Good morning! I'm on the home stretch now, wrapping up what's left to complete the Butler's desk. I've finished installing the lock for the desk drawer and detailed the installation here;
That is the prettiest keyhole I have seen. I hate making them because mine never come out crisp and symmetrical. Never thought of chamfering the opening. Nice touch.
Thanks Bill! Much appreciated as that was nerve wracking to cut on an otherwise finished piece.....less the stay which I'm still working on.
Did you prefer this approach where I do it more like a tutorial than a walk-through?
I ran into a historic example of a similar desk in a shop near me, its about 200~ years old. Got into a good conversation with the owner and ended up finding out that while 200 years old there was absolutely nothing made to prevent the accidental drop and damage of the desk. Just the implication that one needs to pull out the supports prior to opening was enough to keep it intact over 200 years of use and probably 5 years sitting idle in a shop and being handled by many people.
It was encouraging and yet still....i pursue the stay, haha.
That sapwood is interesting. From what my sawyer tells me, the sapwood on walnut trees that are fairly old starts to get to be that mid brown color. The color of the picture with the keyhole is pretty accurate, more so than the other pictures
The tree is about 125-150~ years old from what I was told.
I also appreciate your thoughts on the stay, I'll run it by my client and see what he thinks, ultimately if he is comfortable with it then I will dump the stay.
The sap wood on a 200 year old tree is the same age as the sap wood on a 20 year old tree. I have seen a lot of walnut sawed and don't agree with what you were told. It color will have more to do with how long it has been exposed to light and air.
Interesting. I know you are very experienced in this area and I know the sawyer has been sawing wood longer than I have been alive, so next time I see him I will ask for clarification.
While the most recent rings under the bark would be the same age sapwood, it has been my observation that the thickness of the sapwood, can be relative to the thickness of the bark. Thus, on a young tree the bark will be thinner, with wider / faster growing, spaced rings, than a 150 year old tree with thick bark and thin rings. The young tree may have about 10 years of sapwood, while the older tree with thick bark may have 50.
If that 150 year old tree was hit by lightning 75 years ago which knocked a 3" wide strip of bark off there will always be a thinner 3" line of bark over that scar for the next 75 years, which will induce a offset in the transition from sapwood into heartwood. I think that transition of sapwood into heartwood has something to do with the amount of air passing through the bark affecting the phloem.
However, another thing that I found mysterious when I had a large walnut log, which was not suitable for my mill, but great for my turnings. After laying on my parking lot maybe 6 months to a year, when I cut off a short section to get bowl blanks out of, the sapwood on the bottom had changed about the same as steaming does. I don't know if this had more to do with the tea made from rain flowing down got richer as it flowed down and soaked in. So if the sawyer had the log around a while, maybe under a sprinkling system.
Having said all that, you don't have to speculate that it is "125-150~", You can count the rings on the end grain when you open the door. It appears that the pith isn't too far from about 4" up from the bottom on the right side, and the top L corner hints at cambium. Walnut annual rings are lost on the face of that rift part, but you should be able to see them easily on the end, with magnification, so all you need to do is count them to determine the actual age of your wood.
You wouldn't believe how many time I've been offered trees that were suppose to be 150 ~ 250 years old, and maybe even have old historic photos of a tree in the same location that are claimed to be it. More times than not, there may be another generation or two between the ancestral tree and these.
I would like to see an example of 50 year old walnut sapwood. It has been my experience that a fast growing tree will have thick sapwood, up to 3" thick. A tree in old age will typically have 1" of sapwood which is why I like to get logs from trees nearing death.
I have never measured it but I speculate that walnut sapwood is about the same age regardless of the trees' age, that is to say the sapwood is 10 or 15 years old regardless. The ring spacing and total thickness changes but not the age. I'll investigate next time I am on a log yard with walnut.