I live in a lovely town on the shores of Lake Michigan, where it is nice and humid in the summer. I have a spray booth located in a shop that is 7200 cubic feet. Right now the RH is 67%. I want to spray both shellac and nitrocellulose lacquer. The shop is not air conditioned. I am thinking about a 70 pint (whatever that means) dehumidifier, and running it for a couple days. Does this make sense? I don't want to run it full time. What do you other sprayers do. Waiting for the right conditions is frustrating. Jerry.
You can go to an automotive paint supplier and get lacquer thinner that has retarder added, or get your own retarder. Lighter spraying coats also helps. I doubt if the dehumidifier would be of great benefit because as soon as you kick on the exhaust fan, you are at outside conditions. A variable speed exhaust fan can help. After spraying, slow it down for solvent removal as the lacquer cures. That slows the air flow in the booth and helps slow the drying.
If you dehumidify the air that is evaporating the solvent your problem is solved. Without knowing more than you told us we don't know if a dehumidifier will dehumidify the air that is evaporating the solvent.
A dehumidifier properly sized will drop the shop humidity in tens of minutes, not days.
A woodworker I know still uses nitrocellulose lacquer exclusively and has fits here in Cincinnati trying to spray in the summer. He does not use a dehumidifier. Often after spraying several light coats he has blushing and sprays a coat of pure solvent to try to let the water out of the finish.
If the original poster has a fairly tight building, how quickly can the exhaust fan be turned off? Won't the evaporating solvent continue to pose a hazard for some time after spraying, requiring the exhaust fan, before the building could be closed up and the dehumidifier turned on?
Certainly there are significant conveniences of shellac and NC finishes when repairs are needed, but with good spray technique other more durable finishes can be sprayed in humid conditions without the blushing problem.
I spray conversion varnish any time. I quit lacquer as soon as I discovered conversion varnish. I sprayed conversion varnish last week and it was foggy(the air not the finish as seen in picture).
When I used to spray lacquer I added 5-10% retarder and avoided blushing. Use isopropanol for shellac but in both cases it will take a long time to fully harden the finish.
As far as dehumidification, the humidity only has to be low for 20 seconds after the spray leaves the gun. Once the high volatility solvent flashes there may not be enough cooling from the low volatility solvents to cause water condensation.
I sprayed shellac one morning. The surface retained the "wet" look for some time after spraying like the ethanol had not evaporated. I investigated and there was a layer of water coating every surface I sprayed. I looked great until the water evaporated.
A dehumidifier is useful in the shop for reasons other than finishing. It will reduce the moisture in your stock and make it less difficult to account for the lower humidity conditions you will find in most homes, summer and winter.
With nitro lacquer, you can actually get a blush when the humidity is trapped in the finish. I've never had that happen with shellac. I guess I was assuming that you are spraying the lacquer, but you didn't say. For lacquer you have to get rid of the solvent vapor, RIGHT NOW! Shellac isn't nearly as bad for that either.
Blushing results when the solvent evaporates fast enough to cool the surface of the piece below the dew point of the air around what is being sprayed. Water condenses on the surface and precipitates the finish into finish particles that are not coalesced into a film. These particles scatter light and therefore appear cloudy. This phenomena can occur with any finish that is a solution of finish in solvent.
"Alcohol" as sold in the can at Lowes can be 50% methanol, a more volatile solvent than ethanol. On a damp morning I have seen a layer of water condense on wood sprayed with shellac dissolved in "alcohol". This water precipitates the shellac as the solvent further evaporates and blushing is the result. The solution is to formulate the shellac in ethanol or ethanol/isopropanol mixture. It will take a long time to harden the shellac if there is isopropanol in the solvent, but it works to control blushing.
as soon as you kick on the exhaust fan, you are at outside conditions
There are tricks that can be used to get around that problem.
The shop where I used to work had a large attic space over the shop and the attached house. Usually it was closed off, but on hot, humid summer days, we would remove the sheet of plywood that closed off the top of the stairs. When we turned on the exhaust fan and started spraying, the hot dry air from the attic was drawn into the shop and through the spray booth. Since there is a finite amount of dry air in the attic, this only works for a limited time. Your attic probably isn't large enough to spray a whole kitchen cabinet job in one day, but it can work for a ten foot dining room table. This doesn't work in a production shop that is spraying all day long, but for small custom furniture shops it can be quite effective.
By the way, in this same shop, we needed to fix shellac blushing problems for all the same causes as nitrocellulose lacquer blush. For shellac, you can address the problem before the fact by using a solvent with less methanol or with the methanol replaced with a less volatile solvent (e.g. isobutanol, in Behkol). After the fact, when you can see the blush in the shellac or lacquer finish, wait for a drier day (or see my tip, above) and apply a light spray of the appropriate solvent, straight. As it redissolves the finish and then drys, it usually releases the moisture from the previously applied coats of finish. If it has reduced, but not eliminated the blush, do it again.
