Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

The fading of woodworking

Posts

Re: The fading of woodworking

#26

I'm surprised...

John in NM

That you say taproots are a myth - I had understood that they were the result of both species and conditions, so it wouldn't surprise me much that one wouldn't find them on the east coast. Out here, they are considered to be quite large and common to trees that you see growing anywhere (like mesquite) as opposed to those you only see growing in washes (dry stream beds) or other commonly wet areas (like ash or cottonwood).

Even so, I've seen mesquites that fall over easily when planted as landscaping and are heavily irrigated. The assumption is they never grow a taproot since they don't need to. A few years later they are very top heavy with abundant foliage and an inadequate root system to hold them upright during a succession of storms producing heavy rain and strong winds. I don't recall ever seeing a non-landscaped mesquite fall over like that though, even in washes.

Re: The fading of woodworking

#27

Interesting...

Tony - Memphis

I've heard a similar explanation as to why Bradford pears are so prone to limb damage in this area. In summary, they are being gron outisde of their comfort zone and therefor grow in such a way that makes them vulnerable to splitting. I can't understand why anyone would plant one here....we lose bunches of them each tiem we have a decent storm. A local horticultural wizard told us in a class....don't fight Mother Nature....you will lose! His philosophy was to plant native and plant them in their desired location. Makes sense.

Re: The fading of woodworking

#28

Mother Nature bats last...

John in NM

Always a good thing to remember! :D

Re: The fading of woodworking

#29

Re: Buck up Chuck

ChuckInND

I'm kind of surprised that I haven't got much support on the table saw dust hood subject here. I guess if some of you also don't believe that I designed the table saw dust hood I'll put it to you this way, Ghostses can not give the reasons for the design when he was asked, I can. Plus I can prove that I did the design way before he did. And Phil Thien I can only guess is just upset because I pulled all of my work out of his website. I get the impression that he thinks that anything that someone posts in his website automatically becomes his property.

Re: The fading of woodworking

#30

Re: My last thoughts

ChuckInND

I think that I'm done with forums for awhile, if not forever. For me it's just another setup for disappointment. I will thank some of you that were on a more positive note however. Now I will be deleting this site and the other forums from my favorites. Take care, and good luck. Good bye everyone.

Re: The fading of woodworking

#31

Chuck *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I'll step in here at the risk of you getting pissy at me like last time, but I think you've missed some things that may be the basis for what you are complaining about.

First, as I've said before, your dust collection fixtures are nicely made. The problem you may have is that people have been making similar items for their saws for more than 20 years. There's a post in the Articles Section that contains a whole segment on making a drop-box dust scoop on a contractor saw, and, while crude in appearance and not as efficient when compared to your sheet metal work, it's probably doing an acceptable job.

I understand that you feel that you came up with this solution all on your own, which may be quite true, but I'd (almost) bet that if you did a proper search of U.S. Patent records you'd find something that is so close to your design that you'd run the risk of getting sued for patent infringement if you tried to market your hood.

There have been any number of articles in the woodworking mags over those decades on how to do/make pretty much what you've done. It's not surprising, therefore, that people will ignore you if you try to lay claim to being the original inventor of the idea as applied. You're not the first guy who, having come up with what he believes to be a new wiz-bang item, finds out that there are 15 guys before him that thought so as well. It can, indeed, be discouraging. While Intellectual Property (patents, copyrights, etc.) are not my field, I've had several clients who thought they'd invented a "better mouse trap". After I referred them out to a real patent attorney, they came back to tell me there was no point in going further either because there was already some design on record or it would cost too much to go the whole 9 yards.

Second, and perhaps more to the point of your post, people on WC are not prone to get into some old-style flame war with others on a different website. If you've come here seeking to enlist "troops" in your dispute with Mr. Thiel or others, you're going to be disappointed.

It may be hard, given what you've written, but try to find the positive side of things. You'll go farther and get far more support from others.


Saw -Dust

Re: The fading of woodworking

#32

Re: Chuck

Brian Holcombe

One of the many great things about WC is the complete lack of flame wars.

If you're putting stuff out there on the internet people are likely to copy it...that's one of the major purposes of it.

I felt very highly complimented that a few guys on here and on SMC built frames in the style of my frame, so I think you're looking at it the wrong way. I borrow, they borrow, ect.

Look at the many many people who copy nakashima, krenov, Maloof, ect....didnt stop anyone from wanting original work from them and probably pushed them to keep innovating and proving to the field their mastery.

Re: The fading of woodworking

#33

Re: Chuck

John in NM

On the one hand, Chuck was looking to profit from his work - so I can completely relate to his frustration with the internet.

