Ash
David Frame
Hi All,
Would flat sawed, edge glued Ash make a good workbench top?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Ash
David Frame
Hi All,
Would flat sawed, edge glued Ash make a good workbench top?
Re: Ash
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
yes
Re: Ash
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
Sure
Re: Ash
David Frame
Thanks for the input. One more question. Does ash have a tendency to warp or twist?
Thanks for your time,
David Frame
Re: Ash
David Frame
Thanks for your input. One more question. Does ash have a tendency to warp or twist?
Thanks for your time,
David Frame
Re: Ash
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
Like any other hardwood, you have to allow for seasonal changes in dimension. I'm responding based upon you having fully dried (air or kiln) wood. If it's wet and fresh sawn, it'll be useless for most of a year after the sawyer's done, and it will, indeed, warp and twist ( and bow) if you don't dry it properly.
Re: Ash
Jesse Cloud
Maybe a useful way to answer your question would be to compare ash to other woods.
Like all woods, ash grows and shrinks and potentially warps, but no more than other woods commonly used for furniture, such as maple, cherry or oak.
Ash is strong and it machines well. It glues well with plain old titebond and holds screws well. For many years, it was used for baseball bats.
I think ash isn't as popular as some other woods due to the high contrast between open pored parts and tighter parts. It doesn't take stain evenly without some conditioning.
I have used ash for many projects and they are all still in great shape. And lastly,
in most places ash is a bargain compared to maple, cherry, walnut, etc.
Re: Ash
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
To answer your question, not any more or less than anything else.
For years we sold maple to industry for making utilitarian stuff- bumpers, tables, whatever. Then in the 1990's its price rocketed past walnut for a brief time as the bowling alley craze swept Japan. We moved these customers to ash and they found it as good.
Re: Ash
Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA
first of there are about a dozen different kinds of ash. In my experience black ash warps less than most other woods, but that is taking it from a tree to furniture. The only other kind of ash 'Ive worked with is modesto ash and it moves a bit more but is pretty stable once the free moisture is gone. By stable I mean it still moves like all wood but it is well behaved and tends not to warp.
Re: Ash
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
David: If you buy the ash at a lumber yard it will be ash that will have been prepared for sale to furniture factories for making furniture. Your bench will be no more demanding an application.
Re: Ash
David Frame
Good Morning Jesse,
I picked this 4/4, about 1 1/8" rough, straight line rip cutoffs from 1 1/2" to 2 1/2" wide at a local lumber company. It was being thrown away. They do this from time to time. When I see free lumber, I never pass up the opportunity to put it in my truck.
I don't know what species of ash it is, but it's size is why I want to use it for a workbench top. Being open grained, I know I'll have to fill the pores and give it a finish that will hold up. Ash would not be my first choice for a bench top, but free is very cost effective.
Thanks for the info and your time,
D. Frame
It would be my first choice.....
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
It is durable, inexpensive and not bad looking. What more could one want for a bench? The open grain is not very open. It will not be an issue. And if it came from a lumber yard you don't need to know what kind of ash it is (most probably white ash). It is suitable for furniture building.
Re: It would be my first choice.....
David Frame
To everyone that has responded to my question about Ash and other past inquiries,
I picked 61 pieces of 4/4 x 8' ash, about 1 1/8" thick rough, straight line rip cutoffs from 1 1/2" to 2 1/2" wide at a local lumber company. It was being thrown away. They do this from time to time. When I see free lumber, I never pass up the opportunity to put it in my truck.
I do believe it's white ash. Its size is why I want to use it for a workbench top. Being open grained, I know I'll have to fill the pores and give it a smooth finish that will hold up. Ash would not be my first choice for a bench top, but free is very cost effective. Add a bit of labor and voila, a usable bench top.
I'd like to thank those who have helped me in the past and the now, with many of the problems that arise when I wasn't sure about the direction I should go.
Thanks for your time and expertise,
D. Frame
Free lumber! I'm drooling!
Re: It would be my first choice.....
David Frame
Jesse,
There is this hardwood lumber co. "Deanos" that throws this lumber away. I guess they know it's paid for, so rather than keep it, they throw it in a pile outdoors. I have a friend that works their and he calls me as soon as it's put out. I've collected maple, poplar, oak, and now ash. I'm still waiting on walnut.
For a work bench . . .
Yonak
I wouldn't consider filling the pores and giving a "nice" finish would be overplay in my book. After all, a work bench is still a work bench, not normally a work of art.
Re: It would be my first choice.....
Barry Irby
David, I would turn the strips so that the top surface was quarter sawn if I could. I woudl glue it up and let it float so the natural movement of the wood can be accommodated. If I were unsure of how dry it was I woudl bring it into my shop and let it acclimated for a couple of weeks and then glue it up.
I built a butcher block type top for my lathe cabinet out of oak. Air dried. It has one short crack between the feet of the lathe. The bolts are about eight inches apart and think that was just enough to put some tension on the top when the wood tried to dry and shrink.
Nice score, I am jealous.