Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

Posts

Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

#1

Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


There is an advantage to preparing the thickness and rough sizes of all the drawer sides and backs at one time. It takes me nearly a day to make a dovetailed drawer to completion. With other interruptions the 5 drawers I am assembling for the bed side chests of drawers will take more than a week. I make thin sides(7/16"). As humidity changes in the shop the thin sides are prone to distorting before I get them assembled into the drawer box.

I may have a solution. I am experimenting with wrapping the drawer stock in food wrap. We keep a commercial sized roll of this stuff on hand for freezing food. This polymer is an excellent moisture barrier. I expected that if I wrapped the stock for each drawer as soon as it was dimensioned that it would stay flat until I got to marking and sawing the dovetails.

The experiment seems to be successful. The drawer parts have stayed flat.

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

#2

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

Barry Irby

I wonder if they will mold? I kind of doubt it since they were dry to start with, but I wonder.

OTOH, would a plastic bag work just as well? I made a chest for my nephew with 8" deep drawers and when I moved them to an unconditioned space, they swelled to the point the drawers were stuck. When moved back indoors they did nto shrink as much.

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

#3

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

Gary Smyth

If it works for you then great, but I would think that it would not allow the wood to vent and make it wetter now and more prone to adverse reaction when freed from the airtight wrap. Interesting experiment. Probably only a problem in humid months though.

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

#4

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

Yonak

If the wood's dry there shouldn't be any worry about trapping moisture. The ambient humidity should be the same or higher than the boards.

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

#5

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I would think that it would not allow the wood to vent" I am unsure of what this statement means. I'm not wrapping wood that has not been sufficiently dried to build furniture from it. I'm wrapping because I don't want the wood to change moisture content until I get the sides locked into a drawer box. Once assembled into a drawer two concerns have been eliminated. The dovetails will restrain the wood from distorting and the drawer sides will have equal access to shop air and its moisture content on all sides. Hence, there will be no moisture gradient established in the sides as the shop humidity changes that would lead to distortion.

" Probably only a problem in humid months though. " Thin drawer side distortion is a concern no matter what the humidity is when the lumber is dimensioned. Distortion can occur if the shop humidity goes up or down. It is change that is important, not the moisture content the change starts from.

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

#6

Something that might not be obvious

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It would take several paragraphs to describe the grief of trying to hand cut and fit dovetails in lumber that is not flat. I nail the two drawer sides together before final dimensioning to fit the opening and cut the tails in the sides. (saves time) It is these assemblies that I am wrapping, plus the back. There is more risk of cupping of this assembly in response to shop humidity change because only one side of each drawer side is exposed to the shop air.

I just unwrapped parts for the 3rd drawer and they are dead flat. I'm pleased. Now it is nose to the grindstone to get the drawer done before something moves.

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

#7

Re: Something that might not be obvious

Chuck Kettler

It might have been instructive to have had a blank laying around unwrapped to measure the problem that was avoided.

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

#8

Re: Something that might not be obvious

Brian Holcombe

Bill,

Do you not want the drawer sides and faces at the same RH? Wrapping one and not the other would seem to invite issues.

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

#9

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

Sgian Dubh

Gary, I think the point is to reduce the likelihood of the wood 'venting' between machining and executing the joinery. What Bill has done is essentially the same practice as many suppliers of timber (lumber) undertake. Kiln operators around the world dry boards, cut them all to a standard length, rip to width, paint the ends (not necessarily in that order) dead stack them in a neat bundle, wrap the bundle tightly in plastic and ship it to the buyer. Here in the UK such bundles arrive from North America, mainland Europe and further afield on a regular basis. The plastic wrapping helps to minimise changes in the wood's moisture content between the kiln and the buyer, meaning warping during storage and transport should also be limited.

Similarly, in the DIY stores here bundles of 4 to 10 pieces of machined softwood and hardwood (4X2, 2X1, mouldings, etc) are available to buy, all of it tightly wrapped in plastic.

In both the cases I've described, the majority of warping that's likely to occur will happen after the wrapping is removed and the wood has to adjust to whatever RH conditions it finds itself in. It's quite common for joinery grade wood (dried to a target just under 20% MC) from the DIY store to come out of the pack reasonably straight and true, but given two or three days in a dry atmosphere it can start to warp significantly. Slainte.

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

#10

an alternate solution

Robin Corell in Atascadero

In patternmaking we often encounter the same problem particularly when a weather front is moving in over night. Stacking thin boards will always result in the top one warping like a water ski. The way we deal with this is to stand the boards on edge with a couple inches of space between them so air can circulate. This way both sides of the board absorb or loose the same amount of moisture. This is particularly successful if your stock is quarter sawn.

