Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

Posts

Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

#1

Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

Doug Reynolds

Taking a couple of small Honda generators with the travel trailer. Looking for design considerations on making boxes that will help deaden their sound so as not to disturb other travelers. Wonder how to keep the airflow going and dissipate heat and exhaust while still dampening sound. Appreciate any advice.

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

#2

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

Dick Coers

Quieter Honda generators? I didn't know that was possible. What model are you talking about?

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

#3

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations *LINK*

Gary Smyth

Up front I don’t have an answer. Long ago I did some academic work on audio studios.

What you hope to achieve is very difficult given small budget, portability, and effectiveness.

There are a myriad of factors you need to consider but the first is the sound pressure level you have now with the generator at some set distance without deadening. Then you need to know the level you wish to achieve. Sound reduction levels are not a linear progression. Decibels are a logarithmic progression. There are charts available (one is linked below) that provide typical sound levels to assist you in determining how much would be acceptable to you or the neighbors

1. Mass is the easiest method to reduce sound (but not for your application).

2. Sealing the enclosure is a close second.

3. Isolation (springs, vibration isolators) of the source within a space helps prevent transfer of sound

4. There are peak levels and there are sustained levels. A peak example would be a gunshot. Sustained levels examples would be that of extended time ambient noise in an empty room.

5. You need to determine what level is acceptable at a set distance away from your enclosure.

That said, there are several things that you can experiment with that don’t cost a bundle, weigh a ton, and are relatively portable, and effective -- fiberglass batting, homosote, covered baffles, non-parallel surfaces, commercial landscaping, car, or tractor mufflers, acoustic tile, or panels of perforated metal.

Obviously, if you seal the area you will get better sound reduction, but the generators can’t operate without air. If you provide for ventilation you give the noise a pathway to the outside. All depends on what sound level is acceptable. Don’t forget heat buildup. Don't forget easy access and fuel replenishment.

No answers but perhaps a starting point

Environmental Noise

Weakest sound heard 0dB

Whisper Quiet Library at 6' 30dB

Normal conversation at 3' 60-65dB

Telephone dial tone 80dB

City Traffic (inside car) 85dB

Train whistle at 500', Truck Traffic 90dB

Jackhammer at 50' 95dB

Subway train at 200' 95dB

Level at which sustained exposure may result in hearing loss 90 - 95dB

Hand Drill 98dB

Power mower at 3' 107dB

Snowmobile, Motorcycle 100dB

Power saw at 3' 110dB

Sandblasting, Loud Rock Concert 115dB

Pain begins 125dB

Pneumatic riveter at 4' 125dB

Even short term exposure can cause permanent damage - Loudest recommended exposure WITH hearing protection 140dB

Jet engine at 100' 140dB

12 Gauge Shotgun Blast 165dB


http://www.gcaudio.com/resources/howtos/loudness.html

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

Jack Guzman from Maine

In a former life(young) I worked for a company installing Kohler generators in utility vehicles. We had a metal cabinet built with venting for exhaust and lined inside surfaces with foil backed 1"insulation board. You could do something similar with a wooden cabinet just taking into consideration the exhaust and the heat it puts out.---Jack

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

#5

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

Tom Dunlap

I've read some articles on truck camper/RV and Expedition Portal about quieting gensets.

A lot of what I read is forgotten. One suggestion that did stick with me is the admonition to not forget about doing a good job of isolating the unit from the ground. Telegraphing the vibrations isn't noticed on the genset end but it is in the distance.

When I was in college I worked for AEM...a breakaway from Timesavers...building sanding machines. One some of the large machines we glued sheets of soundproof foam. When I stood next to them the sounds of the assembly shop weren't reflected. I felt like i was going to fall into the black abyss!

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

#6

I applaud your efforts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I tent camp and camp to enjoy the outdoors. the only thing I dislike more than a generator is a leaf blower which a few sites deploy. Loud radios are near the top of the list too.

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

#7

An EU3000IS puts out 58dBa at rated load

Dick Coers

That's less than normal conversion.

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

#8

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

Tony - Memphis

I used to hang around race tracks a lot. Most of the folks had trailers with generators. You might take a look at some race trailor sites. Might be some info on what they do. I don't ever remember hearing them much and just about every trailer had one.

Tony

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

#9

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

Hank Knight

Doug,

Google "sound baffle for portable generator" and you'll get a bunch of hits. Lots of good ideqs - and some not so good. :D

Hank

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

#10

Build a box ...

Mike Farinella

from say 2 X 2s, line it with acoustical ceiling tiles (thickness X 2), then vent it.

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

#11

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

Jim Dillon

Doug, not sure what model Honda generators you are talking about, but the EU3000 series of portable units are REALLY quiet. Had some construction done last year (solar) and the crew pulled one of these out to power their tools while the main power was off. I was checking it out then suddenly realized it was actually running! I couldn't believe it. Immediately went to Amazon to check it out but couldn't justify the cost for my needs. So my advice would be to actually listen to the generator before going to the trouble of making a sound-proofing box etc. Jim

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

#12

Replace the muffler, nothing else will have as muc

Robb Carr

I've been down this path and here's what I'll tell you;

Replacing the muffler is the easiest way to reduce the noise from a generator.

Keep in mind distance is your friend in these situations, get a couple of 100' power cords and locate the generator as far away from the camp site as possible with the muffler side of the generator pointed away from you.

Stop there, because this is the best you're going to do.

Nothing else will have as much affect. Any kind of box will trap heat and shorten the life of the motor. Also, any hole or vent you provide into or put of the box will effectively nullify any benefit the box might provide. Plus, a properly constructed sound deadening box is going to be very heavy and air-tight. And for a portable generator it's another thing you have to carry, setup and store.


img

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

#13

Leo Cuellar

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

Leo Cuellar

Many years ago, a friend of mine had a '65 Falcon that the muffler had fallen off of. His solution, for when he had to drive in town, was to shove a bat of steel wool into the exhaust pipe & clamp a piece of chicken wire over the end to quiet it down. It was very effective for about 20 miles before the heat & pressure would disintegrate it.

An arrangement of several thinner layers with space between, might be an effective sound baffle without restricting the exhaust flow.

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

#14

That sounds like an episode of Red Green show 


Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

#15

Hey Doug, you gonna check back in?

Dick Coers

We can't help a lot if you don't help us here!

Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

#16

Leo Cuellar

True dat, but 10 years earlier   


Re: Generator Quiet Box Design Considerations

#17

Checking In

Doug Reynolds

Lots of good ideas. I'll do some further research but agree a plywood box with insulation of some sort will be mighty heavy and, may not be worth the effort.