Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Reg Poly Over Water Based Poly

Posts

Reg Poly Over Water Based Poly

#1

Reg Poly Over Water Based Poly

Stuart Johnson

I have a small chest finished with water based semi gloss poly. My wife has decided she like the look of gloss better. I have half a can of regular poly, can this be applied over the water based?

Re: Reg Poly Over Water Based Poly

#2

It should do ok... BUT...

John in NM

The piece will still look likes its finished with WB poly. I did this very thing once to preserve the pale, not wetted look of WB poly and top coat with something I was more familiar with. I thought it looked terrible, but it was what the guy wanted.

Re: Reg Poly Over Water Based Poly

#3

Re: It should do ok... BUT...

Stuart Johnson

Would water based gloss give more of the glass finish look? Nothing like several half full cans sitting around going bad.

Re: Reg Poly Over Water Based Poly

#4

Re: Reg Poly Over Water Based Poly

Dick Coers

It can probably be applied, but it's another question if it will bond. It might dry and then flake off with little effort. I'd stay with the same product only different sheen.

Re: Reg Poly Over Water Based Poly

#5

Re: It should do ok... BUT...

William Duffield

Another potential problem is the method used to achieve the semi-gloss and satin finishes. While it can be achieved with microscopic surface crazing during the curing of the finish, it is usually done by adding small particles into the finish that break up the light passing through it (often silica). If so, you will not remove the semi-gloss look of the lower finish coat. You will just add a shiny plastic look on top of it, further obscuring the wood figure.

Re: Reg Poly Over Water Based Poly

#6

I doubt it would...

John in NM

More than a couple coats of WB has always given me a dull, milky looking finish. I hate the stuff. Its just the thing if you put on 1-2 coats to get a "not there" sort of look to the finish, but if you want glassy, its not the stuff in my experience.

Best route is to strip it and refinish with something that will give you the look you want.

Re: Reg Poly Over Water Based Poly

#7

Re: Reg Poly Over Water Based Poly

Stuart Johnson

Thanks for the answers. I'll sand it back and refinish with regular gloss and save the WB for my shop cabinets.