Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Test for Silicone Contamination?

Posts

Test for Silicone Contamination?

#1

Test for Silicone Contamination?

don stephan

Furniture restorer asked me to veneer over old mahogany veneer on a dining table top. He was hired to strip paint and refinish, but found sand throughs after the paint was stripped. A test vacuum pressing with the veneer and my usual urea formaldehyde, on MDF, still looks great. Customer called him this morning and said the tabletop veneer has bubbles everywhere. The finish that was used is NC lacquer, which should have had no effect on urea formaldehyde. Min ambient temp 70 deg F throughout the pressing. There was no bubbling when the veneer was wetted to help remove the veneer tape after 24 hours.

My suspicion is silicone contamination of the old veneer from use of furniture polishes. Is there any test to determine if in fact there was silicone contamination? If that's the case, is there any way to remove the silicone, or sand back to uncontaminated wood?

The restorer is anxious to get the table, sand off the new veneer and urea formaldehyde, and veneer again. I'm anxious to investigate here first before making any promises to the customer. Slicing through the bubbles might be very informative, but that sounds to me like a commitment to re-veneer and I'm not at all sure the results would be any different.

Re: Test for Silicone Contamination?

#2

Did you use paper backed veneer?

Dick Coers

A very heavy thinned out coat of lacquer can release the adhesive between the paper and the veneer. I've never heard of silicone effecting the adhesion of glue. It doesn't effect the adhesion of finish either, it just wants to repel it enough that the coat does not lay down evenly. It's still stuck on very well.

Re: Test for Silicone Contamination?

#4

Re: Test for Silicone Contamination?

don stephan

The veneer used was raw veneer from Certainly Wood, not paper backed.

Numerous times I have been told and read that it is very difficult successfully to re-caulk a bathtub after silicone caulk was used, because nothing wants to stick to silicone caulk, including new silicone caulk. That, coupled with the often described "fish eye" finishing problem over silicone contamination, makes me wonder if silicone contamination of wood will interfere with adhesive bonding.

Re: Test for Silicone Contamination?

#5

I still don't think it is a silicone issue

Dick Coers

How about stripper residue? Was it neutralized before you got it? Did you sand the substrate before pressing the veneer? Just wondering if the adhesive you used wasn't able to get a bite on the wood because it was sanded too fine, or pores were still full of stripper/paint residue. Chemical reaction between the stripper residue and the adhesive? What did the paint look like before stripping? If the paint was okay, not much evidence that silicone was present.

Re: Test for Silicone Contamination?

#6

I feel your pain,

Keith Newton

About how many bubbles are there? The only way I can think to test, would be to maybe take an exacto knife, and cut the veneer bubble off, then examine the substrate. You might be able to tell by how the remaining glue has drawn back from a open pore, probably in a near perfect circle. You might then put a drop of something in that same spot, then monitor if it gets repelled also. If so, I would think this gives you and out, for the expense, or at least a leg to stand on.

If this was due to insufficient glue, or too slow laying up for the open time, or too thick a platen on a less than perfectly flat substrate, or low vacuum pressure, those things would likely produce pretty large irregular shape bubbles, while contamination would likely be more uniform circles.

If there are not so many, and you determine that it isn't silicone or a wax residue, you might consider drilling in from the bottom and injecting epoxy from the back. I've done this before with success. If you stand the top on edge, so you can use parallax by looking down both sides at once. I can place my finger on a blister, then sight down the edge while placing the drill bit on the opposite side, then move my head to change my viewing angle (triangulate) to adjust one or two time, then drill through the substrate, while still holding my finger, feel the drill before it penetrates the veneer. Use a piece of tape or drill stop so you can drill fast initially, then slowly just before breakthrough.

Then with a syringe, I've injected thickened epoxy through the hole, forcing a bigger bulge, which gets pressed by down by a block with weight, or back in the bag. However, epoxy won't stick to silicone or wax, so this would only work, if it was glue starved.

Don, these are just my thoughts with limited input. I hope this helps figure it out.

Re: Test for Silicone Contamination?

#7

Ellis Walentine

And another bubble fix

Ellis Walentine

Bubbles in veneer are not unheard of nor insurmountable. I discovered a way to glue them back down invisibly. First, I modified a regular Exacto knife by grinding a knife edge all the way around, on both sides, then sharpening and polishing the edges smooth.


To fix a bubble, insert the knife tip at one edge of the bubble, with the knife angled as low as you can get it, and slice an opening approximately the length of the bubble, in the direction of the grain. Squirt a little yellow glue along the opening, and use a clean index finger to squeegee it into the air space of the bubble, pressing it in all directions. Then, put a little piece of wax paper over the repair and clamp it down. The low entry angle of the knife blade means that the top flap will overlap the underside and be virtually invisible.

Ellis