Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Unanticipated problems building in a new style

Posts

Unanticipated problems building in a new style

#1

Unanticipated problems  building in a new style

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Daughter needed two bed side chests of drawers. She sent me a blurry picture of something she liked. It was Danish Modern with post and panel construction. However, it has a separately applied base that made it more interesting and attractive. The blurry picture did not reveal fine details of the base construction. But it appeared simple enough to do.......I thought.

I have built lots of chests of drawers with panel sides and 1800’s engineering, and few with frame and panel sides and 1700 engineering, but nothing with “modern” post and panel construction. I study antiques and replicated what they did that survived to this day. No risk or surprises encountered.

The picture she sent looked simple to approximately replicate as I never exactly copy something. Along the way I discovered the problems that can be encountered doing something you don’t have any experience doing, namely post and panel with the nonconventional base. Because I had never studied this style I don’t know how it should be put together. I found out that employing the mortise and tenon and dovetail techniques I traditionally used led to a complex construction. The small posts (1.25 x 1.25”) don’t allow for robust mortise and tenon or dovetails.

Normally when I assemble a case it comes up square with no diddling. Not with this piece. The tiny joints just didn’t provide enough mating surface to ensure pieces came into orthogonal alignment.


Fitting drawers into a case that is not perfectly square is tedious and may never result in a good fit. I had to do something to make these pieces more ridged and square. The fix was to add a solid plywood bottom as seen in the picture (the white birch floor). This piece was glued into a bottom frame. It solved the getting it square and ridged problem.

The base problems were never solved. I could not come up with any engineering that would render the legs for the base strong enough to suit my requirements. I found one solution in a FWW article where the legs were attached with 3 dowels joining the 1.25” leg to the case. I could not see this solution to be adequate. I could imagine these tiny dowels shearing off as the piece was slid across the floor some time in the future. I ditched the base in the picture and set the case on a simple frame. It won’t look as attractive, but it will survive.

The moral of this story is that the engineering to efficiently and adequately make one style of furniture may be difficult and inadequate to make another. I had no opportunity to study how Danish Modern is made. Furthermore, just because someone recently made something for a gallery sale, it is not guaranteed its engineering will survive 200 years. The base shown in the picture provided could well be a unique design of its maker and not of sound engineering. It did look attractive though.

Note: this piece has a top and bottom drawer and a middle book shelf, as required by the client. The shelf is removed for the picture to enable the bottom to be seen. The other piece has 3 drawers.

Re: Unanticipated problems building in a new style

#2

Re: Unanticipated problems  building in a new styl

William Duffield

Hard lessons, but valuable. Thanks for sharing them with us.

When venturing into the unknown, a base built around a piece of 3/4" Baltic Birch ply is a good choice for a failsafe method of construction. I have used it successfully with a post and frame several times, and I agree with your reluctance to use dowel joinery. Twenty years ago, I designed and built a successful piece with the frames attached to the BB top and bottom with yellow glue and biscuits. Since then, I have upgraded my method to Domino "loose" tenons.

When I'm researching construction in an unfamiliar style, I often start with the book by Bill Hylton, Illustrated Cabinetmaking. While it is not exhaustive, and could in many cases provide some more engineering details (what we used to call "scantlings"), it is a very useful resource for sound wooden furniture construction methods that have proven themselves over the centuries. (No Ikea flat packs with KD fasteners and bradded cardboard back panels :D.)

Re: Unanticipated problems building in a new style

#3

Ellis Walentine

Engineering

Ellis Walentine

Hi Bill,

I'm sympathetic to your experience with unfamiliar constructions. When I was making furniture and architectural woodwork for a living, every job we contracted was essentially an R&D project with one chance to get it right and make a profit. Engineering had to be bulletproof or else. But, rather than thinking in terms of styles (classical, Danish modern, etc.) which may or may not even have a proven construction vernacular, I was always about applying what I knew about sound construction to the problem at hand, as you have done here. If you can conjure up all the requirements a piece will have to meet in order to last a long time, you can overcome the failure issues in advance.

Regarding stability and resistance to racking, the concept of "shoulders" is key, as you are aware. That's why the front and back rails of a workbench are wide -- so the shoulders keep the bench stable when hand planing. That concept alone will get you through a lot of thee basic engineering problems. Gussets and glued plywood panels are also valuable devices.

I guess the upshot for me is to think more generally about the forces that will come to bear on a piece and arrange for sturdy enough joinery to resist the worst expected wear and tear. You've done this nicely and made good decisions from what I've seen.

Ellis

Re: Unanticipated problems building in a new style

#4

Re: Engineering

Brian Holcombe

Bill, you may want to have a look at the work of Mogens Koch, one of the works he designed is a series of bookcases and cabinetry which are made of 1/2" thick material and are either hung on a wall or sat on a plinth, similar to the base that you show.

Much of the work he designed is built by Rud Rasmussen and it is properly joined. The design is now about one hundred years old and many examples continue to survive and are in great shape.

It would also be worth investigating Ming furniture and sashimono, when working in thin frame and panel, which is joined, they provide much insight.