Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Buying wood

Posts

Buying wood

#1

Buying wood

Lee Ohmart

Recently I took the advice of a friend who is a professional wood worker on where to buy some red oak and cherry. The lumber yard was quite a distance away so I took them up on their offer to pick me out FAS rough lumber and deliver it for a very reasonable price. The day it was delivered, I was just leaving for work so I did not have an opportunity to scrutinize it very well. While we were unloading is, there was one very noticeable piece of cherry with some 1.5 inch knots and the driver called the yard to get me a credit. They were very nice about it and I thought everything was OK. This morning I moved the wood from my garage into the shop. One other piece of cherry had so much sapwood that it will be, for all intents and purposes, unusable. While it met the technical description of FAS cherry in that one side of the board showed unbroken heartwood, the board is probably 75% sapwood and there will be no way to hide that in a bookcase. Two of the red oak boards have so much of a bow that getting the four foot sections I need out of them is going to be very difficult at best. At this point I'm feeling like I will never do business with them again unless I go to the yard and pick out my own boards. Is my disappointment in this unreasonable or is this what is to be expected from so-called professional hardwood suppliers?

Re: Buying wood

#2

Re: Buying wood

Keith Newton

Anytime I can go pick my own, I do. If they allow other woodworkers to pull their own, then when the packs start getting down, all that will be left, will be the dregs, and that is what you will likely be getting.

One of my longtime dealers has gotten to where they will only sell by calling in an order, then either they deliver, or I can pick it up a half day later. I only deal with them as a last resort now, then I just have to plan on buying about 50% extra.

Re: Buying wood

#3

Re: Buying wood

TomD

It is hard to say. There is only one yard, or was, around here that I ordered from sight unseen, and the stuff was great. I am just a hobby guy, but I would buy several hundred Bft at at time. At one time the place was enormous, like several aircarft carriesrs of endless shed roofs. The buildings were torn down, but they were amazing. The point being that they had huge stock, a really small place has only what they have, and it will be hard for them to get the perfect wood for you. When buying a few hunfred Bft I got wholesale prices, which was good, because they were so cheap that if there was a knot or two in there, it certainly worked out both in the sense of having enough wood to get the job done and fair value. Downside is some of that wood I still have from before my first daughter was born and it was 20 years ago.

For a variety of reasons, I can't imagine ordering the 5 or six pieces of wood I want and thinking that would work out. One time I ordered specific pieces cut to a list. The expectation was that they would come dimensioned possibly not cut to length. I didn't have aplaner at the time.I was building my first bench back in the early 80s. That time the guy actually laminated all the oversized parts and dimensions parts perfectly. Which was not called, for, but one couldn't really complain of his diligence.

There are wholesale prices, retail prices, picked retail prices, and it just keeps on going. All the risk can't be on the seller, but some of them do an amazing job.

Re: Buying wood

#4

Re: Buying wood

John in NM

Unfortunately, this is fairly normal for hardwood suppliers. The trade does not recognize sapwood as a defect, since a great deal of stuff produced for sale is stained they don't worry about it.

I avoid suppliers who limit picking - not because I have a problem with that, but because it tells me that they have a problem with it. Suppliers who sell enough volume to not worry much about letting one guy pick through a whole unit for 3 boards if he likes tend to have better lumber for sale in my experience.

The only advice I can offer is to try to plan your projects to work with what you have available - the biggest point is to buy either rough sawn or hit or miss planed wood - that will give you extra thickness for flattening boards. Most big suppliers will carry hit or miss in addition to S2S lumber. The cabinet shops prefer S2S since it reduces steps between lumber and a face frame. If you don't specify what you want, you'll probably get 3/4" thick surfaced stuff.

Sapwood in cherry or walnut is a tougher one - you may just have to go pick out the lumber, and pass on using it if the forklift comes out with just six boards, all twisted and half sap. I've had that happen before, you go back next week and there is a new unit and you can usually just grab a few off the top and they are all ok. I still figure on about 40% waste with cherry, due to avoiding sapwood. If I were buying sight unseen, I'd probably figure on 50% or worse.

Re: Buying wood

#5

Re: Buying wood

John Foster

Sorry to differ here guys. I work at a building supply store that sells construction grade lumber and I am a hobby woodworker who buys from a local hardwood supplier that serves the commercial market. Probably the biggest sin in both of these places, is being nice guys and allowing customers to pick through lumber. If lumber has been properly graded and stored, a customer should take it as it comes off the pile and buy enough to allow for waste. If we let everyone pick over the lumber to get what they want, what do we do with the dregs? Sell them to the guy who orders by phone and doesn't have a chance to pick it over? Sell it to the meak customer who won't raise a stink? Just raise our prices to account for the higher cull rate?

I have seen customers who have bought standard rough pine for standard pine pricing, and then go out into the yard and demand to pick through the lift for clear pine. When I try nicely to explain our position, they look at me like I am an idiot and continue to curse our business for selling crap lumber.

Your hardwood lumber yard probably does the majority of their business with commercial woodworking shops. They will win or lose on their quotes by cents per board foot. Diminishing their product quality by picking over lumber or expecting them to cull more and raise their prices makes them less competitive and hurts everyone.

If you are expecting perfect lumber, make that clear when you order it, and make it clear that you are willing to pay for it.

Wood still grows on trees, and it is still marketed in a a high volume competitive commodity market. If you can't live with this there are many easy and inexpensive alternatives MDF, OSB , particle board, finger joint, vinyl veneer............