On the other hand, you are entirely correct that if you put it up on the net it is going to be copied. And Mark was entirely correct that while Chuck's dust hoods and ducts may be better made and more effective than what others make, this is not exactly breaking new ground.

I've had one success in web marketing, and a bunch of projects that went no where. The main thing that made the success a success is that no one else was providing that product, for which there is genuine if small demand.

Re: The fading of woodworking

#34

Let's Also Be Clear

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

that in the Internet Age, a patent is of very limited use. Why? Because anyone can take the patent design and make one for themselves if they wish to take the time. It's only when they try to make a zillion and sell them that the patent comes into play to try to halt them taking a commercial benefit from the patented idea/design. Of course, the effort ain't free so save up large a pile of scheckles to pay for lawyers and experts if you plan on trying to enforce your patent. And, of course, even that won't fly in China either. :\

Put a picture of your gizmo on an Internet forum and you're just begging the readers to follow your example. Two months later the reader/maker will only remember that he "saw it on the net" but your name will be lost to the ether.

Seems Chuck thought that if he posted his pix here or on some other forum that readers would beat a path to his door to buy what he'd made simply because of the merits of what he'd come up with. Unfortunately, Chuck has had a very hard "you can't get there from here" real-world lesson in economics and marketing.

Re: The fading of woodworking

#35

Very true...

John in NM

Patents are useless on the internet, and as far as I can tell, the seem to be getting to be useless even in large scale manufacturing.

I've seen lots of name brand knockoffs on ebay - the companies seem to be living with their Chinese contractors underselling them on their own products - either because the prices they get from China make it worth eating the lost sales or because they simply can't do anything about it without moving manufacturing back to the US and quintupling their prices.

I have one tool in the works I used to dream of patenting - but eventually I faced the reality that even if it were patent eligible, I would never have the ability or resources to defend the patent domestically let alone if I were to get parts made overseas.

Re: The fading of woodworking

#36

Re: Ok, heres the story

ChuckInND

When I started the table saw dust hood quite a few years ago I did it because of all the people that were complaining about how poor dust collection was with Contractors table saws. I'm not sure how many of you know, but I'm pretty sure that Ellis knows that I spent a lot of time trying to get it right. I built about three different versions of it before settling on the last and current design. Then I also spent a considerable amount of time on the open back of the saw in a user friendly matter where nothing interfered when tilting the blade. I will admit that I had some luck with the dust hood with a retailer for a few months before that fell through. After that I came to realize that most if not all the folks that were complaining about dust collection on Contractors saws were Cabinet saw pushers, and not the people that own Contractors saws. In my opinion times are changing, people are now using Jobsite saws, and the cheap harbor freight dust collector, then spending a bunch of time and money trying to improve it. In my opinion it's like putting lipstick on a pig, again I think that I have a better setup. But after my more recent experiences with the dust hood I'm in no big hurry to advertise the DC now either, or anything else. One thing that has always bothered me about forums is if it looks at all like your going to make a buck on something your scolded for it, and in some cases booted out. I'll give credit to Ellis for having some patience with me on that subject. To sum it all up, I'm not retired, nor am I rich, I'm more at the bottom of the income bracket in this country and have worked for quite a few arrogant low paying and verbally abusive employers when I had those blue collar jobs. Now I have been out of work for quite some time, and I'm trying to go a different direction but I have to make my time worth something, is that so bad ? Unfortunately I haven't found what is worth my time apparently. End of story like it or not.

Re: The fading of woodworking

#37

Re: Chuck

William Duffield

I try to remember to thank the inventors who post ideas on the web because it can encourage them to post more ideas, and it might help someone else to wade through all the drivel that is out there to find really useful stuff. I know I usually appreciate it when a get at ataboy from someone.

I can remember one instance in which I am glad my name wasn't mentioned. Soon after I had published on WoodCentral, photos and a description of a lumber rack I designed and built, an obviously derivative design was published in a woodworking magazine. However, whoever did it made a couple of mistakes or misinterpretations which I believe seriously compromised its structural integrity.

Another funny story: Some guy decided his goal was to get a tip published in every woodworking magazine. One of them was something I had posted here on WoodCentral. I only heard about it because someone here pointed it out to me. I have no idea where he got the rest of his ideas, or if he ever accomplished his goal.

Who did these people steal from? Not me; I published all my tips freely, for whoever could use them. They did steal from Ellis, and indirectly from all of you, because one thing that attracts readers (and writers) to this forum is the uniqueness and value of the things we learn here. I'm not going to go away because this happened, because I like it here, and I like all of you people, and I like the stuff you build. Although Chuck's post that started this thread pains me a little, it's not going to make me give up and go away either.

