Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

!2" Slider...DW or Bosch?

Posts

!2" Slider...DW or Bosch?

#1

!2" Slider...DW or Bosch?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Here's the thing...I have had a Makita 12" sliding compound saw for 3 years and I'm throwing in the towel with it. I know that many rave about Makitas. I'm not here to trash it. But I have had all kinds problems with this saw and it's time to move on.

Before anyone tells me to get a Festool Kapex...thanks, but no way I'll ever pay that much for a miter saw.

I want a saw that has a wide cross cut capacity and is dead on accurate. After a bunch of research I am between 2 saws. The DeWalt DWS780 and the Bosch GCM 12SD. I'm leaning a little to the Dewalt but I like that the Bosch has an arm that reduces the set-back from the wall.

I cut a LOT of really big 12/4+ timbers and need a saw that has the brute to do that, but also one that can accurately make very fine cuts as well.

Okay, thanks in advance for any input!!

T.

Re: !2" Slider...DW or Bosch?

#2

Bosch?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Two suggestions

Look at 10" saws from Bosch and Hitachi. They should cut your 12/4 but the 10" blades are more accurate for fine work.

I had real issues with my Makita LS 1211 until I put a full (1/8") kerf blade on it. Bullet proof since then. The 12" saws put thin kerf blades on to ease the cut load, but the blades wiggle and flex when cutting hardwood and thick sections. Couldn't get a decent miter until I changed the blades.

Re: !2" Slider...DW or Bosch?

#3

Re: !2" Slider...DW or Bosch?

John K Jordan

Tom, I have the 12" Bosch and like it a lot. The "axial glide" (pivot) system is very smooth, can't clog with sawdust or whatever, and takes less space in the rear than others. I got it when starting on my new shop and cut a bunch of 4x6, 2x10, 2x12, etc., and an entire bundle of 2x6-10s for studs. For 4x12 you'll have to provide additional board support.

Most of my use has been at 90 deg so I can't evaluate the precision of compound angle cuts.

JKJ

Re: !2" Slider...DW or Bosch?

#4

Re: !2" Slider...DW or Bosch?

Mike Circo

Have you considered a radial arm saw?

Mine is more accurate than any miter saw I've tried.

Granted, it's halfway across the state, but here is a beauty!

https://peoria.craigslist.org/tls/5625561102.html

Re: !2" Slider...DW or Bosch?

#5

Ellis Walentine

Crazy notion

Ellis Walentine

In the good old days, I had a 15" Hitachi that I used for larger timbers. It was only a chop saw, but it could cut fairly wide stock (6"-8" IIRC) up to 6" (?) thick, with great precision. I had a smaller slider in those days for routine and smaller-scale work. I know these things aren't cheap, but I thought I'd throw it out there as one possibility.

Ellis

Re: !2" Slider...DW or Bosch?

#6

Re: !2" Slider...DW or Bosch?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Thanks Mike. Tempting but I only have a budget for the SLCS at the moment.

T.

Re: !2" Slider...DW or Bosch?

#7

Not quite so crazy.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

My miter saw is built in between two benches. The benches serve as infeed and outfeed supports. It is possible that some day I might set up a tandem solution.

Mike suggested an RAS. Generally I don't like RASs for much else than cross cutting. But a good RAS, well tuned, can crosscut like a champ.

But for now, my focus is on a SCMS.

But your general idea of a 2 saw solution might someday be the ultimate solution.

T.

Re: !2" Slider...DW or Bosch?

#8

I had a similar Ryobi

Dick Coers

I sure didn't want to take a hair off a big crown with it, but when you needed BIG, it sure helped. I had the Hitachi 7.5" sliding compound for precision in those days! Now I have the Festool. Hated paying for it, but I sure smile when I use it!

Re: !2" Slider...DW or Bosch?

#9

Dewalt 12' slider vs Bosch 10' slider

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

I got a chance to use my neighbors Dewalt 12" slider when we were building a fence between our houses, not exactly a precision or long term test drive but it struck me as a very capable framing tool on a par with the Dewalt circular saw I own. At school we have a Bosch 10" slider, not the glide saw you asked about but it seems a bit more like a furniture making tool vs a framing tool, but I have not gotten to really put it through its paces and use my Starrett tools to check the results.

I went a different direction in my shop, probably due to my background as a patternmaker. I don't have a slider or a compound miter saw. I have an old Makita 10" miter saw, the one with a cast iron table and a huge 3" knuckle of a hinge. For compound angles I use my disc sander. Actually most of the time I use my disc sander for any angles and even for straight 90* stuff. It's not everyone's cup of tea but I can be more accurate on a disc sander than any saw.

Re: !2" Slider...DW or Bosch?

#10

Re: Dewalt 12' slider vs Bosch 10' slider

William Duffield

I knew there was a reason I bought the PM 31a belt/disc sander! Thanks for the tip, Robin. It may be just what I need to complement my radial arm saw. And you just may have saved me from another Festool "investment."