Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Construction question

Posts

Construction question

#1

Construction question

Dan Manturi

Hello. Have not visited in a while but realize the richness of information here. My son has a brick home. The front has a porch roof overhang between first and second floor of about 4 feet out from the house. The width is about 20 feet, supported at both ends. There was a 4x4 post about in the middle of this span that was actually loose. He has removed it with no sag, but it is summer. This span is constructed of 2 - 2x6's bolted together with metal plate of about 5/16 sandwiched in the middle. He wants to reinforce it with another 2x6 glued and bolted to the existing ones. I am more in favor of ripping 3/4" plywood into 5 1/2" strips and putting 2 layers glued, staggered every 4 feet of length, and bolted. Of course, one could make the case for removing the existing 2x6 assembly and going microlam, but that is a huge undertaking.

Which is the better approach - 1 2x6 or the plywood, and thanks for any suggestions.

Re: Construction question

#2

Re: Construction question

George Koch

Without knowing the allowable snow load for your area of the country I don't think any 5 1/2" deep beam could span 20' without sagging over time from its own weight and the roof its carrying. That's probably why the double 2 x 6 s had to be reinforced with a steel plate to even span the 10'. I would advise putting the center column back in, or going with a much deeper steel beam. George

Re: Construction question

#3

Re: Construction question

Dan Manturi

Original home built in 1957. Bethlehem PA. He wants to put a 2x6 in with the others. 2x6 has flex, plywood not so much. I told him to leave the post but he is intent on leaving it out. It really was loose but, in winter, may be a different story. I hear you.

Re: Construction question

#4

Re: Construction question

Keith Newton

There not enough info to make a good recommendation, like how it is attached to the house, and what is going on inside the house. The single post, to me sounds like an afterthought, that was added in the spur of the moment, like under heavy snow load, causing the wall to flex inward across a room, while the ends were more stable due to corners or Tees on the other side of the wall.

It sounds to me like it needs 3-4 post to look right and be safe.

Re: Construction question

#5

Re: Construction question

C. John Hebert

I agree with George, and....Microlams aren't all they are cracked up to be. I've seen many sag and because of that..I stayed away from using them.

Re: Construction question

#6

Re: Construction question

Dan Manturi

Agree with all of this - there is no talking him out of it so.. I guess I will just help him with whatever plan he has and hope for the best. Thanks.

Re: Construction question

#7

Re: Construction question

Barry Irby

George nailed it. And so did the others questioning the layout and other information.

What you have is called a Flitch Plate or Flitch Beam. The steel provides the resistance to bending and carries the load, but will only do that as long as its vertical and does not twist and wrinkle. The wood on either side keeps the steel upright and flat, able to resist the tendancy to roll over and wrinkle. Try it with a narrow strip of paper or cardboard and see what happens. The wood adds a very small percentage to the steel's ability to hold the vertical forces other than holding it vertical. Another piece of wood would add very little to this. At a 20 foot span, it would be very limber.

When you use plywood as a beam, Technically you can only "count" the plies that are oriented with the long fibers horizontal in this case. That is the plies that run end to end. The cross plies contribute very little to the beams ability to carry a load. So if the plywood is half lengthwise plies and half cross plies, it would only be half as strong as a solid piece of timber as a beam. If you had a piece of plywood twenty feet long this woudl be more obvious. This is why LVL's and Gluelam's have all the fibers running lengthwise.

The other questions involve how the porch was built and how its attached to the house. Locally the second floor studs would have been 2 x 4's and there would be a "ridge" board nailed to them and then the rafters of the porch would bear against the ridge. The lower end of the rafters woudl bear on the Flitch plate and there would be ceiling joists creating a ceiling. If the wall of the house were rigid, and the attachments were truly strong, each rafter/ceiling joist/wall section would form a triangle, a very strong shape and they would hang from the house quite nicely and the flitch plate beam would be unnecessary. It is likely this is not what the builders intended and the studs are too flexible and the nailing was not set up to take loads in tension and the porch roof would sag over time. Either the nails woudl slowly turn loose or the studs would flex and the second floor wall would bulge outward.

Without seeing it, my guess is the porch has settled. Stretch a string as tightly as you can from corner to corner across the front. I would use a nylon string and two weights like bricks. Hang the bricks off the ends and pull the string very tight. Use a spacer under the string at each corner and with a piece of the same spacer, check the clearance under the string. If I am right there will be more clearance under the string in the middle than at the two ends. Look closely for a crack. Would not take much and it may be hiding behind the steps. This is the problem if you confirm the settlement.