Re: The fading of woodworking

#38

Re: Ok, heres the story

John in NM

Well, dust chutes and hoods may not be worth your time, but that doesn't mean there is nothing that is worth your time.

Everything I've ever made to sell I knew it was a risk. So far there is only the one niche I've found that really paid off. I would call that dumb luck more than anything else.

I'm afraid I don't see what you expect to get from these discussions. Its clear enough that you don't enjoy them.

Re: The fading of woodworking

#39

Re: Chuck

Brian Holcombe

There is a line that I think is easy to cross when it comes to this stuff. I work on the honor system of; if it looks like xyz I credit them. For example I did a version of Chris Hall's Japanese toolbox and credited him. Chris shares an incredible amount freely and not crediting him would, in my opinion, be quite offensive. I've been lucky in that most people who borrow on me are nice enough to say so.... And that is limited to individual craftsmen building for their own use.

I think if you're gonna borrow you need to credit.

Re: The fading of woodworking

#40

Ellis Walentine

Making a living

Ellis Walentine

I have invented a lot of things in my half-century of woodworking and have exactly one patent to my name, for an architectural integrated office system I designed back in the 80s for a contract furniture company. As a condition of employment, I was required to assign the rights to my patent to the company. Not much joy there. But, in going through the patent process, I learned how much "prior art" there is in nearly anything you think is an original idea. More broadly, design is always predicated on something -- your personal experience, the things you've seen or used, whether or not you attribute your design or parts of it to inventions that have gone before. The point is to not get too hung up on originality, or to kid yourself.

Prior to my contract furniture experience, I had been designing and building furniture and architectural woodwork for a decade or more, and I continued to run my shop, even after I went to work on my new career path at Rodale Press. Looking back on my career, I can see that I have always gravitated to problem solving and invention, but I only ever invented one thing for production and speculative sale, a small line of domestic lighting -- lamps and sconces mostly. I learned the hard way that my lack of interest in sales was not a good match for a business that depends on it. I never came close to recouping my investment in jigs and fixtures and marketing materials, but I definitely learned some valuable lessons.

The way I was actually able to make a decent living was by doing what I loved most: solving problems for people and inventing things of elegance and quality and utility. The secret was that it was work for hire, not gambling on building a better mousetrap. By working my way into the good graces of several architects and interior designers, and always delivering great stuff, on time, I was able to keep our production schedule full. The customers were invariably wealthy and my prices reflected what they were willing and able to pay. Best of all, there was no speculation. My only risk was that I might overlook something on a project and have to start over. But, I thrived on getting myself out of jams, too.

I know this has been a rambling approach to making my point, so forgive me for that, but I think it may be germane to your situation, if not a total solution. Instead of trying to reinvent yourself, try acknowledging what you are -- a guy who enjoys solving problems involving equipment and sheet-metal work -- and center your portfolio around this ability rather than getting married to a particular production item and frustrated by your inability to market it successfully and to protect your intellectual property. I don't know what other skills you can bring to the table, but I'd seriously consider thinking of yourself as a marketable gun for hire. Decide where your interests are and who your potential customers are, and sell yourself -- either to an employer or as an independent contractor -- not just the last widget you made. And don't feel sorry for yourself. If an idea can be protected, protect it; if not, don't be surprised and hurt if somebody lifts it.

My 2¢,

Ellis

Re: The fading of woodworking

#41

Re: Making a living

ChuckInND

Ellis, I've pretty much come to the conclusion that in todays world were the demand of cheap imported crap is so high that I'll never make a living from any of what I've done. Plus the fact that also in these recent years blue collar jobs have taken a horrible beating, and I see no end in site. I certainly can't blame anyone for trying to avoid that type of work. I know someone made the comment that what I did wasn't exactly ground breaking, or something similar, well I say ok, but from what I've seen out there I've spent more time getting the dust on the contractors saw and the jointer right then anyone else, including what the manufacturers did, and they paid an employee to do it. But whatever, I gave it my best shot. And yes, I luv to tinker. The only things that I was good at in school was math and mechanical drafting. You'd probably get a kick out of the large old Posts wood drafting table that I stumbled on quite a few years ago at a rummage sale and refinished. I have an old arm to go with it.

