Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

M & T joint, How tight?????

Posts

M & T joint, How tight?????

#1

M & T joint, How tight?????

Barry Irby

I am building beds for my Granddaughters. The head board is cherry with a solid cherry panel with the grain horizontal. There is a 3" with tenon into the post near the top and the balance of the panel hangs in a slot in the post. The tenon will be glued, but the balance of the panel will not, allowing it to expand and contract. There will be a rail parallel to the panel below with a similar tenon. The rail provides strength to help the posts resist racking.

How tight should the tenons be? I can tap them home with a mallet, but I suspect they are a bit too tight. Any suggestion on how to determine exactly what needs to be pared away? I tried rubbing chalk on them trying to "ink" them, but not have much luck.

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

#2

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When I took the class in the Headley shop we were instructed to make all joints loose enough to be brought together with hand pressure and tapping. If it takes a mallet to bang a joint together it is too tight.

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

#3

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

Jesse Cloud

I was taught the same way Bill was. Remember that however hard it is to close the joint in a dry fit, its probably going to be worse with glue.

Also, it doesn't need much glue, but you do need to glue both surfaces (mortise and tenon).

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

#4

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

Keith Newton

With the exception of just a few woods, the tensile strength perpendicular to the grain is the weakest of all the properties, which means that making it too tight, can cause the mortise side to split from the wedging action.

Be sure to use the slower grab glue when they are really tight, so it doesn't grab before you get it all the way together. Most glues, except epoxy don't like to be moved after the initial set.

On the other side of this issue, if you have made a really sloppy fitting M&T joint, using thickened epoxy is really the best choice, because it likes being thick better than too thin.

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

#5

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

William Duffield

I agree with Keith. This time of year, if you are using West System, you should be using 205 slow hardener. Next month, as shop temperatures climb well past 90°, you might even consider switching to 209 extra slow hardener, but if you do, note that the resin to hardener ratio (3:1) is different than the 206 and 205 hardeners.

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

#6

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

As Bill noted, the mortice and tenon must be capable of being pushed together. What can also be said it that the result stays together - does not fall apart.

I like to use Titebond Liquid Hide Glue. The benefits are slow grabbing, the glue lubricates the parts and makes it easier to slide together, and then the joint can be taken apart (with steam) if there is a problem. Lastly, old hide glue does not have to be removed. It can be reactivated by fresh glue.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

#7

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

Forrest Addy

Glued M&T joints: 0.004" to 0.008 clearance staying on the low side for harder woods like maple, mahogany, cherry etc and the high for pine and other softer woods. The surface fibers take up moisture and rapidly swell making tighter fitted joints difficult to seat without a lot of pounding. Joints fitted in this range tend to be self fixturing. Joints fitted looser may drift unless securely clamped, pinned, or fastened.

I see so-called experts splintering sacrificial scraps used to protect the parts from lusty blows delivered by commander sized mauls and I cringe. Too tight is not a good fit. Just because it can be dry fitted by vigorous hammering doesn't mean the assembly is properly fitted any more than if it would fall apart if not clamped. Good fits are neither too tight or too loose: they are just right.

Experienced woodworkers quail at this specification saying such precision is silly, not needed, inappropriate. They declare common fractions good enough for them. But in fact, these same experienced woodworkers have fitted glued M&T joints as a "light slip fit" for generations - centuries The above 0.004" to 0.008" clearance is simply long-standing practice quantified.

Most present day woodworkers have dial and digital calipers handy so fitting joints by the numbers is no longer guesswork.

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

#8

agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What Forest says is supported by the data in the technical gluing manual from Franklin Glue Company and my experience. The tolerance for a perfect fit for a sliding together joint is only +/- a few thousandths of an inch, relative to "perfect". That is to say that a joint gap 0.005" bigger or smaller from perfect will be too loose or too tight. It is no wonder it take experience to get these joints right.

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

#9

What to do if joint siezes in assembly

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is a fundamental polymer property of the typical partially set woodworking glue that the glue will resist moving quickly under shear, but yield to moving slowly. So, what does that tell us about how to deal with a seized joint during assembly?

Bashing will try to move the glue quickly, not a favorable situation. Steady clamp pressure moves the glue slowly, just what the glue will allow.

When assembling I have clamps already set and at hand. If the joint resists closing up I apply the clamp. Even several minutes after assembly a joint can be slid with clamp pressure.

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

#10

I learned that from you before.....

Barry Irby

I knew the way to go was slow clamping pressure from one of you previous posts. It was set home in my brain when I tried to assemble a sliding dovetail. Tapping with a hammer yielded nothing. Pressing with a clamp sent it home easily and gently.

I stared these into submission yesterday. They slip home nicely with hand pressure. For fear that my chiseling and paring techniques are not up to par I plan to use slow setting epoxy. Or maybe Old Brown glue. Hmmm?

I will dry assemble and tape off the joints with blue tape, disassemble and glue up.

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

#11

Thanks all....

Barry Irby

I have the first of two beds ready to assemble. At least the head board.

I do not have a dial indicator or any other way to measure the M and T down to .004 or .008, but neither did those who went before me. I do have a vernier caliper that gets down to .01, but it will only get the first half inch or so of the mortise.

I think I will use the thickened epoxy to fill and chisel marks etc.

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

#12

Re: I learned that from you before.....

William Duffield

Old Brown Glue is another high quality liquid hide glue. I use it and Franklin. Keep it in the refrigerator for extended shelf life, and put a small bottle of it in your pocket to warm up for a half hour or so before you want to use it.

Plan to leave liquid hide glue and epoxy in the clamps overnight at least. If you are on a tight schedule, Tightbond I, II or III can usually be removed from clamps in a couple of hours.

www.oldbrownglue.com

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

#13

Re: What to do if joint siezes in assembly

William Duffield

If the glue up is at all complicated, I do practice dry runs with all the components and clamps and glue bottles and applicators in place, and repeat until I'm sure I'm not going to fumble anything when the glue is applied. If it is a particularly complicated glue up, the practice even includes picking up, waving and setting down the glue bottle. You don't want to knock your glue bottle or pot on the floor and watch it roll under a machine or bench with glue already in some of the joints.

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

#14

Re: M & T joint, How tight?????

John McGaw

A long time ago in my WW experience I built a small free-standing bookshelf which has five shelves, each of which has six wedged through mortise and tenon joints. I learned that tight is good but if you are using water-based glue which swells wood then it can easily be way too tight no matter what you thought during dry fitting. My solution, seeming brilliant at the time, was to skip the water-based glue and use Gorilla glue which does not swell wood and actually acts as a decent lubricant. I managed to get all thirty wedged joints together without a hitch by gluing first one side then, then after that has set, the other side. The shelf is still rock solid and that is saying something in a piece holding large weights and having no back or braces to eliminate racking.