Right now, I think the porch settled and the roof is hanging from the house and you are waiting for a big snow or time to loosen the connections. You should put

the post back. Wait and see if the settlement continues. It is unlikely, but possible for it to fail catastrophically and tumble off the house.

Re: Construction question

#8

Dan, read my post above, I was typing....

Barry Irby

while you posted your response. I went back a reread your original post and realized its a brick house. Most likely a brick veneer house rather than solid masonry. this means the rafters and ceiling joists are most likely attached to the brick with a few nails rather than bolts. And it increases the chances of a catastrophic failure.

Re: Construction question

#9

Brick, or Brick Facade.. big difference

Grant in Iowa

Firstly, given the 1957 construction date, I suspect that the home may be a brick facade home instead of a brick home. Big difference. Either way, it may have a joist or doubled up joist, or even a steel beam buried in the 2nd floor brick work that you aren't seeing. It could be that the structure beneath was designed as a visual structure to keep the elevation view from looking funny, and to give it a grounded appearance. Conversely, it could be that footings or support has subsided in a way to make the center post loose. More information is necessary.

Sometimes beams are segmented and supported by posts immediately below the splice. Could be trouble brewing with that center post removed.

I would get out a laser or long level and do some checking on why that center post isn't carrying any load. From your description, it makes no sense to me why it isn't unless something is wrong or has moved significantly.

Last thing I would do is to assume the fact that it is loose means it never carried a load.

We really need more information to provide valid input. I propose:

1. take a photo or two to share with us Make sure to show the roof system in the photos. Also endeavor to show the support structure beneath the posts.

2. on the second floor on that exterior wall open an outlet cover and probe downward to see if there is a hidden beam or steel in the space. If there is, then there's your primary load carrying member. I suspect there isn't, but you have to check.

3. Measure the span between the posts. Measure the front to back distance from that beam to the next load bearing wall or posts behind. If there is a roof gable above this overhang, then we need to know how long the ridge board is, and what the climate is in the area the home is located to calculate snow load.

The more information you can provide, the better the answers we can provide.

I'd put the post back in until you are SURE it isn't needed. Insurance may not cover self inflicted disasters...

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Construction question

#10

Re: Construction question

TomD

I gather the options include tacking wood to the sides of the metal piece. I agree that the metal piece is probably carrying the loads in the vertical axis. Removing the beam probably has the effect of requiring something in the order of incresing the beam capacity 3x. Pieceing in two more pieces of steel would do that. using more wood would have possibly no effect. Since as has been pointed out the wood is not there to carry the loads in the vertical axis. I have no idea how much steel is required for that purpose, though, so if the steel used was 3x more than was requored, might be fine.

Overhangs like this quite often successfully mimic cantilevered structures, but long term this may not persist as fasteners are normally oriented to deal with other loads not the cantilevered loads, and the building load take off points may not be in any way sufficient. So for instance a plank applied to the face of the building may be desinged to take veritical loads supporting the rafters, but not in any way be inteneded to transform the rafters into a tension truss for supporting the roof as a cantilever. However these strucures will not necessarily fail right away, because there is all kinds of stuff, like shingles and flashing, and mebrames, and lags, etc... that will mimic tensile structures for some period of time.

Anyway, I am not engineer, I just relate issues that would concern me.

Often a not horrible way to procees if calling in an engineer is out of the question is to look in the neighbourhood for other exmaples of this construction and verify whether they have mid span posts (or check your own structure to see whther the post that was loose was nontheless part of the original plan. This combined with your sense that the sturcture needs something else to hold it up, but for which the planed solutions have proven non-functional, might guide one to replace the post. Of course if the post was there for a mail box added later, and many houses without mid-span posts are standing up nicely on your block, you at least have analogy on your side.

Re: Construction question

#11

Re: Construction question

Dan Manturi

Thanks all for this wealth of info. It is a solid brick home. How the porch overhang is attached to the house I do not know. the home was built by a union mason immigrant from Poland. Everything about the house is over engineered. I believe that the porch roof - which attaches to the garage, was built afterward. I have to agree that the post may have been added as an afterthought when some sag may have been noted. I do not know what the big issue is with the post - purely aesthetic objection he has to it but it is not my home. I will relay all of this information and thanks to all for the very thorough answers.

Re: Construction question

#12

Re: Construction question

walta

If you can afford the money get him an engineers report as a gift.

Should the roof collapse some night in a snow storm it will not be much fun.

Walta