Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

LED Shop Lights

Posts

LED Shop Lights

#1

LED Shop Lights

Stuart Johnson

I'm finally getting around to finishing up my shop and need to add more lights. It seems there are are bunch of retro LED but I'm not finding any complete fixtures that aren't singles. The lights I know have are all in a row so one switch turns them all on. It actually looks like buying very cheap T8 fixtures and then adding conversion bulbs might be the way to go. Any suggestions?

In looking at them there seems to be two types. On has one end dead and the tombstone holding with the the hot and neutral on the other end. Another shows the hot on one end and neutral on the other. Is that true, are there two different types of bulbs?

Re: LED Shop Lights

#3

Re: LED Shop Lights

Barry Irby

I have used four of the fixtures Mark suggests from Costco and am very happy. The local Costco carries them in single packs for $29 each or less. I have two more waiting for the installer (Me) to put them in. I will add more as the others fail. Keep it simple.

Re: LED Shop Lights

#4

I fail to see the advantage of shop LED lamps

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have an article in the Articles Section on lighting but I will summarize here. When considering lighting a shop there are three consideration- how much light is needed, what color is most desirable and the spectral quality of the light. There is a fourth consideration that is not typically significant in this situation and that is operating cost. In any case there will be data on the lamp to guide the choices.

The amount of light the lamp will put out will be given on the lamp or lamp box in "lumens". While lumens per dollar might be important when lighting a 24/7 warehouse, in the typical shop situation one should be more concerned with lumens per shop fixture. The clear winner in the amount of light a 4' fixture will provide is the T5HO and the cheapest place to get these is at Home Depot. Next best will be a T8 fixture with good quality T8 lamps. Worst will be LED which is why I fail to see why they are desirable.

I replaced more than two dozen T8 and T12 lamps in my shop with 10 T5HO lamps to free up more overhead space.

Re: LED Shop Lights

#5

High output T5 fluorescents

John K Jordan

I used the T5 high output bulbs in 4-bulb fixtures throughout my new shop. I am extremely pleased with them. I love the brightness and the color temperature. (They are brighter than the T8s and much brighter than the T12s, presumably since the plasma is closer to the phosphor in the smaller-diameter bulbs. The only down side I see is the initial cost but even that is insignificant compared to the cost of the shop and the contents.

One of the nicest things is the electronic ballast comes with with taps you can wire up to a switch separate from the main power switch. In this mode, flipping the main switch lights just two of the four bulbs in each fixture. Flipping the "extra" switch lights them all for a lot of extra light when desired. (I mount the extra switches higher on the wall above the main switches so they can't be confused.) Most of the time just 1/2 the light is sufficient and saves power, but sometimes the extra light is so handy for detail work. One friend jokes that he needs sunglasses when he comes in the shop!

Another thing I did is wire the fixtures in zones (turning, flat, storage, welding, etc) each with it's own switch and only light the zone I'm working in. The third thing I did which I REALLY like is wire a string of lower-power lights on a separate switch, a mix of LED and CFL, all the way through the several rooms of the 62' shop. This gives me plenty of light for walking and retrieving tools and things without firing up the main light fixtures.

I do use several LED fixtures elsewhere (in the barn) and they are quite bright. One thing, though, that concerns me is reports of some specific inexpensive LED fixtures which slowly lost much of their brightness over some months of time. There was a lawsuit over this. How wide-spread is this? If it is gradual, with a shop full of the same lights it might even be difficult to tell the light was gradually decreasing without a light meter or substituting a new bulb or fixture at some point. When I bought LED fixtures I looked for those designed with good a heat sink between the chips and the room, i.e., the chips mounted close and tight to the aluminum reflector housing.

JKJ

Re: LED Shop Lights

#6

Lamp surface brightness does not mean more light

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Note on the lamp box how many lumens the lamp produces. It is this value that will determine how much light will fall upon your work bench. The apparent brightness of the surface of the lamp is meaningless.

Re: LED Shop Lights

#7

More to the story than # of lumens

John K Jordan

>>Note on the lamp box how many lumens the lamp produces.

>>It is this value that will determine how much light will fall upon

>>your work bench. The apparent brightness of the surface

>>of the lamp is meaningless.

The stated lumen value is also (relatively) meaningless at the workbench depending on the amount of light absorbed by the reflector, diffuser, and perhaps the ceiling and walls.

