Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

IKEA and dresser lawsuit

Posts

IKEA and dresser lawsuit

#1

IKEA and dresser lawsuit

Stuart Johnson

I just caught the last little blip on the news but it sounds like IKEA lost some sort of lawsuit about dressers tipping over if all the drawers are pulled out and a child climbs them like a ladder. It seems to me any dresser manufacturer would have the same liability. There was something about them agreeing to supply wall anchors.

Tide has a Youtube commercial that list I think 10 things in a normal living room that could be classified as child dangerous. Aren't parents responsible for anything?

Re: IKEA and dresser lawsuit

#2

Re: IKEA and dresser lawsuit *LINK*

Dick Coers

"The CPSC says a child dies every two weeks and a child is injured every 24 minutes in the U.S. from furniture or TVs tipping over."

Not a bad idea to do something. 26 deaths per year is quite a few too many. But IKEA's deep pockets probably got the law suits going.


http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/messages.pl/page/1/md/read/id/499956/sbj/ever-wonder-how-many-pieces-ikea-sells/

Re: IKEA and dresser lawsuit

#3

Re: IKEA and dresser lawsuit

John C Lucas

I want to know where they get thise numbers. That sounds awfully high. I remember a comedian who was talking about furniture lawsuits. He said when he was growing up they had a 200lb TV sotting on a TV Tray. I think virtually every piece of furniture i own except my Bed would tip over if you climb on it. There seems to be some sort of responsibility of the adults.

Re: IKEA and dresser lawsuit

#4

I agree. Where's the parental responsibility ?


Re: IKEA and dresser lawsuit

#5

There is a design issue....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The problem with this piece is that the drawers are on what must be ball bearings. When it starts to tip they all can come out, which makes a tipping situation worse.

Re: IKEA and dresser lawsuit

#6

Not Totally *LINK*

Bill Howatt

There is a standard by the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) International and the IKEA dressers do not meet any of the criteria for safety.

Parental responsibility definitely is necessary and is often neglected in this day and age but what parent with an active child under the age of 5 is going to see what they are doing 100% of the time? It only takes an instant for an accident.

Bill


Safety Standard For Tipping

Re: IKEA and dresser lawsuit

#7

Re: There is a design issue....

Barry Irby

On a similar note, As a Home Inspector, one of the things I check for is if the range has an "Anti Tip" bracket. For at least the last ten years these brackets have been required. They "capture" the back foot of the range and prevent it tipping over. Apparently kids were opening the oven door and climbing on it to get to the top of the stove. Newer ranges are so light, the added weight of the kid is enough to tip it over possibly dumping whatever is cooking as well as the range itself on the kid.

My kids were Free Range Kids. Its a wonder they made it.

Re: IKEA and dresser lawsuit

#8

Re: Not Totally

William Duffield

The link you provided is to the ambulance chasers' website, and all their arguments are designed to extract the maximum amount of money from their current target, IKEA, while ignoring all the hazardous furniture built by other makers. They do not tell us when the standards were written, or when they were put into effect, or which if any other furniture manufacturer complies with the standards. How arbitrary are the values stated in the standards? Do they address our obesity epidemic, or are they borrowed from European standards, and based on a much lighter population? Maybe we should sue CocaCola, too? Do the standards address the very real danger of a pack of competitive rug rats climbing the chest together?

Does your reproduction Philadelphia Highboy meet the standards? Does the original highboy by Affleck or Savery, and valued at several hundred thousand dollars meet the standards? How about your Goddard and Townsend Secretary? Maybe, we should require that warning labels be slapped on all the museum pieces, too?

Re: IKEA and dresser lawsuit

#10

Re: IKEA and dresser lawsuit

allen heatyh

This is too bad about society in general these days...no one is responsible for anything anymore. Everyone wants something for free, and mostly refuse to put in a day's work for a day's pay. I have a sign in my shop that states "CAUTION I cant fix stupid.....I only charge for it"

Re: IKEA and dresser lawsuit

#11

Re: IKEA and dresser lawsuit

john lucas

I'm looking for a lingerie chest to put my TV on in my office. They typically run about 14- 16" square and 4 to 5 feet tall. I'll be interested to see what safety instructions come with that. I don't see any way you could design one of those to be tip free short of putting locks on the drawers. I don't have any kids so not worried about it. If I do have any over I may get a bigger TV to put there so the Darwin award winners will get what they deserve.

Re: IKEA and dresser lawsuit

#12

Re: IKEA and dresser lawsuit

William Duffield

3M 5200 :b Glue it to the floor, and glue the TV to the top?

Re: IKEA and dresser lawsuit

#13

Teach the kids to use ropes

John C Lucas

Free climbing is dangerous. Teach them how to use ropes and proper belay techniques. Climbing,on belay.

Re: IKEA and dresser lawsuit

#14

Re: Consumer Product Safety Commission report 2006

Brian Holcombe

That first website suggests that the dresser should be able to remain stable with a 50b weight hanging from it's fully extended top drawer while the dresser is otherwise empty......so does any dresser from any manufacturer meet such a guideline?

I dont have a dresser in my boy's room, and his bookshelf.....I did pullups on the top shelf to ensure it would not budge, as I did with every other bookshelf in my house.

I went on a binge of over-doing it, putting fabricated metal reinforcements into wall mounted cabinetry that has been hanging for a few years without issue.