Brick, or Brick Facade.. big difference
Grant in Iowa
Firstly, given the 1957 construction date, I suspect that the home may be a brick facade home instead of a brick home. Big difference. Either way, it may have a joist or doubled up joist, or even a steel beam buried in the 2nd floor brick work that you aren't seeing. It could be that the structure beneath was designed as a visual structure to keep the elevation view from looking funny, and to give it a grounded appearance. Conversely, it could be that footings or support has subsided in a way to make the center post loose. More information is necessary.
Sometimes beams are segmented and supported by posts immediately below the splice. Could be trouble brewing with that center post removed.
I would get out a laser or long level and do some checking on why that center post isn't carrying any load. From your description, it makes no sense to me why it isn't unless something is wrong or has moved significantly.
Last thing I would do is to assume the fact that it is loose means it never carried a load.
We really need more information to provide valid input. I propose:
1. take a photo or two to share with us Make sure to show the roof system in the photos. Also endeavor to show the support structure beneath the posts.
2. on the second floor on that exterior wall open an outlet cover and probe downward to see if there is a hidden beam or steel in the space. If there is, then there's your primary load carrying member. I suspect there isn't, but you have to check.
3. Measure the span between the posts. Measure the front to back distance from that beam to the next load bearing wall or posts behind. If there is a roof gable above this overhang, then we need to know how long the ridge board is, and what the climate is in the area the home is located to calculate snow load.
The more information you can provide, the better the answers we can provide.
I'd put the post back in until you are SURE it isn't needed. Insurance may not cover self inflicted disasters...
FWIW,
Grant in Iowa