Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Which way up?

Posts

Which way up?

#1

Which way up?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


Shown are the veneer pieces for the sides of the bed-side chest of drawers I am making. I have the two pieces oriented opposite in the up-down orientation. I am trying to decide what end to make up on the side panel.

Re: Which way up?

#2

Re: Which way up?

Stuart Johnson

I find the piece on the right is has a pleasing look that causes the eye to look up. The one on the left is just the opposite and hard to look at. If they were side by side it might not make any difference.

Re: Which way up?

#3

Adam of Oakland

Re: Which way up?

Adam of Oakland

that is gorgeous veneer, Mr. TIndall - I would probably orient the panel such that the grain swooshes *inwards* as it moves upward, if that makes sense. So if i understand what you're presenting in the photo, i'd go with the one on the left...

Re: Which way up?

#5

Re: Which way up?

Larry Barrett

This is a bedside table, right? So one side with the cathedrals up, since you get up in the morning, and one side with the cathedrals down, since you lie down in the evening. Nice veneer either way.

Re: Which way up?

#6

Re: Which way up?

John C Lucas

At first glance i picked the one on the right because the center light area pointed up. After a closer look i think the one on the left has more lines that tend to lead your eyes up. Then the darker lines pull your eye up into the lighter area so i lean toward the left panel orientation

Re: Which way up?

#7

Ellis Walentine

Context

Ellis Walentine

Seems to me you've got two things going on here, Bill -- the cathedrals and the sloping grain on either side of it. I believe that our eyes like to see cathedrals arching upward, so if that were the only criterion, you'd choose the right-hand orientation. But, in the left-hand piece, the sloping grain creates a sense of sweeping motion upward and inward, reminiscent of the buttress of a tree or the upward energy of a fire, which might have a more dramatic effect than if the grain were converging downward, as it is on the right. In the end, the decision might best be informed by looking at the overall side elevation, because the top, moldings, foot, etc. will be part of the final composition.

No clear winner here for me.

Ellis