Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

The Butler's Desk Build - Workspace

Posts

Re: The Butler's Desk Build - Workspace

#2

Re: The Butler's Desk Build - Workspace

Tony - Memphis

I dunno, I'm just not impressed with those drawer pulls. Perhaps I'm a little too traditional in my taste, but lime green? And how long do you think those will last?

Nice work!

Re: The Butler's Desk Build - Workspace

#3

Re: The Butler's Desk Build - Workspace

Brian Holcombe

Haha! It's all part of my plan....I will be the authorized dealer for replacement drawer pulls....$25/ea....an inexpensive way to ensure you will always be able to open your drawers. ;)

Thanks Tony!

Re: The Butler's Desk Build - Workspace

#4

Re: The Butler's Desk Build - Workspace

William Duffield

His choice is obvious to me. Surely, you've noticed the systainers sitting around his shop? The pulls are Festool green. :D

Re: The Butler's Desk Build - Workspace

#5

Re: The Butler's Desk Build - Workspace

William Duffield

Again, the unconventional joinery and lack of a published project overview have me scratching my head. Are the battens totally enclosed breadboard ends in the back edge of the drop leaf? I'm used to English and American drop front desk designs with full thickness breadboard ends with mitered corners. I am most concerned with the lack of structural support for the sides of the knife hinges, since they are not set into hinge mortises. At least, I am relieved that you are not sinking the screws into end grain.

Re: The Butler's Desk Build - Workspace

#6

Re: The Butler's Desk Build - Workspace

Brian Holcombe

You know how I roll!

Re: The Butler's Desk Build - Workspace

#7

Re: The Butler's Desk Build - Workspace

Brian Holcombe

Thanks for your comment William.

It's a bit late at this point, with the cabinet practically together, but I think on *some* future projects I will begin with an overview of the project, a sketch of the design periodically point out which part I'm working on as I go.

For instance, putting together a Nakashima style table doesn't really warrant much overview, but the next cabinet or complicated table that I do certainly will.

As to your comments on the batten, that is correct it functions much like a breadboard end and will ultimately be locked in the center to allow the panel to expand at the outside edges (or biased toward the top). It's similar but different from the bread-board end style fold down desks I've seen historical examples of.

The hinges are firmly located with screws and yes part of the reason for doing this, is as you've observed, the screws are into side grain. The are housed not by the battens (except the small shoulder) but by the bridle joint, which is at least equal to the side grain support it would otherwise receive (not that much).

It has it's positives and negatives, but it did also provide the aesthetic I'm looking for.

The final bit of work to be done on this is to install a friction stay so that the hinges will not be subjected to excessive forces.

Re: The Butler's Desk Build - Workspace

#8

Re: The Butler's Desk Build - Workspace

William Duffield

I think most people who frequent here could put together a Nakashima end table in their sleep. :D

Re: The Butler's Desk Build - Workspace

#9

Re: The Butler's Desk Build - Workspace

Brian Holcombe

Indeed! I make them complicated however :D