Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Any HVAC gurus here?

Posts

Any HVAC gurus here?

#1

Any HVAC gurus here?

Keith Newton

About 25 years ago, my sister and late BIL drilled a couple of wells in the yard in order to switch to water-source heat pump, rather than keeping the standard heat-pump that has to work harder when the weather is either really hot, or really cold. The water in the well, is always 55º which should make it much more efficient, when you consider that over the next couple of months, the high for the day will be close to 100º.

The warranty on this unit just ran out a month ago, and the problems are already starting, just like the last one before it did. Now they are trying to sell her on giving up on the water-source, and trying to sell her on buying the standard type, saying they are more efficient. I'm finding that hard to believe. How can we compare these apples and oranges?

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

#2

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

Mark Nowicki

You can compare the cost of apples to the cost of oranges. You don't need a guru.

The usual method is a Net Present Value analysis, NPV calculators can be found all over the internet.

An NPV analysis requires that emotions, prejudices, beliefs are cast aside (or quantified) and only the future cash events are considered. Difficult for most people.

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

#3

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

Barry Irby

25 years ago earth coupled heat pumps made more sense than today. Air to air units had a SEER Rating of about 9 and the Earth coupled ones were at about 16 or 18. That dramatic difference helped offset the costs of installing wells and ditching etc. In the mean time Air to air units have improved dramatically and builder grade units have a seer rating of 14 and up graded units can be much higher, surpassing earth coupled units.

What makes your computation difficult is that you already have the wells etc. Installing an Air to Air unit might be more expensive that putting in a new earth coupled unit. Mark's Present Value Calculator could help you there. Locally, standard heat pups last about 12 to 14 years. Earth coupled units are supposed to last twice that. (Richmond VA) There are lots of people that can install and maintain standard units. When an Earth coupled unit breaks down, Who you going to call? Ghost Busters?

Look into the ductless systems. Very Efficient. Expensive to install. Seer Ratings of 18 to 24 are common.

I will leave you to look up SEER, Seasonal Energy Efficiency Rating.

And, as an Old Fuddy Duddy, I stay away from the exotic. I woudl buy the most standard system I could and take the savings and up grade my insulation and envelope sealing.

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

#4

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

We have heated and cooled our house with a geothermal heat pump using two wells for over 35 years. About 6 years ago we replaced our heat only unit with a heat/cooling unit for about $3500, about the same cost as a conventional a/c system. Other than changing filters, it has required zero service in those 6 years.

You don't say where your sister lives, but if she lives where the outside temperature falls below 35 degrees, air source heat pumps do not do well at those temperatures, even the latest and greatest ones. I have a friend that just installed a top of the line Mistubishi air to air heat pump last summer and in our mild winter in northwestern Pa last year there were weeks where he had to use a pellet stove to keep his house reasonably warm because the heat pump couldn't keep up. My water source heat pump had no problems at all. We live less than 2 miles apart.

As far as who are you going to call. There are at least 3 dealers in our town that sell and service ground source heat systems. Find a dealer that sells ground source heat pumps and work with them.

Lee

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

#5

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

Mark Nowicki

<>

Actually, Barry, it doesn't.

Moneys sunk in the wells are "sunk costs", (sorry for the pun). They are not considered in NPV calculations.

Usually, this is the part where the emotions come in.

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

#6

Why can't I copy and paste???


Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

#7

Re: Why can't I copy and paste???

Stuart Johnson

Try CTRL-V (or whatever the MAC uses) instead of the right click. I don't know why but sometimes the CTRL-C and CTRL-V works when clicking doesn't.

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

#8

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

Keith Newton

Lee, Little Rock is ~35º N so a good bit South of your latitude. She does have a natural gas stove on the lower level that she can turn on if the power goes out in cold weather, or to boost in extremely cold periods.

I recently installed a natural gas generator for when her power goes out. She had to use it last night actually. We had a storm blow through here that has left 100,000 customers without power this morning, so she was happy to have it.

About the installer and service company. The company that initially installed it, has been bought by one of the largest companies in the state, so who knows what that merger will mean for the future! I suspect it will be all about selling new product, more than servicing older existing units.

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

#9

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

As the outside temperature drops there is less heat to recover. On most systems at ~28°F the first 5KW strip is allowed to turn on. As each additional 5° drop occurs another 5Kw strip is enabled. Since the outside coil is below freezing it ices up. Combine the strip heaters and increasing defrost cycles, you are recovering NOTHING! Heat pumps work best in Florida where it rarely drops below 45°F.

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

#10

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

John McGaw

The assumption there seems to be that the efficiency of the geothermal units haven't been improving over the intervening years. You can easily buy units now with EER ratings of 50+. The real difference will be a guesstimate of how long any given type of unit will last, the difference in installed costs and the cost of energy over the lifetime of either type. Not easy. Personally, I'd love to have geothermal rather than my present setup but I probably won't live long enough, or at least live here long enough, to make it pay off.

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

#11

doesn't match my epxperience

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We usually have near zero +/- weather for a few days each year. Our 23 year old unit heats fine in the winter. The auxiliary resistance heat only comes on when it is well below 20 F. If I recall correctly the "extra" efficiency of our unit goes to zero at less than 20 F. If the outside temperature is expected to be in the low teens we just switch to resistance heat s the heat pump part doesn't run continuous.

We live on a river. We considered a water system but the installation cost was boggling, for no reason I could see. I thought it would never pay off.

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

#12

Re: Why can't I copy and paste???

David Bair

Apple:command+c to copy, command+v to paste.

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

#13

Sunk Costs???? Hmmm?????

Barry Irby

I am (Vaguely) familiar with the phrase "Sunk Cost is not a consideration". I am not an economist and don't even play one on TV.

It seems to me that sunk costs woudl not be a consideration, AFTER they are sunk.

BUT, if you are considering a Earth Coupled heat pump at say $10,000 (including the wells) against an air to air unit at $4500, that initial cost would come into play. Maybe because it has not been sunk yet.???

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

#14

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

Jim Hoeller

I've had geo-thermal heating/cooling in a new house for about 5 years and have been very pleased with it's performance. The one night when temperatures dropped to -20 degrees fahrenheit the unit performed well and did not need to use the back-up high wattage electric elements.

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

#15

Re: Sunk Costs???? Hmmm?????

Mark Nowicki

The wells were put in 25 years ago.

The question appears to be; keep the old heat pump and repair as necessary

or install a new, more efficient heat pump.

Only costs that are relevant are the future repair costs and higher energy bills, vs

initial large cash outlay and future savings.

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

#16

thanks everyone

Keith Newton

She has a good friend from church who's late husband and three sons have a commercial HVAC business, that are going to guide her through this decision process.

Re: Any HVAC gurus here?

#17

Re: doesn't match my epxperience

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Bill: I spent from 1968 to 2009 doing residential, commercial, and institutional HVAC. I did it in North Florida, South Carolina, and North Carolina. I spent eight years on the other side of the HVAC parts counter. I held a NC Refrigeration Contractors License. Everything I said about heat pumps was standard procedure in these areas. Humidity and coil temps below zero makes ice. This makes defrost necessary. When auxilliary strips are on, the HP loses efficiency. Is Tennessee a desert with no humidity?