concerned that it would have cracked on the ends.

I would have employed chemical warfare in a fumigation attack. Coat wood with something volatile and toxic to bugs, wrap and let set a few days. Lacquer solvent would be a possible choice and maybe for good measure I would have added moth balls. Actually I would have sprayed it with Lindane, but it can't be bought anymore (but I still have a half gallon for these purposes). The problem with the borate is that it is not volatile so it can't kill where it isn't.

Re: Roasted PPBs

#14

50bf

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

of curly 5/4 maple plus a 9/4 maple slab 30" x 8'. All air dried for 20+ years in a shed.

Moth balls and such would not fumigate into the bugs' egg galleries. The heat was to bring the buggers out of their holes where the borate gets them on the surfaces. Doubt you could get a sufficient vapor concentration with light solvents. Need a license and moon suit to buy Lindane. Not going there.

Re: Roasted PPBs

#15

Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If oxygen will diffuse to where the bugs are, they have to breathe, why wouldn't you expect a vapor toxic to bugs to get there too? Even Lindane, which isn't very volatile, will kill them in place.

Lindane containing soap used to be available for treating head lice and dog fleas. Worked great.

Re: Roasted PPBs

#16

Lindane

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

It has to penetrate under vapor pressure. When they fumigate infested furniture they use Vikane or phosphorus gas under pressure in a sealed chamber. Nobody I've found in Jersey will handle that stuff due to insurance requirements. Their response is "buy new furniture." I'm told it, the gas, has to be "recovered" from the chamber rather than vented and the whole process is simply not worth the cost; especially when the piece can be heat treated if the owner insists on saving it. As said, I would have run this stuff through a kiln if one was available, and not bothered with the Timbor and zip-lock bag.

I have my tree guy looking to save me some maple logs. I'll treat the boards with Timbor as they're coming off the mill when I have them sawn to keep the little buggers out during air-drying.

Re: Roasted PPBs

#17

Not so

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If the bug killer is a gas then obviously the gas needs to be under some pressure or it will leave. But if the bug killer is a liquid or solid the killing chamber does not need to be pressurized and in fact pressurizing the chamber will have no beneficial effect. Sealing the chamber will for it will prevent dilution of the toxic vapor.

The molecules in a toxic vapor will diffuse to where ever they aren't. This diffusion is described by Fick's first law of diffusion

rate of transport of stuff = diffusion coefficient times the concentration gradient.

Because initially there will be no toxic stuff where the bugs are , the initial concentration gradient is large and there will be rapid transport of toxic stuff down the bug hole.

Pressure does not affect either the diffusion coefficient much or the concentration gradient unless the diffusing species is a gas. Then the pressure of this gas will be important. Or to put it another way, the gas will have to be pressurized to have any concentration available. But for a liquid or a solid that has vapor pressure it will be the vapor pressure of the material that drives diffusion.

If the concentration of the vapor in the bag is sufficient to kill the bug this concentration will fairly rapidly equilibrate any place in the bag or board where it can diffuse and it can diffuse anywhere oxygen can diffuse.

Oxygen will travel by diffusion about 2 inches in a minute. Something that will kill a bug will be slower, but not 10 times slower.

I think I recall painting a bug infested board with lacquer thinner and it killed what was within. At least I would expect it to.

Re: Roasted PPBs

#18

Re: Not so

Dick Coers

Any treatment to kill PPB also has to kill the eggs. Don't know how easily the egg is destroyed by anything but heat.

Re: Roasted PPBs

#19

Okay

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

But, while lacquer thinner will evaporate, what is the residual effect of the toxic chems you're referring to. Useless to kill the bugs but render the wood and its dust from cutting and sanding as a dangerous substance through pesticide residue. Timbor is (reportedly) less toxic to humans than table salt.

Re: Roasted PPBs

#20

One possible solution from HS Biology

Grant in Iowa

I recall with fondness the High School Biology class where we each had to make an insect collection. We were tasked with needing to secure dozens of samples of insects from each Phylum. I recall starting too late (procrastination) and not getting a Green-Lace-wing, the only insect in our area from the Order Neuroptera. At least I remember one Order, and an example of an insect that belongs to it. Each time I see a green lace-wing, I call all present to BEHOLD THE GREEN LACEWING FROM THE ORDER NEUROPTERA!

