Lots of hidden factors here...
Grant in Iowa
I am a facility manager in a 100,000 square foot building built 4 years ago with LEED approved lighting. I have been dealing with these issues a LOT. Here are some thoughts I would offer:
1. Nobody brought it up, but I feel compelled to say that LEED, while it sounds nice creates a LOT of issues with maintenance issues of fixtures of all types. Being an early adopter has its drawbacks. LED fixtures are no different. In my opinion, LEED dollars would be better spent on properly sealing and insulating the building envelope. Don't believe me? Come visit my facility or better yet do your own research online.
2. I would not retrofit LED lamps in to a fluorescent fixture unless the fluorescent ballasts are removed. Ballasts use energy too (note how warm they are in operation), and they occasionally need to be replaced, usually at a significant cost. Hidden electric cost plus more hardware to maintain equals a bad deal long term. To be fair, the ballast life may be greater with the slightly lower wattage of the LED lamps, but who wants more complexity if you can avoid it?
3. New fixture LED lighting would be a good thing, although they aren't (as of this writing) more efficient than good quality fluorescent with T5 or T5HO lamps.
4. There is a benefit to LED in that the lamps last longer, but what they don't usually tell you is that the drivers usually have a MTBF (Mean time between Failure) shorter than the 25K to 50K hours of the LED's. Drivers can be costly. Some LED's also have a power conditioner as well which can fail. More $$. Point is to do ALL of the research and see what replacement parts cost and what the MTBF of each component is before leaping.
5. By all means replace any and all incandescents with LED retrofit screw in lamps. Lots of value here, and often rebates to be had. Sadly, my building has none of these.
6. Check with your local Electric utility. They may have guidance and rebates for your area.
7. If you have fairly modern T8, T5, or T5HO lamps already and electronic ballasts, you probably would not see much better efficiency by retrofitting or replacing with LED--maybe up to 30% if you don't consider the cost in $ and labor. Rebates can change the formula significantly. If you have T-12's with old style or even electronic ballasts, it would likely pay back for you, especially if there's a rebate available.
8. See this link for an explanation about the lumens difference between LFL (Linear Fluorescent) and LED LFL retrofits that some have issue with: http://www.premierltg.com/should-you-replace-your-t8-fluorescent-lamps-with-t8-led-tubes-2/
Regards,
Grant in Iowa <-Director of Facilities here: www.ncsml.org