The lumen output value on the box is the total output of the lamp, captured and measured with an integrating sphere. This assumes the maker does not lie and cheat to save money or increase sales. I think many do make up numbers or estimate them since a large calibrated integrating sphere is incredibly expensive. We had a relatively small one in our lighting laboratory and it would take a mortgage on the house to buy even it. Even a 12" integrating sphere can be thousands of dollars.

I suspect LED bulb and fixture manufacturers that do use an integrating sphere simply measure one LED in a tiny inexpensive sphere and extrapolate, perhaps ignoring all the factors that can reduce the light output in the final bulb or fixture.

Lumen value is the light in all directions. For an integrated fixture properly measured, no problem. For a bulb in a fixture you have to consider the light absorbed by the fixture and surroundings. For example the T5 HO bulbs I use are rated at 4000+ lumens each on the box. Some of my fixtures have wide mirrored reflectors that direct much of the light downward. I also have some that are not wide or mirrored and I'm sure they lose some of the light that goes upward and sideways from the bulb.

To best determine the actual light that reaches the workbench use a good light meter after the lights are installed. This isn't much help when shopping, though. :-(

JKJ

Re: LED Shop Lights

#8

All true....but

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For most the only guide they will have for putting lumens to the bench will be the number on the box. It may be possible to borrow a light meter from a "full service" lighting store or even to get the people there to design lighting to meet a need for some level of lighting .

With a light meter one could buy one of various fixtures with its respective lamps, install them one by one over the bench and measure light intensity at bench level. If that seems impractical then the other choice is to believe that Sylvania doesn't lie about lamp output and buy the most lumens per dollar spent on lamps. It will be likely that the more expensive fixtures will have longer lasting ballasts and better reflectors. Or just go trendy and buy LED lamps the cheapest place you can find them.

Re: LED Shop Lights

#9

light meter

John K Jordan

It's handy to have a light meter in the toolkit. This one has even dropped significantly in price since I bought one two years ago:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0075ZS8VQ

JKJ

Re: LED Shop Lights

#10

Lots of hidden factors here...

Grant in Iowa

I am a facility manager in a 100,000 square foot building built 4 years ago with LEED approved lighting. I have been dealing with these issues a LOT. Here are some thoughts I would offer:

1. Nobody brought it up, but I feel compelled to say that LEED, while it sounds nice creates a LOT of issues with maintenance issues of fixtures of all types. Being an early adopter has its drawbacks. LED fixtures are no different. In my opinion, LEED dollars would be better spent on properly sealing and insulating the building envelope. Don't believe me? Come visit my facility or better yet do your own research online.

2. I would not retrofit LED lamps in to a fluorescent fixture unless the fluorescent ballasts are removed. Ballasts use energy too (note how warm they are in operation), and they occasionally need to be replaced, usually at a significant cost. Hidden electric cost plus more hardware to maintain equals a bad deal long term. To be fair, the ballast life may be greater with the slightly lower wattage of the LED lamps, but who wants more complexity if you can avoid it?

3. New fixture LED lighting would be a good thing, although they aren't (as of this writing) more efficient than good quality fluorescent with T5 or T5HO lamps.

4. There is a benefit to LED in that the lamps last longer, but what they don't usually tell you is that the drivers usually have a MTBF (Mean time between Failure) shorter than the 25K to 50K hours of the LED's. Drivers can be costly. Some LED's also have a power conditioner as well which can fail. More $$. Point is to do ALL of the research and see what replacement parts cost and what the MTBF of each component is before leaping.

5. By all means replace any and all incandescents with LED retrofit screw in lamps. Lots of value here, and often rebates to be had. Sadly, my building has none of these.

6. Check with your local Electric utility. They may have guidance and rebates for your area.

7. If you have fairly modern T8, T5, or T5HO lamps already and electronic ballasts, you probably would not see much better efficiency by retrofitting or replacing with LED--maybe up to 30% if you don't consider the cost in $ and labor. Rebates can change the formula significantly. If you have T-12's with old style or even electronic ballasts, it would likely pay back for you, especially if there's a rebate available.

8. See this link for an explanation about the lumens difference between LFL (Linear Fluorescent) and LED LFL retrofits that some have issue with: http://www.premierltg.com/should-you-replace-your-t8-fluorescent-lamps-with-t8-led-tubes-2/

Regards,

Grant in Iowa <-Director of Facilities here: www.ncsml.org

Re: LED Shop Lights

#11

Re: Lots of hidden factors here...

