Re: patent rights
Alan in Little Washington (NC)
As Ellis mentioned, there is little out there that has not already been invented in one form or another (items that fall under either Design or Utility Patent categories). I agree, based on a number of formal and informal patent searches I have done. There is probably something the same or similar out there designed in recent times or designed as far back as Andre Roubo's era! And just because something was never patented doesn't mean you can patent it, or that it won't affect your patent application. (note- I am not a patent attorney and I may be omitting caveats and details from the following discussion)
Would-be inventors need to read and understand about patents if they intend to attempt to patent something. Among the many patent principles are three, "prior art," "public domain" and "non- obvious," that would-be inventors need to understand early on.
"Prior art" is anything already out there patented or not that may be the same, similar, or perform the same function. "Public domain"- when an idea or widget is readily available to the public (already out there), either as an idea, drawing, or model, it is considered to be in the "public domain." Posting on a woodworking forum puts the subject in the "public domain." A widget that has already been in the public domain, is not patentable. To be eligible for a utility patent, the item must be unique (not found in prior art) and "non-obvious" - a rock to hold papers down is obvious. This may be an over-simplification, but a funnel-like structure that is mounted below a saw or other dust producing machine doesn't seem non-obvious to me. Frankly, I think some of the patented dust collection stuff on the market should not have received a patent due to one of those principles. However, the USPTO, once it has issued a patent rarely if ever reviews and rescinds it. It can be challenged but that must be done by a complaint through the courts at the complainant's expense.
Now, as to actually marketing an invention- according to my research most inventions (many sources say 95% or even 99%), patented or otherwise, never make it to market. Not because they don't do what the inventor claims, but because they can't be economically manufactured, there is not a big enough market to justify the tooling, manufacturing, and marketing expenses, or the market is full of similar items or the item is too complex for a simple task.
Even if you have a good item, manufacturers, especially in woodworking, will not buy it from you- too much money up front for an unproven item. At best they may license it. Licenses for items like woodworking accessories typically earn between 1% - 5% of wholesale. (FYI, the highest product license fees (20%) are for Beatles related merchandise.) Unless you license a high sales, high dollar item, like an iPad/iPhone (instead of an IBOX), you aren't going to get rich. You can read all about licensing in the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO)Exchanging Value - Negotiating Technology Licensing Agreement training manual. It is straight forward, an easy read, and available online for free.
Unless you have a guaranteed lucrative invention, it rarely makes sense to spend the $10K to $20K it may take to get a patent. Remember, not a cent of the money you spend on filing fees (about $2K - $3K) and intellectual property lawyers is refunded if a patent is denied! Patent attorneys are pretty much a necessity since patents must be written in a strange arcane language and they know how to deal with the USPTO- there may be a lot of back and forth with the USPTO during the review process which can take up to three years. One of my applications is now into its third year.
I have some experience in this area. I licensed two items, the I-BOX, a box joint jig manufactured and marketed by INCRA, and the Lock Miter Master jig for setting lock miter bits, manufactured and marketed by Infinity Cutting Tools. I have other "almost" successes and many flat out rejections too! I had two "sure things" under development at Lee Valley/Veritas- the first one was terminated after 1 month, the second one lasted about 6 months but was eventually cancelled at the final decision point. I even made it to the point of contract negotiations for another design with Woodpeckers before the deal fell through. I have also been rejected by some of the bigger companies like Franklin Glues. One company, a nationally know manufacturer of router bits never responded to my proposals. That is not at all unusual. Some companies do not want to hear about your ideas- they are afraid that if they have a similar item in development, that you will sue them claiming they stole your idea when their product hits the market.
I would starve if I tried to live on my royalties and design work. I am retired Navy and Fed Govt so these projects were not necessary to my livelihood. I do this when the spirit moves me because I enjoy it and I am also a problem solver. You'll never see me on Shark Tank!