Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

able saw for a jointer --second attempt

Posts

able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#1

able saw for a jointer --second attempt

eliot feldman

I got hammered for asking about this last time -- and properly so.

Still, I think there's a simple and safe way for a board that's not too big -- say 8 in wide (I'm thinking wider than many 6 in jointers ) and a few feet long. Just glue on some runners along the edges. Then take repeated light cuts with a dado blade.

I would use a hefty feather board, too, because there's no splitter. If you don't want to wait for a glue up to dry, you could use screws and be careful about not running the blade into them.

Once one side is flat, even if a bit rough, the planner will do the rest.

What's wrong with that?

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#2

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

John K Jordan

My limited experience with a dado blade makes me wonder if that face will be perfectly smooth but a drum sander or planer could fix it. I'd take very light cuts and still stand out of the line of fire! Maybe a feather board or three on the top too?

Have you considered using a router for this? People build a simple cross frame that slides on rails and flatten even large slabs this way. Should be real quick for such a small board. Or take the board to a buddy with an 8" jointer?

JKJ

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#3

Kneale Brownson

If you have a planer, why not use a sled?


Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#4

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

eliot feldman

The first wood working project I ever made -- maybe 40 years ago--was a Woodshop-design workshop bench. I had only a vague idea how to do it from the Woodshop plans, and it's amazing that I pulled it off without hurting myself. It's one of those classic benches with angled square dog holes and two built-in vices. To make it, I actually made a really big router sled from long -- twelve foot -- aluminum angle iron. I still have it shoved away in my garage somewhere. It has numerous little lift levers, etc. The idea was to make a sled that holds the work piece and uses a router that slides in the aluminum tracks above the object to be flattened on one face. I used it to flatten the hard maple top of the bench. It worked fairly well, too; but I had to do a lot of planning and scraping afterwards. A learning experience.

My post was not so much about actually needing to flatten a board. I kind of like to solve little problems. Maybe , this time, I'll actually flatten a smallish board the way I described just to see if it will work!

Actually, now that I think about what I said, why not glue on the runners and put THAT in the planner to begin with? The only advantage I can think of is that you may need to flatten a board that's wider than the planner.

Thanks for not laughing this time around!

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#5

Re: If you have a planer, why not use a sled?

eliot feldman

You're absolutely right, of course. In my reply to John, which I wrote before I got your post, I answered that the only advantage I can think of, is that the board may be wider than the planner.

And now that I think more about it, how would you flatten one side of a board that's wider than your planner? ( I mean without taking it to some professional.) Perhaps it's a piece of really fine exotic wood that you don't want to cut up and glue back together.

I can think only of a router sled arrangement, which is a big deal, I can tell you.

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#6

Re: If you have a planer, why not use a sled?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

A planer sled's the best. I've tried a router sled for a coffee table top and that was a one-time exercise, won't do it again. For a regular dining table that was too big even for a timesaver, I glued up the center portion, had that flattened and then added on side pieces. The whole thing then got flattened with a jack plane, followed by a jointer and smoother.

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#7

Simple answer ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

And now that I think more about it, how would you flatten one side of a board that's wider than your planner? ( I mean without taking it to some professional.)

This is where a couple of handplanes really add to what you can achieve in the workshop.

It really is as simple as that.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#8

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

Barry Irby

I think you could do it on a TS, with the rails glued on the edges. The thing that would worry me is you would have the blade sticking up and it would "appear" out from under the plank at each pass. This sort of mind numbing repeated exercise is the sort of thing that would cause my mind to wander and I would end up touching the blade. Big ouch.

The rails will work with a planer. Just do a nice job of gluing them on. Hot glue will work. Lay the board on a flat surface and "balance" it like you want it and glue on the rails. They should be as thick as the warped board including the "warp". Then run the whole thing through the planer, planing the board and the rails.

I recently flattened some boards by gluing tapers on one side That filled the "void" under the high points. I used shim shingles. They went through the planer fine and I flattened one side and then removed the wedges.

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#9

There is a reason....

John in NM

Why the typical planer is wider than the typical jointer.

You can easily flatten one side of a 12"-14" board with an 8" jointer. The only downside is the need to remove the swing guard to do it.

If you don't have a jointer at all, then the best way is a toss up between a planer sled and a scrub plane. There are various router methods too, but personally I think the effort of building the jig is better spent on a planer sled.

There is sure to be a way or two to do it with a table saw, but I doubt they would work as well or be as safe as the sled or a scrub plane. The jointer itself is not exactly a safe machine, but they work really well, making it the preferred method.

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#10

Re: There is a reason....

jerry roberts

Remove the swing guard. OH YES. That brings back memories. I did that once on my 8 inch. As I was running it through I forgot my little finger was hanging over the board edge where the guard used to be. I felt a sharp pain and looked down. Blood on my litter finger. I had cut a nice little notch on the corner of my little finger. Had a hard time explaining that to my doctor. He said Ill bet you don't do that again. Correct!

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#11

Re: Table saw for a jointer --second attempt

Grant in Iowa

Eliot,

Here are a couple ways I tackle this age old problem:

If my 8" jointer is too narrow to face joint a given board, my first choice is to move the jointer fence as far over as possible to admit as wide of a piece as possible. On my Delta jointer, this allows a board of nearly 10" to slide between the guard and the fence. I make one heavy pass very slowly with the board being flattened at least somewhat down its middle. In the resultant wide flat area, I have a place to lay a flat board of 8" width that will support the wider board through the planer. If I remove the guard (not recommended), I can handle a board 11 inches wide in this way.