Re: The fading of woodworking

#42

Model making is the perfect job for that skill set

Dick Coers

It took me 27 years to get the job, but I spent 14 years as a model maker for Caterpillar. It's a tough job to get, only 2 people out of 100,000+ worldwide employees. I was a mechanical draftsman when I heard about the model shop. I immediately sent in a transfer request and was denied. Basically 3 careers latter, I got the job! Took a down grade to get it, but I knew that was the job for me. The entire day is filled with decision making, inventing and working to do one off items. A lot of making full size operator stations out of 2x4s and rigid urethane foam takes some real inventiveness. Basically taught myself how to operate a CNC router after a few days of training. If it wasn't for the young engineers telling me when they needed it, how little they had budgeted, all at the first instant I had seen a powerpoint presentation on their computer, I may have still been there. Well that and endless meetings and self-evaluated performance reviews that were such a study in frustration. But 41 years on the workforce turned out to be enough. Having a blast in retirement now!

Re: The fading of woodworking

#43

Re: Model making is the perfect job for that skill

ChuckInND

I never went to college, so it narrows my choices now.

Re: The fading of woodworking

#44

A chuckle...

John in NM

"If it wasn't for the young engineers telling me when they needed it, how little they had budgeted, all at the first instant I had seen a powerpoint presentation on their computer, I may have still been there."

Yeah, we have one of those where I work too. I'd find it funnier if our machinist wasn't always on the verge of quitting thanks to that engineer! :D When I worked for furniture shops, it was often the designer who'd never built anything who filled this role!

Re: The fading of woodworking

#45

Re: Making a living

John in NM

About the only way I could see being able to market your dust improvements would be to the manufacturers themselves - which would be a pretty tough sell, but could spark some interest if you could come up with a way of demonstrating that you're not just another crank with an un-tried idea for them - bet they get a dozen of those a week and are pretty deaf to them.

The tool I'm working on I mentioned to a manufacturer a couple years ago, and never got a reply. More recently when I was inquiring about becoming a dealer for their tools to sell in conjunction with my own, the guy I was dealing with expressed interest in seeing my tool. Not sure how that could help you at all, but they seem to pay attention when you demonstrate that kind of seriousness about moving forward with or without them.

Re: The fading of woodworking

#46

patent rights

John K Jordan

>>I have invented a lot of things in my half-century of woodworking and have

>>exactly one patent to my name,... As a condition of employment, I was

>>required to assign the rights to my patent to the company. Not much joy there.

Yikes, it sounds like there was not much incentive for more innovation there either.

I liked the way they did it at the large laboratory where I worked and retired from: we did give up the rights to all patents BUT they gave the individual an extremely nice cash award, some sizeable innovation awards for selected patents, and a percentage of any royalties if licensed. I got royalty checks for years for a couple of my patents, not much, but hey, it was fun! These financial incentives, plus recognition, awards banquets, and best of all, excellent line items for the personal annual reviews had researchers working hard towards something completely new. A buddy of mine is about to get his 14th patent and his picture will go up on the wall of fame!

If more did it this way everyone would be happier and could result in a huge financial payback to the company.

JKJ

Re: The fading of woodworking

#47

Re: patent rights

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

As Ellis mentioned, there is little out there that has not already been invented in one form or another (items that fall under either Design or Utility Patent categories). I agree, based on a number of formal and informal patent searches I have done. There is probably something the same or similar out there designed in recent times or designed as far back as Andre Roubo's era! And just because something was never patented doesn't mean you can patent it, or that it won't affect your patent application. (note- I am not a patent attorney and I may be omitting caveats and details from the following discussion)

Would-be inventors need to read and understand about patents if they intend to attempt to patent something. Among the many patent principles are three, "prior art," "public domain" and "non- obvious," that would-be inventors need to understand early on.

"Prior art" is anything already out there patented or not that may be the same, similar, or perform the same function. "Public domain"- when an idea or widget is readily available to the public (already out there), either as an idea, drawing, or model, it is considered to be in the "public domain." Posting on a woodworking forum puts the subject in the "public domain." A widget that has already been in the public domain, is not patentable. To be eligible for a utility patent, the item must be unique (not found in prior art) and "non-obvious" - a rock to hold papers down is obvious. This may be an over-simplification, but a funnel-like structure that is mounted below a saw or other dust producing machine doesn't seem non-obvious to me. Frankly, I think some of the patented dust collection stuff on the market should not have received a patent due to one of those principles. However, the USPTO, once it has issued a patent rarely if ever reviews and rescinds it. It can be challenged but that must be done by a complaint through the courts at the complainant's expense.

Now, as to actually marketing an invention- according to my research most inventions (many sources say 95% or even 99%), patented or otherwise, never make it to market. Not because they don't do what the inventor claims, but because they can't be economically manufactured, there is not a big enough market to justify the tooling, manufacturing, and marketing expenses, or the market is full of similar items or the item is too complex for a simple task.

