Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Efficient dovetail making (by hand)

Posts

Efficient dovetail making (by hand)

#1

Efficient dovetail making (by hand)

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Background- I dovetail some drawers about 3 times a year. It takes me a while to remember all the details. I enjoy the sawing and chiseling and don’t like the time it takes to lay the dovetails out. I thought how I could avoid screw ups and make layout more efficient. The result.....

Pic 1 book



I bought a Lee Valley log book to keep sketches and records of stuff I build. It is pricy but a dandy book for the purpose. I find it useful to draw out the dovetail spacing on paper so that it looks right and I remember all the details of where the drawer bottom slot goes, allowing enough room for a half pin below the slot, what to saw and what not to, etc.

Pic 2



I fasten two drawer sides together with two brads. Then I cut the sides to size. I scribe the depth of the front and back tails. I set a marking gauge to the width of the half pin, top and bottom, and scribe this mark. Then with a divider I divide the distance between these half pins into the number of tails to be cut and make a mark at this spacing. All these marks can be seen in Picture 2.

Pic 3


I find that variation in the angle or even spacing of the tails isn’t noticed. But they need to be the same size. And, later for checking, I need to get a square in the pin hole. This situation led to a handy way for marking the tail cuts as seen in Picture 3. The pin width is just marked from the blade width of the square. That’s it for marking!

Pic 4



I made a saw guide with a lip to hook over the face of the drawer side and the end is cut at 14 degrees. I simply align the end of the guide with the line on the drawer end and use the end as a guide to start the saw. After 2-3 strokes with the saw the orientation of the saw is established and I finish the cut free-hand. It takes less time to saw the tails than it would have taken to mark them. This procedure is a substantial time saver.

Pic 5


I waste out the pin hole with an electron assisted coping saw (AKA band saw) , stack several sides and chisel the pin holes to the scribed base line. A quick check with the square to see the base line is right and I’m done.

Re: Efficient dovetail making (by hand)

#2

Re: Efficient dovetail making (by hand)

John Pappas

Bill, I did this article years ago. Ignore most of it, but I think the first part about how I look at dovetails as a "tail/pin" set is worth considering. Also, the dovetail marking gauge you have works well with this approach. For pins first, mark the end of the board. For tails first, mark the face the board.

http://woodcentral.com/articles/handtools/articles_547.shtml

Re: Efficient dovetail making (by hand)

#3

dividing a space or line into parts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I find that I can divide a space into X parts with a divider quicker than any way I have found as an alternative. Make a guess at setting the divider for the length of the part. Walk the divider down the distance and it will likely come up short or overshoot and call this error distance "O". Estimate O divided by X and adjust the divider opening by this amount. Walk the divider down the distance again and repeat refinement of divider span if necessary. I never have to make more than 2 adjustments of the divider to get the divided distance just right. It takes but seconds.

I just timed dividing an arbitrary line into 4 parts and it took 25 seconds with an error in the divided fraction of less than 1/16"

Re: Efficient dovetail making (by hand)

#4

Re: Efficient dovetail making (by hand)

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

I probably do not cut more dovetails than you each year, but I look forward to them - in the same way as I do bringing together the design of any piece I build. Even with carcases, where dovetails are a more utilitarian method of joining panels and where the emphasis is on strength, the dovetails on drawers are designed for the way they look and compliment the whole. I do not seek a short-cut ... otherwise one may as well be using a router and jig.

Drawer design covers a number of areas, with dovetails being an obvious one. Other issues include whether to groove or use slips, the placement and the slope/angle of the dovetails, the proportions of the drawer front and drawer sides, and the materials (wood type and grain orientation) used.

Further, while carcases may have bold dovetails that are more evenly spread, drawers will have dovetails that are finer and where the spacing and angles are chosen for each. Where possible, I prefer fine, slim ("London") dovetails with a 1:7 ratio. Carcases and sliding dovetails may use a broader slope, such as 1:5.

Here is a set of shopmade dovetail guides (from angle brass). They range from 1:5 through 1:8. They are square at the rear, and may be used for both pins and tails ...


I also use dividers to set them out (most recent set of drawers) ....


... or space them by eye ...



So you see, while I appreciate that you do things differently, my preference is not to keep records and make templates. They serve me no purpose.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Efficient dovetail making (by hand)

#5

Re: Efficient dovetail making (by hand)

William Duffield

If anyone can't figure out Bill's or Derek's method, Meghan Fitzpatrick has made a very clear video of the process (tails first) that works for any number of evenly spaced tails, including London and more robust widths. It uses two pairs of dividers.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MUiPJF_jNEA

Re: Efficient dovetail making (by hand)

#6

Re: Efficient dovetail making (by hand)

Brian Holcombe

I have a similar preference to Derek wrt dovetail angles with one exception; I find very small dovetails look better at 14 degrees. On my picture frames I found the 1/4" tall tails in need of the steeper angle.

For drawers where the pin is 1/2-5/8" tall, the shallow angle looks nice.

For case sides with through dovetails I like the steep (14 degree) angle.

Weird, right?