Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Varnish/Urethane

Posts

Varnish/Urethane

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

Varnish/Urethane

Jack Guzman from Maine

I have a recipe for a wipe on finish for sealing milk paint. It calls for equal parts BLO mineral spirits and Spar varnish. My local hardware store only has something labeled as Spar Urethane. Is this the same product with a different name? If not ,will it work the same way or should I go elsewhere and find the real thing?---Jack

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#2

a better idea

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The problem with these home made wiping recipes is that the addition of the oil leaves them soft after curing. The properties of the altered varnish have been substantially compromised from the unaltered product If you need wiping varnish that is durable then buy a product formulated to be a wiping varnish. They are made by altering the properties of the uncured resin components to lower initial viscosity and probably cure time without compromising the properties of the cured varnish.

Fine Woodworking reviewed many wiping varnishes a few years ago. Choose one with properties suitable for your needs.

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#3

Re: Varnish/Urethane

John Veerkamp

Jack,

I just use polyurethane for sealing Milk paint. Satin finish.

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#4

Re: Varnish/Urethane

John in NM

Real spar varnish seems to be harder and harder to find. McCloskey's used to be the stuff, but around here it now says spar urethane too.

I think I would use Waterlox original sealer for that myself rather than making a wiping varnish for the task.

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#5

Re: Varnish/Urethane

John McGaw

Yep. I've been using satin water-based poly over milk paint for years. It is painless and cheap and it cures hard and fast. It is important to rub down the milk paint before coating since the poly will permanently preserve any lumps bumps and imperfections. I decided that poly was an improvement over the coating that the Old Fashioned Milk Paint Company sells being both thinner and less prone to brush marks.

If there is a downside to clear poly is that under some lighting conditions iit seems to give black a slightly bluish tint that might be objectionable but this is probably preferable to the muddy orange-yellow cast that oil or varnish would invariably give to every other color.

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: a better idea

Jack Guzman from Maine

I got this recipe from Curtis Buchanan. I like it because it gets a very pleasing result. I know nothing about finishes and every time I try to make sense out of any of it I get lost. I figure Curtis has been doing this long enough his method is well tested. I won't try to out think him on something I know absolutely nothing about.

I just need to know if this stuff is the same thing as spar varnish.---Jack

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Varnish/Urethane

Jack Guzman from Maine

The problem is that there are so many different finishes available I never know what to try so I go with what the experts use. In this case ,Curtis Buchanan recommends the recipe I am following. ---Jack

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#8

Getting Rid of Blue

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

John,

A number of waterborne polys, notably Minwax, will cure to a "cool" or bluish cast due to the refractive index of the cured film. In the context of the borgs, Varathane seems to give a more neutral coating. It's also easy to kill the blue in what you've got by adding a drop or two (depending on volume) of TransTint Amber concentrate to warm up the color a smidge.

If you go to a better grade of waterborne poly finish like General Finishes Hi-Per or Enduro Clear, you'll be better off from the get-go.

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#9

Ellis Walentine

Conjecture

Ellis Walentine

I don't like to venture guesses, but here goes. Spar varnish has been around longer than polyurethane varnish, so if Curtis is talking about the old, original resin mixture (if there ever was one -- doubtful) in spar varnishes of yore, your spar urethane probably isn't the same animal.

Ellis

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#10

Spar Varnish *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Jack,

You'll find the real stuff at a marine supply place. The link is one, but up where you are it shouldn't be tough to find a boaters store you can drive to and ask the warm bodies for help.


Jamestown Dist.

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#11

Re: Spar Varnish

William Duffield

The brands of real spar varnish that I trust are Sikkins Cetol and Epifanes. In addition to Jamestown, they are available from West Marine and Chesapeake Lightcraft. By definition, spar varnish is soft, and remains flexible under adverse weather conditions. It also has UV blockers, which give it a yellow-brown cast. You need to be aware of how that color will change the final color of your finish when you apply it over the pigmented milk paint, so you can choose an appropriate color. It goes without saying that experimentation on scrap is essential.

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#12

Personal Ideas

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Jack,

Don't know Mr. Buchanan, but will note that many woodworkers who do a lot of finishing tend to concentrate on a particular formula. The danger is that we will tend to close off further knowledge in favor of our personal "tried-and-true" routine. Just because Mr. Buchanan has been "doing it for a long time" doesn't mean his method is the best for what you want to do.