Even if you have a good item, manufacturers, especially in woodworking, will not buy it from you- too much money up front for an unproven item. At best they may license it. Licenses for items like woodworking accessories typically earn between 1% - 5% of wholesale. (FYI, the highest product license fees (20%) are for Beatles related merchandise.) Unless you license a high sales, high dollar item, like an iPad/iPhone (instead of an IBOX), you aren't going to get rich. You can read all about licensing in the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO)Exchanging Value - Negotiating Technology Licensing Agreement training manual. It is straight forward, an easy read, and available online for free.

Unless you have a guaranteed lucrative invention, it rarely makes sense to spend the $10K to $20K it may take to get a patent. Remember, not a cent of the money you spend on filing fees (about $2K - $3K) and intellectual property lawyers is refunded if a patent is denied! Patent attorneys are pretty much a necessity since patents must be written in a strange arcane language and they know how to deal with the USPTO- there may be a lot of back and forth with the USPTO during the review process which can take up to three years. One of my applications is now into its third year.

I have some experience in this area. I licensed two items, the I-BOX, a box joint jig manufactured and marketed by INCRA, and the Lock Miter Master jig for setting lock miter bits, manufactured and marketed by Infinity Cutting Tools. I have other "almost" successes and many flat out rejections too! I had two "sure things" under development at Lee Valley/Veritas- the first one was terminated after 1 month, the second one lasted about 6 months but was eventually cancelled at the final decision point. I even made it to the point of contract negotiations for another design with Woodpeckers before the deal fell through. I have also been rejected by some of the bigger companies like Franklin Glues. One company, a nationally know manufacturer of router bits never responded to my proposals. That is not at all unusual. Some companies do not want to hear about your ideas- they are afraid that if they have a similar item in development, that you will sue them claiming they stole your idea when their product hits the market.

I would starve if I tried to live on my royalties and design work. I am retired Navy and Fed Govt so these projects were not necessary to my livelihood. I do this when the spirit moves me because I enjoy it and I am also a problem solver. You'll never see me on Shark Tank!

Re: The fading of woodworking

#48

Re: I can relate.

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I worked for near 40 years as an Engineer. During this time I designed many automated assembly and test machines for automotive components and switches. Due to the fact none of my machinery was more than a "one off" product and was captive to the factory I worked in, none were patented. They were considered as "Proprietary", and were covered with a tarp when we had visitors that might be interested in copying a portion or the machine in its entirety.

Our patent attorneys explained it would be fairly easy for a competitor to copy the design with a few minor changes and the cost to defend the patent would not be feasible.

I really didn't care as I had signed an agreement that assigned any patent to the company as part of my employment condition.

As to doing projects for others for free, after my retirement from my Engineering job, I have done several.

BUT, one of the things I made very clear to my friends and family was that I would never, ever take a paying job for my hobby. I felt (and still believe) that doing paying work would require me to do a project on a schedule, do it their way and it become a JOB.

That would destroy eventually destroy the enjoyment of my "hobby". I have way more money invested in my shop and tools than I could ever recover based on my limited design and woodworking skills, therefore I want it to remain a hobby.

As far as helping people, I enjoy the "thank you" if given, but never really expect one. My reward is far greater in the memories that I retain of the times I have been fortunate to be able to help. I have never regretted helping anyone, as I do not expect a reward (other than the memories) nor a thank you.

The other way we are different is that I would never do a task that may not be wanted, I would always ask first if I could help (like mowing a yard). For many reasons doing thing not requested may lead to resentment, not appreciation.

Re: The fading of woodworking

#49

Re: Well I do know this

ChuckInND

A very high percentage of woodworkers now days are retired. Everyday less people in this country will be able to retire, including myself. Times and people in this country aren't what they use to be, and may never be again.

Re: The fading of woodworking

#50

Those that don't prepare won't be able to retire

Dick Coers

But plenty that did prepare sure will. What has changed, is that in the past, anyone with a High School diploma(or less) could walk into any place with no skills what-so-ever. They would be trained on the job, and then be told to stand in one place all day. Do that for 30 years, and you get a pension. Yes that has changed. But if you prepare with the right schooling (which may mean going back to college in your late 30s or 40s), you can become a valuable employee or start your own business. Make some smart money decisions and investments, and then you will be able to retire. You just have to work smarter today(maybe not harder) at putting yourself in the right spot, but you will be able to retire before your body retires! I know this as much a generalization as your comments, but it is meant to point out a positive option. I reinvented myself many times over my work career. The longest I ever held one single job was 15 years. But I did that twice at one company and earned a pension. Lucky? I worked damned hard to put myself into the position I am today.