Anyway, we used nail polish remover on a cotton ball in a jar to to the "offing" of our target insects. It seemed to work quickly and easily. In those days, it was Acetone that made up most, if not all of nail polish remover. I don't know if it is still the same stuff, but if so, it therefore follows that it may make a good widely available chemical for "offing" PPB's, etc. Acetone is available anywhere paint is sold, for the most part, 'cept maybe California. I suspect the stuff would make its way in to nooks and crannies, larvae holes, etc. rather readily.

Of course I have no empirical evidence (Other than not being able to tell you if it is an effective way to euthanize Green Lace-Wings), but it would be rather easy to do a test on a suitably buggy piece of wood contained inside a simple vessel of some sort. It sure seems to me that the stuff would readily penetrate a semi-porous item.

FWIW, no warranties expressed or implied. Bill, Feel free to chime in with a chemistry lesson as to why Acetone excels at offing insects.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Roasted PPBs

#21

Thanks Grant

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The real problem with this wood is not the live adults; they're well done. It's the eggs buried in the nest galleries of the wood that "continue" the risk. I'm hoping that reaching 125 F was enough to get them as well. I wouldn't be as concerned if I hadn't smoked out the adults that I did. They established that there was an active infestation rather than just historical holes from generations long gone.

Re: Roasted PPBs

#22

Thats' what I have been saying!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

there are two situation.

Prevention- borax is likely a good thing to use if you don't like persistent pesticides.

Killing an established infestation before it does more damage- Only two choices, heat and toxic fumes. Which is why I thought lacquer thinner to be a good choice that was readily available. Acetone by itself may be too volatile to keep up a toxic concentration. I still think that moth balls in a bag to be what I would try on a bagable piece. A bath in lacquer solvent would be my choice for a larger plank that was obviously infested.

Actually, the professional bug collectors that happen to be chemists use ethyl acetate in their jars. Isopropyl acetate worked to fumigate a 55 gal barrel infested corn kernels. I had it on hand so that is what I tried.

Re: Roasted PPBs

#23

If the concern is a re-infestation...

Grant Smith

If you read up on PPBs, the little buggers won't typically re-infest wood with a MC below about 12%. Therefore, so long as you lumber is below that MC, any insects that pupate and come out of the lumber will either just move on to other lumber they prefer, or die trying.

I do logs to lumber and have now for over a decade. While no expert, I have found that simply having the lumber dry is enough to ensure they don't re infest in my situation. Here in Iowa, if I move lumber in to the shop in fall or winter, it is typically dry enough that it is below 12%. Usually around ten or so. Of course everyone's climate is different, but this has been my experience.

I suspect your sun treatment (though it likely trapped any moisture at least to some degree) has been largely effective in the sense that it will prevent the insects from completing the life cycle on the same lumber.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Roasted PPBs

#24

The Goal

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Since I rather doubted I could get the wood to 135 or above and hold it there, I was hoping the heat would bring any adults to the surface and maybe force the eggs to hatch and come out. As noted, I had a decent crop of dead adults, but I didn't see evidence of little ones.

Your MC note is encouraging as all the wood in my basement, hardwood stock and house framing, is at 8%.

Re: Roasted PPBs

#25

Fire hazard!!!

Keith Newton

If I were to use the acetone to do more than just a small amount of wood, I'd certainly suggest doing it outdoors. I don't know if the vapors sink and flow downhill like gasoline but I'd treat it the same.

I've worked in shops with plenty of guys that probably didn't pass HS biology that wouldn't think twice about taking your advice, and pouring out a gallon of acetone on a stack of lumber in their closed garage with a leaky compressor cycling every few minutes, or a hot water heater in the storage closet, with the pilot light burning, or piezo available to ignite the pool of fumes.

Speaking of HS classes. Could someone diagram or proof the above paragraph for me. I normally try to break them down to shorter sentences. Mrs Harrell would be all over me for that. ;>)