You haven't told us what you're finishing or the paint color you're trying to a) seal and b) ultimately get for the piece. Since you've come to WoodCentral with your question, you'll find a great deal of knowledge here if you allow yourself to consider alternate methods to get you where you want to go on the item you're finishing.

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#13

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Personal Ideas

Jack Guzman from Maine

Hi Mark,

What I am doing is following a complex chair building recipe. Complete from harvesting a tree to final finish. I do a five step two-color black wash coat over red milk paint finish. I rub this out then seal it with the oil varnish mix. I have been learning from these forums for alot of years and I listen to all suggestions but I don't wish to change any part of this recipe. It works very well.I've done it many times successfully. I just want to know where to get the ingredients. thank you.---Jack

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#14

Fair Enough

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Find a boat yard; they'll have the right varnish. ;)

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#15

Start here *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

You'll meet one of the true masters of chairmaking. Have a lot of your favorite beverage available. The series is 52 segments long and exceedingly thorough. No one does this better.


Curtis Buchanan Windsor Chairs

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#16

spar varnish meaningless

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Spar varnish denotes the properties of the finish not what is in it. Hence, there is no chance you will replicate Curtis's finish unless you use exactly what Curits uses. That said, Curits probably can't exactly replicate his finish because manufacturers are always changing what is in them while the label stays the same. BTW, when he demonstrated chair finishing for our cub he used linseed oil only. But he did complain that his joint problems precluded him from the rubbing that he traditionally used with this finish and he therefore was using a helper for rubbing. It may be that this spar varnish formula is a replacement for just linseed oil.

I think you will find that any wipe on varnish will seal milk paint nicely. And as always finsh a test piece before doing chemistry experiments on the final piece.

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#17

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Spar varnish denotes the properties of the finish not what is in it"

And these properties are of no importance to finishing furniture. A chair does not need a flexible finish nor one that is out door stable. Within the realm of finishes that are suitable for a boat there will be dozens of resin and stabilizer formulations called "spar varnish".

Email Curtis and he will gladly tell you what he uses. But this one is a no brainer. Any wipe on will work.

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#18

Re: Spar Varnish

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I will bet that Curtis does not use a boat finish. These finishes are very dark. Their main attribute is that they last a long time in the sun, hardly a requirement for a chair.

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#19

Re: Varnish/Urethane *LINK*

John in NM

I think the best route is probably to try a few varieties of "spar varnish" and see whether it matters.

A few manufacturers still make actual spar varnish - Epifanes, Sutherland Welles, & I think Waterlox make them.

There is also the outfit in the link.... I've never used any but the Waterlox marine and McCloskey's. McCloskey's might still be actual oil varnish, but since Valspar now owns them I bet its a urethane.

For your application, I doubt it matters much - a gloss urethane mixed 50/50 with BLO will give you the same result as a spar varnish so mixed.


http://www.epoxyproducts.com/varnish.html

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#20

Jack Guzman from Maine

Thanks for the responses

Jack Guzman from Maine

I guess I need to try this stuff to see if it works the same.

I was just reading Peter Galbert's blog and he uses the same mix. I sent Curtis Buchanan an email asking if it makes a difference. Maybe he can answer that question.---Jack

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#21

Re: Varnish/Urethane

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Jack,

Stephen Shepherd used to recommend Ace Hardware's Spar Varnish, as being non poly-urethane etc.

Bob in NJ

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#22

Last but not least....

Tony - Memphis

I always refer to my finishing bibles by Flexner and Dresdner. I think they both do a real good job explaining the various finsihes and what they really are beyond the lable. Great references. Let us know what you find out! Can't wait to see the finished project too.

Tony

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#23

Buchanan Chairs

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I've no doubt he has mastered what he does.

Not for nothin', but I have no interest in making Windsor chairs or other pieces like them.

As I said, I don't know him, but on looking at the link, I was reminded of what he does, have seen his fine pieces several times, and have had several friends who have followed his lead.

Re: Varnish/Urethane

#24

Re: Start here

john lucas

I took a course from Curtiss probably 15 years ago or more. That chair has been used daily and still works just like new. Curtiss is a great teacher and I had a blast in the class.