Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Walnut Sawdust in the Garden

Posts

Walnut Sawdust in the Garden

#1

Walnut Sawdust in the Garden

Heather

I found information on this site concerning the use of kiln dried walnut shavings being used without any problems seen in the plants. I was wondering if anyone had any information about using sawdust from a walnut tree that has not been kiln dried but let dry naturally. The sawdust in question comes from a tree that was downed this past winter. It was cut into several large pieces and left lay for awhile. We brought it into the garage about 2 months ago and it is mostly dried out. We have gotten 2 large bags of sawdust for it. I recently mixed the sawdust in with soil in potato grow sacks and for planting in the flower garden. I did this before I knew about walnut. I guess I will see how the plants do. I was just wondering if anyone knew if this was going to be a problem.

Re: Walnut Sawdust in the Garden

#2

Re: Walnut Sawdust in the Garden

John Veerkamp

In my experience, not a problem. I've used walnut in the garden for years.

Re: Walnut Sawdust in the Garden

#3

Ellis Walentine

Re: Walnut Sawdust in the Garden *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

My science here isn't perfect, so please indulge me. The usual complaints about walnut have to do with the chemical Juglone that is given off by the root system and which is actually lethal to many plants. Only certain species of plants will survive under the canopy of walnut trees. The sawdust, IIRC, doesn't contain (much of) this chemical. And, I can't imagine any difference between kiln-dried sawdust and air-dried.

The problem with sawdust -- any sawdust -- in the garden is that it is not a good medium since it robs nitrogen from the soil. I only use it to mulch pathways between raised beds. My old pal Mike McGrath has summed up the sawdust argument convincingly on the Gardens Alive website. Click the link below to read all about it...

Ellis Walentine, Host


Sawdust in the Garden

Re: Walnut Sawdust in the Garden

#4

Re: Walnut Sawdust in the Garden

Yonak

Heather, an on-line search will yield lots of good information about this subject. The important things to keep in mind, in my opinion are : There is a smaller group of plants that are intolerant to juglone, the subject chemical in walnut and, to a lesser extent hickory, trees than are tolerant of it. Your search will provide this list.

Also, juglone is concentrated mostly in the roots, nut hulls and buds, to a lesser extent in the bark, leaves and twigs, and least of all in the trunk and branches of a tree. This is why it is recommended not to plant certain species within the drip line of live walnut trees.

I don't know if kiln drying has any effect on modifying the concentration of juglone but, as it is water soluble, it does wash out pretty quickly if it is allowed to compost for a short time.

Bottom line for me : except that the fibres don't break down very quickly, I would have no problem with putting walnut sawdust in my compost pile.

Re: Walnut Sawdust in the Garden

#5

disagree with some points

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

First an agreement. I think I have read that the wood contains juglone. But this chemical is not very stable out in the environment. I expect it will decompose quickly once exposed to air. In any case I mulch tomatoes and peppers with dry ( air and KD) walnut sawdust and chips without any noticeable effect. There is a potential problem with sawdust. It compacts when used too liberally as mulch and could exclude oxygen. I usually use the pure dust in walkways and the chips and shavings as mulch.

"The problem with sawdust -- any sawdust -- in the garden is that it is not a good medium since it robs nitrogen from the soil."

I find Mike McGrath's lack of scientific knowledge entertaining but the notions that come from this state can offer unreliable guidance in the garden.

Bacterial and fungal growth requires a source of biologically available nitrogen- nitrate, ammonia, urea, protein, etc. Vigorous growth requires a lot of nitrogen. The sugars in fresh/green chips and sawdust will support a vigorous growth of bacteria and fungus which can temporarily deplete the nitrogen in the surrounding soil, or compost pile. When these critters die they give back the nitrogen they took up in the form of protein which decomposes to nitrogen available to the plant.

Dry wood waste decomposes at a very slow rate. Here in TN it takes a year to decompose shavings and sawdust in my garden, where I use it liberally, along with partially composted wood chips, for mulch around plants. This slow rate will have no significant effect on the nitrogen available to surrounding plants. I snag a load of wood chips any time the tree trimmers are working nearby. After composting a few months I used it as needed.

Unlike Mike McGrath I do not believe that ammonia and urea from poop is any different from these chemicals made from methane. Hence, I use these synthetic fertilizers as a nitrogen source as needed, but I never had to add these fertilizers to compensate for the slow rate of dry wood decomposition. .

Re: Walnut Sawdust in the Garden

#6

On Wood Decomposition

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The agents that break down wood are fungi not bacteria. Spalting is the visual evidence of their presence and activity as they break down both lignin and cellulose. Fungi are, after all, vegetable organisms, and need nitrogen and water to "grow" and be active. These fungi are pretty slow growers and will be inhibited by a lack of water or nutrients. Since wood is not a great concentration of nitrogen, we can increase decomposition (to get spalted coloring or mulch-feeding) by adding nitrogen (Urea - 46-0-0 is great) and keeping the wood wet. If the moisture content of the wood drops below about 20% the fungi go dormant.

If you want faster decomposition of your sawdust, add some urea and keep it wet.

BTW 46-0-0 is available at most garden/farm stores. It is about the same stuff they repackage and sell at 20 times the price in the pet stores as ice melter that won't hurt dog's paws in the winter.

Re: Walnut Sawdust in the Garden

#7

I stopped reading after...

Tom Dunlap

...the second paragraph of the response.

Too broad a statement saying that sawdust will make the soil dead. Oh, sure, if you pile it on in a thick layer. Wait, that won't kill the soil it just isn't a very good layer for plants to live/grow in.

So many myths about sawdust and chips as mulch. Then, another use, soil amendments. These are two different things.

I've attended many sessions at arborist's conferences/workshops where real research about mulch/compost are discussed...for years! The common take-away...don't worry about nitrogen deficiency unless you're concerned with single digit differences in soil performance. Yes...there is very small amount of nitrogen used but it's negligible.

The overall benefits of adding mulch of any kind is offset by the short term miniscule drop in nitrogen.

Re: Walnut Sawdust in the Garden

#8

Re: On Wood Decomposition

Walt

"BTW 46-0-0 is available at most garden/farm stores. It is about the same stuff they repackage and sell at 20 times the price in the pet stores as ice melter that won't hurt dog's paws in the winter."

Yup. It used to used for airport deicing because unlike salt it's not corrosive. I don't know if it's still used for that purpose or not. We use it on our sidewalks, the only downside is if it's been an icy winter, come springtime the grass next to the sidewalks grows REALLY well;-) Still I think it's better for the local water supply to use urea over salt though they both have their issues.

Re: Walnut Sawdust in the Garden

#9

Ric Taylor

Re: Walnut Sawdust in the Garden

Ric Taylor

Aside from the specifics regarding walnut (and I've heard the same comments from a few people about mesquite), consider this:

Is there any difference between buying a bag of wood mulch and putting it around your bushes, and putting your wood shavings and sawdust around your bushes? There is no difference at all.

Re: Walnut Sawdust in the Garden

#10

Re: Walnut Sawdust in the Garden

Ron Pemberton

Ric, my nursery person explained to me this way. Wood mulch is relatively big chips where sawdust is a lot smaller. Even with any kind of mulch you don't put it around the base of the plant and it tends to stay where you put it whereas sawdust packs more and tends to move when you water. Mulch, being bigger allows for air and water to pass thru where sawdust packs to much for this to happen.

Re: Walnut Sawdust in the Garden

#11

ebd

+1 on this