Re: Buying wood

#6

Re: Buying wood

Hank Knight

Lee, I feel your pain. Most lumbr yards around here that sell hardwood have very little empathy for hobbyest woodworkers and do business as John described above. Consequently, I don'd do business ith them except on a very limited basis, and then only if I can hand pick my lumber. I order most of my hadwood from reputable, online suppliers like Hearne Hardwoods, Steve Wall Lumber and several others. These dealers are accustomed to selling to small-time guys like me and do their best to ship you good stock. Even then, they will drop a horseshoe or a snake on you occasionally. It helps if you can talk to the guy who's going to pull you order and tell him what you need. I've found them to be very accommodating. In your case, I don't think the lumber yard treated you as they would any commercial customer, so you probably don't have much room to complain. Treat it as a lesson learned. You might, however tell your friend what happened and see if he has any suggestions for how to deal with the poor service you got.

Re: Buying wood

#7

That is like what I was trying to say...

John in NM

Basically, I have a choice of a couple hardwood yards in Albuquerque. I typically go to the one who does enough volume that a picker and chooser wouldn't upset them much. That is the yard where you don't actually need to pick through lumber to get decent boards - any five out of the first two layers will give you what you need and the ones you leave will likely be usable by their other customers.

The other yard - the one I rarely use - makes a big deal about all this stuff. That tells me they do a lot less volume, so it puts me in the position of having to worry about picking and choosing too. The bigger yard I'm never need to do it to get stuff I can easily use. One can only assume that the bigger volume yards get better units or something else that dilutes the problem.

At your yard, you could suggest to the boss something I've seen work very well (assuming you guys do enough volume). When a guy comes in and wants 3-4 boards, you charge him about 40% over what he'd pay at Home Depot. He can pick whichever one he likes at that rate, and you can be sure he won't find a board nice enough to come back next time :D

When we were building our house, I often went to a yard that did this. I was buying ~3 ton loads (that was what my truck would carry) so they treated me like a customer they wanted, but one time I saw the 1 board treatment while I was there. Have to admit, it seemed to work pretty well.

Re: Buying wood

#8

Re: Buying wood

howard gorman

My hardwood supplier is about 1/2 hour from my shop and they let you go through the piles to pick what you want, but they want it put back neatly. If there is a local sawmill nearby that might be a good option. But, and I think this is the heart of the matter, as woodworkers we are creating something very personal. That process starts with choosing the lumber that either appeals most to us or to our customers. How the color or grain pattern affects one person may be different to another. In my view, I think it is always the better option to pick your own boards so you can make specific judgements on placement, etc. If you have no other option, then I agree add in extra board feet to allow for what the lumberyard is choosing for you.

Re: Buying wood

#9

Re: Buying wood

David Bair

I guess I'm very lucky. My supplier has been in business for over a century, and now I know why. They cater to hobbyists and hold an annual, free woodworking show. They price based on the dried width and thickness out of the kiln. Their prices are more than reasonable and get lower with larger volumes. And, they understand woodworkers. Most of the employees are woodworkers and nobody minds sorting; they will forklift down bundles, open new bundles and even help you sort (especially helpful when you're looking through 8/4 white oak or hard maple 12 footers). They do insist that everything be restacked but will even help you do that.

Re: Buying wood

#10

Re: Buying wood

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Years ago I bought cherry from Weaber Lumber in Lebanon, PA. Minimum order was 300 bf and they picked it for you, and would load up your vehicle. Entire bundle was premium stuff including some figured boards.

This was high quality stock and very little went to waste. Unfortunately they've

changed their operation to now limit it to oak and poplar apparently for flooring.

Since then I've made friends with a couple of tree service firms and have a good Woodmizer guy, so I've got everything I need outside of specialty stuff.

Re: Buying wood

#11

Re: Buying wood

Chuck Kettler

If you are at all close to Indiana you should consider going to Frank Miller Lumber. Great wood and really nice folks to work with.

Re: Buying wood

#12

Re: Buying wood

Lee Ohmart

I put a 4 foot rule on the bowed red oak. Over that distance the deflection is only about 1/8 inch so I think I can work with it unless any of you have been in this situation and found otherwise. I bow to your collective wisdom. (sorry, can't help myself some times) The cherry, as I indicated earlier, is useless with my bookcase plans and being desirous of heartwood only. I did consider using the sapwood with creative glue-ups to create special effects. Anybody else ever try that? In an effort to find a solution I called the lumber yard to see what they would do about the situation. It turns out the 6/4 oak was all they could scrounge up so I really did get the dregs. We talked about swapping the cherry board out for something better and he's going to call me back. He was very cordial and said I always had the option of coming to their location to pick their piles. Trouble is they are half-way across the state from me. There was a guy local to me (Brewer, Maine) who had a band-saw mill but he seems to have disappeared. Too bad, he was a wicked nice guy to work with when I bought some quarter sawn red oak. There is also a lumber yard over in the Mexico/Peru Maine area I might take a look at next time. They operate a showroom for woodworkers to show/sell their work.

Re: Buying wood

#13

Re: Buying wood

Jim Hoeller

For quite a few years I bought from a saw mill in Moscow Mills Missouri and one of the owners would price the wood (red oak, ash or white oak) at $.90/BF from the pile or $2.00/BF for picking and choosing. I took the $.90/BF and rarely was disappointed. If you have saw mills in your area, visit them and see what they offer.

Re: Buying wood

#14

Re: Buying wood

Yonak

Re : "There was a guy local to me (Brewer, Maine) who had a band-saw mill but he seems to have disappeared."

Lee, it's hard for me to believe that small mill operators are that scarce in your area. Try calling Woodmizer. They maintain a list of mill owners and could, likely, tell you who's in your area. I discover Woodmizer owners I didn't know about in my general area from time to time.

Of course, the wood will be green and, as such, you will be buying wood for next year's projects, but the price should be good.