John K Jordan

Grant, some good thoughts. You might want to explain what LEED means and if it is important in this situation. Lots of people might think it is a kind of light.

JKJ

Re: LED Shop Lights

#12

LEED is....

Grant in Iowa

LEED is an acronym which stands for "Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design". LEED green building system, developed by the U.S. Green Building Council (USGBC) provides a suite of standards for the environmentally sustainable design, construction, and operation of buildings and neighborhoods.

The organization is a private 501(c)3 membership based non-profit organization.

It is not another type of lighting fixture, in case anyone was confused by my inclusion of it in my previous post.

It has its good and bad, but is mostly a good thing to spur the growth of better building design. Early LEED standards tended to skew builders toward better fixtures, while little attention was paid to the building envelope. Critics say this was due to the points system and some building features having a points rating out of proportion with other efficiency items. Things have improved with LEEDV4, however, and I hope it gets better from there.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: LED Shop Lights

#13

Re: LEED is....an aside for Grant

Barry Irby

Years ago the government got the idea to use the spy satellites to record the heat signature of every building in the country. Then they were going to go to the owners and pressure them to tighten up. (pardon the pun) They thermographed a couple of cities. The thing that killed the plan was when they noticed the governmental buildings were the worst offenders.

Re: LED Shop Lights

#14

Re: LED Shop Lights *LINK*

walta

The way I read the chart in this article none of the LEDs make as much light as a T8 with an electronic ballast.

When I look for efficacy in lumens per watt the LEDs do not look that impressive to me.

The data is getting a little old may be things have changed.

Walta


LED Magazine

Re: LED Shop Lights

#15

That's my point

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It would seem that the overriding consideration in buying shop light is how much light are you getting per light fixture. Think of the purchase as buying light. What do I need to spend and install to get the light I need on the bench ,saw or whatever. From this perspective LED shop lights don't make sense to me. Add in the fact that with T8 or T5 you can get your preference of color temperature.

Re: LED Shop Lights

#16

Re: LED Shop Lights

Grant Smith

Walt,

Here's an explanation of why, a cut and paste from my link I provided above about lumens and LED lighting aimed at replacements for linear fluorescent lighting:

"While some may complain that LEDs have lower rated lumens than fluorescents, judging the two in this category is really like comparing apples and oranges. There simply is no direct comparison. This is because LEDs can get by with less lumens because their directional nature ensures you get a greater concentration of light exactly where you need it. And, as mentioned, fluorescents waste light within the fixture and illuminate unnecessary places. The bottom line is: don’t get too hung up on lumens, if you’re going to do a comparison, consider the delivered lumens of both the lamp and luminaire together."

In the strictest sense, you are correct by the numbers. What LED's do, however, is provide a much more directional light, thereby putting more of their output on the subject. This can be an issue with one fixture due to shadowing, but with a room full of fixtures, it works quite well.

Indeed, there are other options too. One of the most promising is the edge lit technology. This provides a very diffuse light, which would be ideal for a shop in my opinion. Here's one option: http://www.beeslighting.com/product-p/dv-fp22-40l-50k-d10.htm?gclid=CJPx8YKl4c0CFQUFaQodCxoA_g&gdffi=803d4dd6a5df420f86f4dc5cbe5c4201&gdfms=68EA29A45A3A4BE28185E3DFCC74F519

I won't represent LED's as a panacea, but they certainly have their place, and as time passes, they are becoming the best choice in more and more applications for a number of reasons.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: LED Shop Lights

#17

And you get your choice of color temperature(nm)


Re: LED Shop Lights

#18

Technically correct but.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.....not where most people are buying them. While I can get a selection of color temperature lamps even at Lowes, as far as I know the Cosco source of LED shop lights does not offer an option.

Re: LED Shop Lights

#19

Which temp/color for T5 shop lights?

Chuck Nickerson

Any guidance you can provide or point me towards?

TIA

Re: LED Shop Lights

#20

Re: Which temp/color for T5 shop lights?

John K Jordan

Chuck,

Mine say 5000K on the box. I use the 54w T5 HO bulbs. I love the color of the light and when I checked they were extremely close to the photo lights I use.

I found this table that has some info:

http://www.lrc.rpi.edu/programs/nlpip/lightinganswers/lat5/pc1a.asp

JKJ

Re: LED Shop Lights

#21

It's personal

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I like something that looks like the sun in my cave-like basement shop (4500 or 5000K). Others like something closer to incandescent (3000 or 3500)K)