Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Need screen door construction suggestions

Posts

Need screen door construction suggestions

#1

Need screen door construction suggestions

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

Hello all,

We need a new screen door for our porch and I was wondering what you all think wrt constructing a new one. The existing door is made entirely from treated lumber, but sagged and twisted IMO due to poor construction methods and possibly choice of material.

For decay-resistance, I believe my options are to use treated lumber, walnut, cherry, or cedar. I have not found locust locally and presume I will need to add an exterior finish regardless of wood choice.

The rails and stiles on current door (38” x 87”) are 1.5” thick. I like the thickness and think a 1x door will be too flimsy.

My current plan: use cedar from Menards, and construct using loose tenons in all the joints including the lattice in the lower half of the door (to add stiffness).

What do you think and what would you do differently?


Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#2

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

George Koch

Paul, It appears to me from the top photo that the bottom left jamb (hinge side) is twisted way in which would throw the top right corner of the door out an equal amount. This I think is half of the problem. It also looks like the door was made from 2x lumber with no thru tenons or even half lap joints. Manufactured full screen doors like this that have full thru tenons still have a tendency to sag due to the full screen design. Is there any way to make the lattice structural enough to prevent this from happening. George

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#3

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

Keith Newton

The mitered corners are a mistake. Just let the rails butt into the styles then use your loose tenons.

You could stay with the pressure treated lumber, but I would look for QS, or edge-grain as it is called in softwood. Even if you have to drop down to 5/4" x 6deck boards to find a enough clear material.

You could take care of the sag with a turnbuckle, which is common on screen doors.

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#4

Exactly

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Mitered corners work for picture frames; not doors

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#5

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

William Duffield

Not cherry - it has insignificant rot resistance. If you need to use a hardwood, you might consider white oak, but cedar will work fine. Use pinned mortise and tenon joinery, waterproof glue and a marine spar varnish with UV inhibitors.

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#6

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

I made a similar sized screen door out of 1 1/16" bass wood for the tack room of my parents barn. I used bass wood because it was free and I butted the rails to the stiles with biscuits and non waterproof glue. it was painted with a water based poly and that was 15 years ago. It could stand to be sanded and refinished, but it has not sagged or warped. If I could have made it out of my choice of wood I would have picked old growth redwood or douglas fir. I definitely would not make it more than 1 1/16" thick and I would also not use hardwood.

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#7

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

Dick Coers

Add another hinge on your new door, and bigger. Also a wide bottom rail helps with the sagging. Not uncommon on screen doors to add an angled cross rod with turnbuckle to also help with sagging.

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#8

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

Barry Irby

All good advice so far. If I were to use Treated wood, I woudl find a yard that sells Kiln Dried After Treatment (KDAT) or Air dried After Treatment (ADAT) and use that. Even if I were using the wet stuff from the borg, I woudl buy oversized pieces like a 2 x 12 and rip the edges off it. With care, you can find some that is straight grained, and quarter sawn (Vertical Grain in soft wood) on the face and free of knots. I'd bring it indoors and let it dry if necessary. Rip the pieces over sized so they can be straightened later if necessary. Or lay them out in the sun and cook them a bit to test the gods of warping. Might reduce the thickness to 1 3/8 or 1 1/4".

Narrow stiles and a wide rail at the bottom. An angled tension rod. Three brass hinges. Sturdy joints. Healthy loose tenons. Water proof glue, Etc.

If cedar were available I would use that.

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#9

Ellis Walentine

Shoulders

Ellis Walentine

All doors want to sag. Customary anti-sag approaches include turnbuckles, gussets (think gingerbread corners), rigid panels, diagonal bracing, etc. Your porch design won't easily allow for any of those, but you could greatly increase the sag resistance by making your center and/or bottom rails wider, and, at the same time, using joinery that will keep those shoulders absolutely tight. If those joints can't pull or shrink apart, the shoulder contact area prevents racking in that plane. The taller the shoulders, the more racking they resist. From a design standpoint, your center rail should be the same height as the adjacent structures anyhow, and I'd make the bottom rail taller as well. You could probably do both with 2x6s. Loose tenon joinery with boatbuilder's epoxy should keep the joints tight enough to ensure good shoulder contact for a long time.