There seems to be a prevailing misunderstanding of what causes "blush". As previously described the cause of "blush" is as follows:
Blushing results when the solvent evaporates fast enough to cool the surface of the piece below the dew point of the air around what is being sprayed. Water condenses on the surface and precipitates the finish into finish particles that are not coalesced into a film. These particles scatter light and therefore appear cloudy.
There could be an additional source of light scatter. The presence of water in the surface of the drying finish could cause crazing, a complex phenomena that results in tiny cracks that scatter light.
Fixing blush is as simple as redissolving the finish particles, and possibly healing the crazing, that are scattering the light, and then redepositing the finish as a coalesced film as the solvent evaporates.
Blush has nothing to do with moisture trapped in the finish film. Water is a tiny molecule and it would diffuse out of the film readily. We know this to be a fact for a finish only slows moisture equilibration with the wood beneath the film. If trapped water was causing the cloudy appearance the clouds would part after a few days as the water diffused away. The clouds don't part ever because the particles and the air around them that results in light scatter stay that way, forever, unless the film is redissolved and redeposited.
you're doing something wrong. A properly vented attic will be warmer than outside air, but should not be much different from outside air. I also suggest you have an undersized paint booth exhaust fan for that to begin to work.
The only air intake for the shop during the spraying was the attic end vents. The air in the shop was air conditioned, so a lot of the water had been removed from that air, which is what we started with. After using up the majority of the conditioned air, the additional air from the attic had been warmed by the morning sun hitting the roof, and as long as it stayed warm as it was pulled through the spray "booth" it's temperature was close to the highest it had been in the previous several hours and it's relative humidity therefore the lowest. In both theory and practice, I think it worked.
Re: There is misunderstanding about cause of blush
William Duffield
I never took a microscope to a cross section of the blushed finish, so I can't argue the location of the water droplets that formed due to condensation. Whether they were at the surface or trapped just below the surface, the light was scattered and the blush appeared. Since I have only seen the condition occur on days with high humidity, I'm sure that water was a contributing factor. Yes, retarder helps to both smooth the surface and reduce condensation or water by reducing the rate of cooling, but the best solution to the problem is keeping your eye on the hygrometer and planning ahead.
In the case of shellac, both isopropanol and isobutanol are much less toxic than methanol, so there are multiple reasons to use them. For lacquer, about the only thing I can recommend is nitrile gloves and a respirator with fresh VOC filters, and to get everyone out of the shop as soon as possible.
Re: There is misunderstanding about cause of blush
don stephan
Are white spots and white rings that form in cured NC lacquer finishes due to a different phenomenon then? My understanding is they form when say a wet glass is left on a NC finish for a short period of time, a finish that may be several years or more old.
The white in blush and rings results from the same cause. Light is scattering off a lot of tiny air/polymer (finish) interfaces. In the case of white rings the source of the scatter is probably crazing.
My daughter has a friend who is an expert in crazing. I asked him to explain it and he said "it's complicated and not entirely understood". Summarizing what I remember........ When solvents that have certain properties are placed on a polymer with certain properties a bazillion tiny cracks form which is called crazing. The result is a white looking spot or surface. What is not fully understood are the origins of the forces that result in the cracks.
There are a couple of examples that may help to understand the phenomena. If you bend a CD (polycarbonate polymer) into a Taco shape and then put a drop of isopropanol on the bend the CD will explode into fragments. (wear safety glasses; it's impressive. ) The isopropanol caused the stressed polymer to craze. The cracks from the crazing propagated through the stressed CD and shattered it.
Water bottles are now largely made from Triton polymer. The original formulation had a fatal flaw. If you left a finger print on the surface of the bottle the polymer would craze were the oil from the finger print was left. I think the new formulation may also do this if it is heated after finger printing. Daughter thought of writing a murder mystery where this property solved the crime.
I suspect the water from a wet glass will craze dry shellac, I can't think of any other cause of the whitening. Crazing may also be involved in blushing.
All that is requited is to keep the air next to the finish above the dew point by lowering humidity, raising air temperature or slowing evaporation rate.
Hot water is worse than cold water, and alcohol worse yet. Hot buttered rum will even leave a ring on lacquer. I have some friends who think I am a magician. They had gotten a white ring on their dining room table. I showed up with a little Everclear in a squeeze bottle and a pad made from a t-shirt rag, quickly and lightly padded the ethanol over the ring and waited a few minutes. It had almost disappeared, so I waited a little longer and did it again. The ring was gone after a half hour or so. Black rings, where the damage has gone al the way through the finish and stained the wood, are a lot more difficult to fix, usually requiring stripping, bleaching, and refinishing the surface.