A matter of philosophy
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I dovetail drawers because that is the best way to hold them together. I pay no attention to fashion that can't be seen, which includes anything inside a case. I have just completed a chest of drawers, these current pieces will make two more and son in law wants a large chest of drawers made soon. I am looking for ways to take labor and risk out of making drawers.
I would say that my goal is to make stuff similar to a 1800's shop making stuff to sell to middle class customers, with an occasional personal touch added such as careful wood selection. I spend a lot of time on wood selection and I have a lot to select from.
If one splits a half pin the drawer front is ruined. In my cases I have usually carefully selected drawer fronts and if I ruin one I might have to start over with a new set to get all of them to match. Hence, I make the half pins as wide as I can and still be able to hide the slot for the drawer bottom in the front in the tail of the side. The result is a half pin with the small end 5/16". I keep a marker set to this dimension.
I attempt to slightly overcut tails for it makes removing the corner waste more reliable, and easier. A crumb in the corner and the drawer side doesn't close up. I nail the two sides together and fit and dovetail them as a unit. Someone asked, "but what about the nail holes"? It's a drawer side. Who cares about a nail hole? Well, anyone striving to build as best they can would worry about a nail hole, but that is not my goal for a drawer.