Clear finishes on exterior wood require maintenance. I like to start with three coats of spar varnish at the outset and another coat annually to keep the wood looking natural. Siding stains are an easier regime to maintain.

Ellis

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#10

agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1' to 1 1/4' is plenty thick enough. The ones I have made are 1 1/16". I used shouldered tenons and they have not sagged in 23 years. Any wood will work fine. If finished, rot is not an issue to be concerned with. I used white pine.

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#11

Disagree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have made several screen doors. None have sagged. The heavier the materials the more the sagging force. My doors are typically 2 3/4x 1 1/16", with one cross piece about hip height because that is where you will be bumping it to open it when your arms are full. If made of lightweight wood there will be little force to distort the frame.

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#12

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

Grant in Iowa

Hi Paul,

I would change at least two things about the existing door:

I would not miter the corners of the outer frame as in the original. Instead I'd use loose tenons, preferably enough or large enough to be about a third of the surface area of the butt joint.

I would consider adding some triangles, either via a wooden feature, or by installing the threaded screen door turnbuckles widely available. There's a reason Grandma and Grandpa's door lasted so long, and I think the turnbuckles that were standard so long ago had a hand in keeping them from racking.

I do not know what woods you have available, but Cypress, Black Locust, and Walnut would all do well. I made some Walnut basement window sashes fifteen years ago and they are as solid as when I made them. of course they were painted.

Plan to put a proper sealer, finish, or paint on (and in) the surface. I like what boat builder suppliers offer. Jamestown Distributing offers great products.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#13

Ellis Walentine

Not sure...

Ellis Walentine

... what you disagree with, my statement about shoulders resisting sag proportionate to their height, or my reference to 2x6s. I stand firmly by my shoulder statement and, while I would personally be using thinner wood for a screen door, I wasn't about to tell Paul that he couldn't use 1 1/2" stock if it suited the look of the porch and his personal preferences. What's the beef?

Ellis

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#14

Re: Not sure...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

2 x 6's are counter productive. The heavier the material the greater the need for antisagging engineering.

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#15

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

I will definitely use wider rails, but am undecided about whether to structurally incorporate lattice into the bottom section merely due to the extra time and effort. The existing lattice is just screwed on and does nothing except add weight to the door. The use of a turnbuckle is a good idea, but I would like to avoid using one unless absolutely necessary. So using 1.25” thick wood with wider rails, good joints and glue seems like a good start in that direction. I will add a third hinge as suggested and will find a good finish.

Thanks for all of the input.

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#16

Ellis Walentine

Agree

Ellis Walentine

... but it is entirely possible to make a 2X door that doesn't sag. That's for Paul to decide.

Ellis

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#17

yes but........

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It will look like a barn door not a screen door.

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#18

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

Larry Copas

One starts by choosing the wood. My choice would be one of these, black locust, quarter sawn white oak, walnut, or as in the pictured door catalpa. Light weight with rot resistance up there with black locust.

Construction should be mortise and tendon. If I had a 700 Domino I might use it with the special tendons required for outside exposure. I can always dream. My tendons were pegged with dowels and the glue used was West System epoxy.


Finish should be paint unless the door has sun protection or the owner likes lots of maintenance. I painted this door as it catches a lot of sun and I don't like maintenance.


Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#19

Ellis Walentine

Re: yes but........

Ellis Walentine

Of course 2x material will look bulkier than a typical screen door, but that's an aesthetic concern, not an engineering one. A heavier look would fit right in with the look of the adjacent structures. In fact, regardless of the thickness Paul settles on, a wider center rail would match up nicely with the fixed rails nearby.

Ellis

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

#20

Re: Need screen door construction suggestions

Jerry Gibbs

I have made several doors in our trailer park. The openings are non-standard and out of square. To prevent twisting, I add a perpendicular box type frame around the inside near the screen. Works well. I would show a pic but the doors are in Florida and I am in Michigan.