Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

bandsaw questions

Posts

bandsaw questions

#1

bandsaw questions

Dan Bundy

Recently replaced the tires on my little Delta 8" (28-180). Today I was trying to get it working again. In adjusting the tracking, I've got the blade pretty nicely in the middle of the top wheel, but it's riding close to the front of the bottom wheel. Putting a straight edge on it, it appears that the top wheel is "outside" of the lower wheel (the straight edge touches two points on the top wheel and none on the bottom).

So I should shim the lower wheel out a bit, yes? What's the best way to go about this?

I tried removing the lower wheel once before, but couldn't break the screw loose. Is it a standard thread (righty tighty ...) or would it be reversed? The parts diagram calls it a "(Din 84) M5 x 10mm Cheese Hd Screw." If I put some heat to it, will I cause any damage?

The parts diagram also shows that the wheel sits directly on motor shaft. If I can get the screw out, how much effort will it likely take to pull the wheel off?

I have the book "Care and Repair of Shop Machines" and it mentions it should be checked, but it doesn't go into a great deal on the methods, etc.

I may have been using it all these years with the blade closer to the front on the bottom wheel; can't remember and it was cutting pretty good until the tires started slipping off, so maybe I should just leave well enough alone?

Appreciate any advice you can provide. DB

Re: bandsaw questions

#2

Re: bandsaw questions

John K Jordan

Dan,

I've read books and articles on tuning bandsaws and I can say there sure are a lot of opinions. Some say the wheels should be co-planar. Some say it doesn't matter.

When I tuned up my 14" Delta years ago I did make the wheels co-planar. I removed the wheel (the top one in my case) and added shims. With that and help from some other things such as a good tension gauge, the saw, with a riser block, served me well with straight cuts, thick green wood, and resawing. With that saw and my bigger one, I've found that the blade tension is very important. Most of the built-in tension gauges seem to be horribly inaccurate.

If your blade stays where you put it and the saw cuts straight and tracks well it does sound tempting to just leave it alone.

For your saw, could the upper wheel have some shims behind it that could be removed? Mine came with shimming washers on both wheels, evidently to allow adjustment.

As for removing a stubborn screw or bolt, I usually soak threads in PB Blaster for a day or two then use an impact driver. That is risky on a screw, though, since it might be damaged. I just took apart and restored an old electric farm fuel pump built in the mid 60s that had been sitting outside in the rain the whole time. Many of the screws and bolts were rusted and difficult to remove. The PB Blaster worked on most of them. On some I had to use heat.

I would not be afraid to use heat in moderation if the parts diagram didn't show any plastic, fiber washers, packing, etc. and it wasn't too near a sealed bearing. I use a propane torch with a fine conical flame and keep it moving to heat some, then try the screw. Often mild to moderate heat will break loose a stubborn thread.

Sometimes freeze spray works as well as heat and is not as risky. (I have some left over from debugging electronic circuit boards.)

For removing the wheel itself, you may need a gear puller. A set of these are pretty cheap if you don't have one. There is some need of care to avoid breaking wheels such as made from cast iron. Tubal Cain has some good instruction on this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7jvmR1BsLs8

You can always make a puller if you have steel stock and have means to drill and tap. When disassembling the old fuel pump I had to make a custom puller to remove a thick cast iron motor plate that had apparently been installed with a press.

JKJ

Re: bandsaw questions

#3

Re: bandsaw questions

Stuart Johnson

When I purchased my MM16 Sam Blasco sent some set up instructions. Here is what he says about co planer:

---------------------------------------

Co-Planer Wheels—

Please forget everything you may have read about co-planer wheels. It really is given way too much air time and means even less on flat tire bandsaws, like these. You can, theoretically, have co-planer wheels for one particular blade at one particular tension and one particular tracking adjustment... Change blades, it all goes out the window. Think about it. You have a fixed lower wheel and an upper wheel that tilts -- how can this ever be co-plane? Within the vicinity of co-plane is more reasonable, and almost every saw is there. Waste your energy making a jig that does something, not making a jig to try and test something that can't really exist.

-----------------------------

Re: bandsaw questions

#4

Re: bandsaw questions

John K Jordan

>> ...on flat tire bandsaws, like these.

What about bandsaws with crowned tires?

Re: bandsaw questions

#6

no co-planer

del schisler

i would leve it alone if it is sawing ok the band can be maybe to the frount of the wheel a little , that may make the botton band to run to far to the frount of the wheel watch this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wGbZqWac0jU&list=FLYDEiGLzvqQNIl-nqvD2OOQ&feature=mh_lolz

Re: bandsaw questions

#7

Re: bandsaw questions

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

When I tuned up my saw (18" Jet with crowned tires) I checked to see where the blade was running under tension. If the tires and blade are fully engaged and the blade was stable in both axis (front-to-back and side-to-side) without the thrust bearings and guides controlling it, I called it close enough.

Of greater concern was the concentricity of the tires' surface with the wheels. A bump in the tire (or build-up of dust/resin) will screw up your cutting worse than most anything due to vibration and a wide kerf.

Re: bandsaw questions

#8

Re: bandsaw questions

Stuart Johnson

I don't know. It makes sense though that it would be out every time you changed blades. I've also read (on the internet so it must be true) if the wheels are co-planer any mis-adjustment could cause the the blade to run off the wheels.

On as side note is it co-plan or coplane ?

Re: bandsaw questions

#9

Skeptical... as usual

John in NM

I used to think that all bandsaws were basically intractable beasts (or perhaps untrackable? :D ) until I got one that tracks perfectly with zero problems.

I dispute what Sam says, though I do acknowledge that he knows a lot more in general about bandsaws than do I. The reason I dispute it is that I believe his conclusion is drawn from an insufficient sample of bandsaws - it is what you would say if you never came across one that did track perfectly.

On the other hand, none of this matters, practically speaking, because it became too expensive to build proper saws (PM 141 or General 490 for example). Having used a few of these saws, my theory is that the stiffness of the cast body/frame is what makes them simply track straight all the time. The wheels are coplanar and stay that way regardless of blade.

The modern trend towards welded steel frames has its advantages - large yet affordable saws, but with it comes a lot of tuning work to be done. I've used two of these kinds of saws, and they both were very finicky. One can make them work, certainly, but I've not seen them just show up with a blade already tensioned and cut perfectly straight regardless of what blade you put on them.

As to the question of crowned tires vs flat, I believe the idea is that flat tires won't care about coplanar wheels, provided they remain parallel and that crowned tires were invented so that the wheels could be slightly antiplanar without huge effect on tracking. With a sufficiently stiff frame, I would bet both of these hold true. No one makes frames like that any more though, which is why you see so much discussion of bandsaw tuning.

Re: bandsaw questions

#10

Re: bandsaw questions

Dan Bundy

Thanks fellows. Very good advice, as usual.

Original tires were black rubber and crowned. New ones are yellow, urethane (I think) and flat. I'll take a look at the videos.

DB