Another way is the method with a carrier board beneath the board to be face planed, then add shims with a touch of hot melt glue where the board being planed doesn't touch the carrier. Run this through the planer until flat, then remove the board from the carrier, flip it over and plane it again.

On boards too large for my 15" planer, I will do the carrier board trick, but run it through my 25" drum sander. I typically use heavy paper like 33 grit until it is flat, then work up through the grits. This can be time consuming, and hard to handle larger boards this way, however.

I did recently create a trammel jig for my PC 7518 router with a 1" flat cutting bit and used this method to flatten some large slabs, which was messy but did go faster than using my 25" sander. See the below photo of the finished project, which has 22" wide slabs 7' long that came out quite flat. Each slab had to be placed on a large flat assembly table, shimmed and clamped so it wouldn't move, and then I went to work with the router trammel. Maybe ten minutes per side. Once more or less flat on each side, I had help from my wife running them through the sander, then some final sanding with a Fein 6" orbital. Each of these cherry slabs weighed around 100 lbs.

There are many ways to skin a cat, and most of them would likely be more refined than the dado blade method. The major drawback from my perspective is that the blade would get a lot of use very quickly, and therefore need an expensive sharpening.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa


Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#12

Here's a simple router sled/ trammel *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

Here's the basic idea for a router sled setup. The benefit is infinitely large pieces can be worked with this method.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa


router sled easy cheesy on youtube

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#13

Shorter version - no table saw

Hoa in Alameda

Still, I think there's a simple and safe way for a board that's not too big -- say 8 in wide (I'm thinking wider than many 6 in jointers ) and a few feet long. Just glue on some runners along the edges. Then take repeated light cuts with a dado blade feed it though a thickness planner, taking light cuts. Keep feeding the board (with the runners attached) through the planner until one side is flat.

I would use a hefty feather board, too, because there's no splitter. If you don't want to wait for a glue up to dry, you could use screws and be careful about not running the blade into them. Make sure the runners are co-planar.

Once one side is flat, even if a bit rough, the planner will do the rest.

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#14

Re: Simple answer ...

eliot feldman

You must be right. After all, years back, they had to do it that way. It's probably very satisfying , too.

I was trying to see if there is a way do it with power tools assuming no jointer or a board wider than the jointer.

You must be pretty good with hand planes.

Again, now that I think about it, I have a bunch of those really big old wooden planes that I pick up out in the country stores.

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#15

Derek is good with hand planes

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Are so are the people who hang out on the handtools forum :D . Drop by. Someone will be glad to help you out.

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#16

Lots of scrub plane options...

John in NM

For years I used a Stanley #3 that was of their cheaper handyman series. $20 or so in the junk store. A narrower plane makes a better scrub. Open the mouth a bit with a coarse file and put a strong radius on the cutting edge and you have one. They take a deep cut and roughly surface fast.

Then one day I dropped it on the floor and it broke in half (probably been cracked at the mouth for years). So I took the blade and lever cap to make this:


Hardest part is cutting the blade bed nice and flat with a chisel, but a guy could also make one with the lamination method and do that cut at the chop saw (and be done a lot faster! :D ). The lever cap bears against a big brass wood screw - nothin tuit.

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#17

Re: Lots of scrub plane options...

eliot feldman

What a beautiful plane!

Would you believe that I actually made one of those Kanna -type Japanese planes, and I did it entirely with a chisel and the edge of a file. It's obviously not for scrubbing; it's a very fine thing. I got the blade from a wonderful lady in California. She took a liking to me and GAVE me a fabulous Japanese food cutting knife. My wife is afraid to use it because it is so sharp! I believe I am one of the few on the hand tools site that actually did it. There's no question that it's my best plane. It took me an entire summer to do it. But, between you and me, I'm not that good at using it. I mean, I was down to sharpening with special oils on a special supper flat surface with multiple diamond films and all that. And still, it takes a lot of practice to get good at it.

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#18

Re: I would never do what you suggest

AZ in Colorado Springs

I've cut dadoes into plywood and other boards using a Dado stack. I've also watched others do it. I've seen the boards get a bit cocked around and fly off the saw top like a Frisbee. Seen a guy catch one with his groin and go down like a sack of potatoes.

It's worst with plywood that bows a bit. So you're going to take a board that isn't flat at all, and a smallish one at that (i.e., lighter, rather than heavier) and pass it over a Dado stack. I think that's asking for trouble. With rim blades, and chippers (2,4,6,8 teeth?) and an irregular face on the bottom of the board being presented to the Dado stack, they'll be grabbing in a really uneven pattern.

I realize you concluded that the sled can just go to the planer, but I think it worth saying that this is an unwise adaptation for the table saw, especially for anything less than a cabinet saw with an enormous out feed table.

Re: able saw for a jointer --second attempt

#19

Re: I would never do what you suggest

eliot feldman

I believe I will take your advice and not do it.

If you read my "third attempt" , you'll see that I switched to trying to do multiple cove cuts and then smoothing out the "washboard" with a plunge router with a planning bit and wide base -- also possibly not the safest way to go.

I am curious though: I do have a serious 5 HP cabinet TS with a substantial out-feed table. But what has the size of out-feed table got to do with it. Unless you mean just that you don't ever want the work piece trying to tip over at the end of the cut. That would be crazy altogether!