Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Wood flooring

Posts

Wood flooring

#1

Wood flooring

Bob Boswood

I have an apartment recently vacated by utter pigs. Its a 24X24 studio apartment. Half is carpeted. You guessed it, carpet is destroyed. Years ago I acquired a complete high school gyms bleachers consisting of roughly 5000 board feet of vertical grain doug fir lumber. Boards are 5/4 8" wide 16' long. I need to use these up before I die so I was thinking of using some for flooring. I realize fir is prone to splintering but figured if I put enough coats of fininish it would work fine. My question is what type of joint should I use? I have a complete woodshop and can make most any type of joint, however I am in no way a wood floor expert. Any suggestuions would be appreciated.

Bob

Re: Wood flooring

#2

Re: Wood flooring

Barry Irby

The flooring will be interesting.

The problem is that no matter how dry or well cured the lumber is it will still expand and contract. In modern times we think wide flooring is classy and cool. In colonial times they thought wide boards were cheap and easy. (Easy, being a relative term.) I have seen houses with boards a foot wide or more with a 1 1/2" wide filler strip in between. In the Governor's Palace in Williamsburg They use boards that were about an inch wide. Imagine how much work that was to do that by hand?

The idea is, the shrinkage accumulates. Even with AC and Heat, the difference summer and winter is likely to 1 or 2% Two percent of a narrow board is insignificant and almost invisible, but on a wide board its a mess.

Running a T & G on 16" boards in a private shop might be quite a challenge. Trivial if you can find a commercial shop with the right machines.

The vertical grain fir will make an excellent floor. There is a lot of it around here that is a hundred years old. Wears well.

If it were mine, I might take it someone who has the right equipment and have them rip it in to 4" wide strip and T & G it. Or rip it myself and let them T & G it.

Don't want to do that? I might clean up the edges, cut a tiny bevel on them and screw them down to the joists with a few biscuits in between. Counter bore the holes and plug them and sand.

Nice problem to have. A thousand ways to skin this cat.

Re: Wood flooring

#3

get a good resaw blade on your bandsaw

Dick Coers

You should be able to get 2, if not 3 boards from each piece. Tongue and groove on all sides if you use shorter boards. 16' boards are not too straight and making up long joints will add to the difficulty. Vertical grain moves less than flat sawn. Up to you if you want to back cut the bottom of the boards like commercial flooring, I would not.

Re: Wood flooring

#4

Re: Wood flooring

Bob boswood

The 3/4 " plywood floor is ready for the wood flooring. I'm going to end up with 3/4 " x 7.5 " board. I'm cutting to manageable lengths and routing a tongue and groove on them. I'll face nail the starter board and blind nail from there on out. My question is should I put some 30 lb felt down on the 3/4 ply substrate first?

Am I headed in the right direction?

Re: Wood flooring

#5

Re: Wood flooring

George Koch

If you are determined to use the full 7.5" width boards without any face screwing and plugging as suggested, I would not put felt paper down but would use plenty of construction adhesive between the plywood subfloor and your finished flooring. Also you should tongue and groove the ends of each board.

Re: Wood flooring

#6

Re: Wood flooring

Jim Dillon

Bob, if I were younger I'd love to have your problem! Vertical grain fir is gorgeous IMO. I did all the interior trim in our log cabin with the stuff and love it. Anyway, back to flooring. My wife and I did the flooring in our cabin using random width T&G vintage locust, wormy oak, and new heartwood pine. Tore up the old 3/4 inch particle board (leaving the old 1/2 inch plywood that was under the particle board.) and replaced with 3/4 inch T&G plywood glued and screwed. Like you plan, IIRC I face nailed the edges and nailed the rest using a floor nailer purchased from Amazon. I left a gap around the outside edges that eventually was covered with baseboard. I waxed the nails to prevent splintering of the tongue - especially for the locust. I used resin paper under the flooring. On boards wider than 5 inches, I sunk 2-3 screws in each end and at intervals along the longer boards, then plugged the screw holes with plugs made from the same wood. A lot of work, but it sure looks nice. The book "Hardwood Floors" by Don Bollinger was a big help. All this was 20 years ago and we have had no problems whatsoever except for dog toenail scratches on the soft pine and cat scratches on the fir. Depending on the size of your floor, that could be a LOT of planing, sawing and doing the T&G. Have fun. Wow, 5000 bdft! I'm jealous because I paid a lot for my fir, but it was superb stuff and so straight, even in 12 foot lengths that I almost didn't have to joint the stuff. Jim

Re: Wood flooring

#7

Re: Wood flooring

Barry Irby

I studied the "standard" practice of putting felt under wood flooring. Felt is a water barrier but not a vapor barrier. I came to the conclusion that the cushioning effect was undesirable. (why would you want a cushion under the flooring?) I decided the practice came from back in the day when subfloors were diagonal boards. It was a wind/air barrier. An effort to keep air from seeping or blowing through the flooring. Especially in winter to reduce heat loss. Therefore unnecessary over plywood.

When I laid my oak flooring (typical prefinished 2 1/4" strip) I nailed it with a home made nailer. It was a big Sendo stapler that shoots 2 1/2 inch staples. I ground the snoot on it down to a vee so it would fit in the angle between the tongue and the edge and made a wooden shoe to hole it at the desired angle. I wanted the staples to penetrate all the way through the 5/8" subfloor. (Helps reduce "nail pops" or the backing out of the fasteners.) I'm not sure air actuated floor nailers were available and I was not about to try the old two pound hammer version all day. Stapled the heck out of it. Worked great. My goal was NO Squeeks. Guess What, twenty years later, no squeeks.

When we installed 3 1/4" Brazilian Cherry in my son's house we use an air actuated nailer. Worked very well. You don't have to wail the heck out of it and the rubber hammer is useful for bumping the flooring up tight and the nailing action helps. He only lived in the house for about a year and I have not checked it since, but I think it worked well.

If its easier, I would put a biscuit in the ends of the pieces.

I don't know where you have had the floor stored, but if it has not been in a conditioned space similar to the house, I would mill it and bring it in and let it acclimate for two weeks or more. This is much more important than it seems. Perhaps you can move the stock into a conditioned space while you mill it?

I am not sure about gluing the flooring down. 7" wide boards are going to shrink and contract. Maybe not a lot, but they will move. That's the theory behind only nailing one edge, the other edge floats. I suspect that if it were glued with rigid glue it woudl crack. I might put a bead under the tongue edge. OTOH, if you decide to remove the floor later, the will be hell to pay.

Congrats on scoring the vertical grain fir. Lots of it was used locally for bedrooms and other lower traffic areas. 100 years later it still looks great.