Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Considering a jointer

Posts

Considering a jointer

#1

johannaj

Considering a jointer

johannaj

I would like to find a local woodworker who has one or more jointer planes that I could examine for size and weight before I invest my funds in one - or make one.

I live in Placitas, New Mexico.

Re: Considering a jointer

#2

Re: Considering a jointer

Jesse Cloud

Hi Johanna,

I have a Lee Valley 27 inch jointer. Drop by give it a whirl.

Jesse Cloud

3 Lunar ct

Re: Considering a jointer

#3

johannaj

Re: Considering a jointer

johannaj

Thanks, Jesse! How about late next week? Right now I have one of those very expensive black boots on my right foot, so cannot drive until after next Wednesday (assuming my surgeon lets me go back to real shoes then).

I started a thread on Sawmill Creek earlier this week stating that I was looking for a jointer and was considering either the LeeValley or the LieNielsen. There were many, many responses to the thread and now I am thinking that I really want to consider a wider variety of options, including making one (although the largest plane I have ever made is only 13" long). So many choices!

Re: Considering a jointer

#4

Re: Considering a jointer *LINK*

John in NM

Making one is a very good option, especially considering the weight of an iron plane that large. I have a vintage Stanley 7 you can try out, though I can scarcely predict when I will next make it up to ABQ area. If you want to borrow it we'll figure out a way to get it up there.

In addition to the glued up style of plane making, I've done one by Cecil Pierce's method. His book is now available used only I believe, but still might be worth it. Basically you cut the blade bed/mortise like for a wedged plane, but without the side mortises for the wedge. Then you use a large wood screw and a lever cap like on a iron plane. The plane I made, I used an old Stanley lever cap, but Cecil seems to have mostly made his own.

Nice chunk of mahogany would make a pretty manageable jointer, maybe cherry or walnut too.


https://www.amazon.com/Fifty-Years-Planemaker-Cecil-Pierce/dp/0962800120

Re: Considering a jointer

#5

easy

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

buy the longest widest jointer you can afford. Long enables easier jointing of long stock. Wide enables flattening wider boards. An adjustable outfeed makes setting the knives much easier.

Re: Considering a jointer

#6

Re: easy

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Don't think he's talking about a power tool, Bill. He's talking hand plane for jointing, I think.

Re: Considering a jointer

#8

Re: easy

Brian Holcombe

Kinda.....

A big iron jointer is about the only tool in my shop that truly wears me out by the end of the day, I avoid using it and have found a wooden try plane to be a much better alternative.

No one on SMC mentioned this (and the thread was bombarded with opinions so I did not bother) but a Japanese jointer, called Nagadai Kanna, is a nice option to consider.

If you spend an hour or three in the shop then probably a LN 7 is fine, but if you are in the shop all day I would consider a lighter plane.

Re: Considering a jointer

#9

Agreed


Re: Considering a jointer

#10

Re: Considering a jointer

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi again Johanna

I will mention my choices again here, with a little more reasoning that I did on SMC.

I know that you are looking for a lighter jointer, as this will be less fatiguing in use.

There are two metal jointers that are not necessarily lighter, but they are so well balanced, that they feel lighter.

Firstly, the Veritas LA Jointer. This is a bevel up plane with a very low centre of gravity. It encourages a low centre of effort, which translates to less effort needed to push. Of interest, the plane is 22" long, which is typical for a #7-type, but the mouth is a little further back, essentially providing the same registration as a #8 jointer. The only downside of this plane is the reinforcement around the toe, which prevents the plane being used on its side as a shooter.

Secondly, the Veritas #7 Custom Plane. This is a bevel down plane, also with a low centre of gravity (but not as low as the LAJ). The advantage of this plane is that the frog can be the angle of your choice. Mine is 40 degrees which, when used with a chipbreaker, is capable of planing the most interlocked grain. The low frog creates a plane that is easier to push. The other advantage is that you can use the plane on its side to shoot edges on your bench top.

All Veritas planes can use the new selection of handles and knobs, which come in three sizes - you would find ones to suit your hand.

If you have time, you may wish to read my review of the Custom planes. This is more about design and choice than the planes alone:

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/VeritasCustomPlanes1.html

BU, BD, vintage and modern appear in the article(s) ...


The third choice of plane is a little different. The planes above are 22" long. For someone your size (5'2"), the alternative is a #6 length plane, which is 18" long. My choice here (from experience) is the Australian-built HNT Gordon A55 Trying Plane. This is a woodie - which makes it very light - with a single blade (1/4" thick!) on a high 55 degree bed. This plane comes with a Norris-type adjuster, and can also be used as a scraping plane. Terry Gordon makes superior planes.


Link (in AUD prices): http://www.hntgordon.com.au/gidgee-bench-planes/product/34-gidgee-a55-trying-plane-with-ts-blade-out-of-stock.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Considering a jointer

#11

Re: Considering a jointer

Jesse Cloud

Bummer about the boot.

I will be out of town for a while starting next week, but I can drop the plane off at your house before I leave.

Give me a call on the placitas exchange + 6819 and we can set something up.

Re: Considering a jointer

#12

Re: Considering a jointer

Johanna

In the end, I received the most wonderful surprise - one of our number offered to give me a jointer plane made by David Finck! I am really looking forward to it.

All in all this has been a great thread - lots of excellent comments here and on SMC. Many thanks to all of you who responded.

Johanna