Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Bedside Chest of Drawers

Posts

Bedside Chest of Drawers

#1

Bedside Chest of Drawers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Daughter needed something beside their bed, his and hers. She found something she liked and submitted it to be added to the list of stuff to make. It has become the project from Hell. Why? I’ll deal with that later. The sides are made from a veneered panel inset from the frame whose horizontal rail is in turn set in from the vertical members. Each post has 4 mortises, 2 dovetails and a dado, plus rebate for the back member. That is a lot of investment for each piece and the complexity invites a screw up. It is ever so easy to cut something on the wrong side or wrong end.

What wound up to be piddly M&T’s for the frame served to align it more than strengthen it. The rigidity comes from gluing the panel into the frame, a realization that revealed itself late in the assembly as I chopped away ever more of the mortise and tenon to accommodate the panel.

Liquid hide glue saved the day with glue up. It lubricated the multitude of joints and its slow set enabled the assembly to be glued up and adjusted. If you consider how this thing is put together there are no degrees of freedom like in a normal panel that floats, or in the reveals of the offset rail and panel. It either goes together perfect, or not. It did, to my relief and as a result of many dry fits. The rest of this piece is straightforward, thankfully.










One of the annoyances of Irfanview is that when you aren't looking it defaults to saving files in B&W. To lazy to redo them.

Re: Bedside Chest of Drawers

#2

Some Philosophy

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

As someone here on WC showed and referenced in their Fine WW article, this kind of construction is straightforward with floating tenon construction, a capability I don’t have. My mistake was proceeding with joinery I was accustomed to employing like what is found in Period pieces. The result was complexity and stringent requirements for fit which led to a stressful project.

Popular furniture styles, in this case Danish Modern are accompanied by engineering, techniques and tools to enable making the style practical and robust. Krenov furniture is another modern example. But I suspect that every style has construction techniques optimized for the task and tools and skills to support making the parts.

This presumption suggests that when we approach making some style of furniture a study of the tools and techniques of that time be undertaken. And when we deviate from what was optimized to make some style we face a research project, or journey of discovery, to determine if our deviations will result in an equivalent result or a practical build or a stressful build. Problems will reveal themselves when we are not expecting a problem.

Re: Bedside Chest of Drawers

#3

Where did  you get the charcoal gray wood?

Barry Irby

I agree with you about the tools and techniques. Thinking about it I realize that my design possibilities are limited by the tools and techniques I have. (MY design skills are simply limited and I'm not sure more tools and techniques would help. Wait, Is this an opportunity to buy more tools???? HMMM?) As I think about a design things I can't do get edited out. For example, I don't do carving. So do I not make pieces that have carving because I don't like it or because I can't do it?

I look back on great periods of furniture making and wonder did they cut those dovetails by hand because they were good at it or because they did not have a router and jig? I have always thought they were "modernizing" their shops as fast as they could. At least, they were not one tool away from greatness.

Re: Bedside Chest of Drawers

#5

Re: Some Philosophy

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

I'm not sure I totally agree with your assessment about each style having its own construction techniques engineered to optimize the tools and techniques. I think a lot was often dictated by the tools and materials available at the time as well as the prevailing economics. I have an old Patternmaking text book that discusses was of doing things when the cost of labor was much lower and the cost of lumber for a pattern could be more than the labor. that has flipped and the cost of labor is several times the cost of materials. I think that also has translated some changes.

A good friend and I have talked many times about the idea that if Duncan Phyfe had plywood available to him he would have used it along with a table saw to cut it and a router to cut a rabbit for it. The conversation recently expanded to include the idea that he would have likely run out and bought a Festool Domino and used it as well.

I have no doubt that the top craftsmen through the ages have strived to make quaillity well engineered pieces but I suspect the changes in engineering and techniques have been more a result of changing materials, new tool technology, and changing ecomonomics.

Re: Bedside Chest of Drawers

#6

Re: Some Philosophy

Gary Smyth

Might I add that the apprenticeship system practiced throughout early America and today in Europe and some Far East countries make the construction of many things not only understandable, but in many instances better. In my view it’s not so much the tools (important as they are to be well made, tuned and cared for) but the skills practiced, repeated and monitored by master craftsman. Truth is, modern tools “save so much time” that many of the skills necessary to complete a design have lapsed or were never learned. People complain, for example, on how difficult it is to set up and learn the Leigh dovetail jig. Yet to do it requires the cost of the jig, the router(s), bits, pages of illustrations, and perhaps a video. Whereas to do the same task (as well as or esthetically better) as that jig traditionally requires but practice, a saw, chisel, and a measuring device.

So many of us, me included, spend so much money to save time that we sacrifice skill to perform the same goal – and in the end never gain the knowledge, often sacrifice fit and structure, and don’t save the time. The casual non-woodworking observer would say we went off the deep end.

Re: Bedside Chest of Drawers

#7

Re: Not sure thats true!

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I remember working with a gentleman in his 60's back in the late 1940's. He was very proficient with hand tools, but he had purchased a powered side drive circular saw. I doubt you could have pried that from him with twice the purchase price in cash.

Many of the tasks we do today like mortise and tenon can certainly be done with hand saws, chisels and hammer, and block plane.

But the ability to do this properly took an apprentice woodworker years to learn. Yeah I have a set of Lee Nielson chisels, saw, and good sharp well tuned planes.

However, I can do a better job in far, far less time using my bench mortiser and tenon cutter on my Unisaw. I am sure I could improve my ability to work with the hand tools but I doubt I will live long enough to become completely proficient with all the tools and methods to build that way in a timely manner.

Actually the price of furniture prior to powered equipment was very high due to the time required to construct the same using entirely hand tools. That's one of the main reasons so many of the average homes in the late 19th and early 20th centuries were filled with "hand me down" furniture from the last generation.

I really doubt any of the very skilled craftsmen of earlier times would have not used today's powered tools (like the dovetail jigs, table saws, joiner and planer) if they were available.