Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Scraper Plane

Posts

Scraper Plane

#1

Scraper Plane

Howard Gorman

I would appreciate your recommendations on the best one to get. I have reached my tolerance from the sore thumbs using the cabinet scraper by itself. Even when using the holder that I think Veritas makes, someshow I end up skinning my fingers. Thanks for your suggestions.

Re: Scraper Plane

#3

Scraper Plane Recommendation

Tom Colligan

I've heard in the past that the smaller of the Lie Nielsen planes was very good but you might want to post this on the Hand Tools forum, Howard.

Re: Scraper Plane

#4

Re: Scraper Plane

David Yoho

Even though I have the scraper plane from Lee Valley, I find I reach for and use one of my Stanley #80 cabinet scrapers more. I hardly ever use a card scraper.

Re: Scraper Plane

#5

Re: Scraper Plane

Hank Knight

+1 for the Stanley #80. I have the big LN 112 and a Stanley 12 1/2. I almost never use them. If I need something more robust than a card scraper, the Stanley #80 fills the bill every time. I find the #80 much easier to set up and use than the others.

Re: Scraper Plane

#6

Alternative

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Howard, I prefer cabinet (card) scrapers to scraper planes. I use them to remove small sections of tearout rather than smooth a face with difficult grain. In that regard, a smoother with a closed up chipbreaker works well.

One of the cabinet scrapers I really like is simply a 3/16" thick section of a plane blade. This has a burr raised by grinding on a 80 grit CBN wheel, which takes seconds to do.


The thickness of this blade means that it does not get hot in the fingers.

This is how it is prepared ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Scraper Plane

#7

Re: Scraper Plane

howard gorman

Thanks Everyone!

Re: Scraper Plane

#8

Late response...

Tony - Memphis

I have the Veritas scraper plane. I'll be honest. It has quite a learning curve IMHO. I have yet to master it. I sorta regret getting it.

Tony

Re: Scraper Plane

#9

Howard...

Christopher Fitch Memphis

I replied to your question over on the Hand Tools board...take a look.

Re: Scraper Plane

#10

Re: Howard...

Howard Gorman

Chris, thanks for that great review, there is nothing better than getting good advice from people who are actually using these tools. I know you said that you would not get the Veritas cabinet scraper, but I was thinking of starting with this before buying the more expensive scraper planes. I use spokeshaves a lot, so I would like to see how this similar body style works as a scraper. Thanks again for all the advice and photos.

Re: Scraper Plane

#11

Re: Howard...

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Anytime Howard.

One point about the Cabinet Scraper in comparison to Spokeshaves...it's meant to be used only on the Push stroke..ie. pushing away. It's possible to pull it towards you but it's somewhat awkward that way.

Good luck!