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

#11

No dog in this fiight.

Gary Smyth

You posted as an experiment, I made my comment. If it works then fine. We all benefit. I’m not suggesting that you don’t monitor moisture in your wood before wrapping. However, my thought is that wrapping the wood keeps what moisture is in the wood at that point in stasis and that when it is unwrapped it might have more of a reaction to the new environment/humidity than it might if it were, for discussion, pressed to stay flat in air, allowing acclimation before you do your work. If what you do with the wrap solves a problem that you have experienced in the past, thank you for the post. Good to know.

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

#12

the problem with what you suggest

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"than it might if it were, for discussion, pressed to stay flat in air, allowing acclimation before you do your work"

I agree what you suggest is a sound approach to the problem. There are three thin parts per drawers. I am working on 5 drawers. Sometimes I am working on 7 drawers. That is a lot of parts to keep pressed flat and exposed on both sides to shop air during the 1-2 weeks it takes me to get the parts into assembled drawers.

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

#13

Agree, but

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I do that regularly with things like case sides and tops. But with drawers there are a lot of parts to deal with, 3 per drawer times how ever many drawers are involved. It becomes too many parts stacked around with 2" gaps. In the current case I have 20 drawers parts involved. Wrapped and stacked it doesn't take up much room. In fact I store the parts in the case as shown in the picture

Second, I nail the right and left hand drawers sides together and dimension them to the opening as well as cut the dovetails as a unit. What I am storing are these drawer sandwiches awaiting dovetailing and final fitting. Any humidity change experienced by the assembly will cup both sides because the inside of each side is not exposed to shop air. Been there and done that on most occasions where I tried storing the assembly unwrapped.

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

#14

Not something I worry about

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am wrapping the assembled sides (nailed together to fit and dovetail as a unit) as well as the back. These are thin and thin stuff cups quick in response to differential moisture change on the surfaces. In my time scale the 3/4" fronts are stable.

In my experience it takes but a tiny moisture gain or loss to cup the thin sides. However, this tiny difference between a drawer face and sides is inconsequential. In practice there are larger stresses in play but these too have been shown to be inconsequential. Different species, differences within species and differences in grain orientation all will result in stress to the drawer joinery, But drawers held together the way they have been held together for 200+ years have shown in practice that these issues are not significant.

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

#15

PS works for veneer too

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Any lumber that is thin distorts quickly when the surfaces experience a difference in moisture change. Home made thick veneer is another problem. I have been wrapping flitches of sawed veneer this way for a while and it stays flat. This observation is what led me to trying drawer sides.

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

#16

Re: Not something I worry about

Brian Holcombe

Makes sense. I think its a good idea and I've seen the guys who plane at Kezurou-Kai do it to prevent the wooden dai from moving while they're in transit.

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

#17

Re: I Agree with Robin

William Duffield

Robin's method is the only one that has worked reliably for me. Of course, it's a little more complicated that that, and doesn't work with plastic wrapped boards from a retailer, or waxed tropicals, either.

For boards that I machine to size and thickness in my shop and then join into boxes, the first step is acclimating them to my shop environment. Next, it is critical to remove approximately the same amount of material from both faces of each board. To do this, you have to count carefully while processing them through the jointer and planer. I pay close attention to how much I have needed to remove from the first face with the jointer, and take off about the same amount from the other face with the planer. After that, I just flip them between every pass as I continue to reduce them to finished thickness. Third, I stack them on end as close to vertical as I can manage, on battens, so they are not touching the floor, and with small blocks stickering them, to allow as much EVEN air circulation around all surfaces as possible. If I think I might need to run a fan, I insure it is on low and as far from the stack as I can manage, and blowing evenly through the stack, but not against one face. I build the stack as close to the center of the shop as is practical, and not up against a wall, and especially not in a corner.

When marking pins from tails or tails from pins, the alignment appliance Bill and I mentioned in the other thread is very useful, as it can be used with clamps to temporarily flatten out any residual warpage in the top board. The appliance and the face vise, of course, temporarily flatten the front board and square the assembly during layout.

Finessing the clamps while gluing up the box is probably beyond the purview of this thread, so we should discuss that separately, later if necessary.

Re: Keeping drawer sides flat during construction

#18

Re: PS works for veneer too

William Duffield

But as soon as you remove the plastic wrap, thin veneer starts to dry unevenly and thus to warp. When I'm working with sawn veneer, I find that a spray bottle of deionized water to judiciously apply to the concave surface is still necessary to push it back towards flat.