Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Am I a WWking Snob?

Posts

Am I a WWking Snob?

#1

Alan Young

Am I  a WWking Snob?

Alan Young

I'm working on the last details of a cabinet. The top sections' door will hold a stained glass panel. The bottom section has two doors. I am making overlays that mimic the stained glass from the upper case.


The original plan for the lower doors was to have "thick" veneers ie 3/16 glued to a colored back plane. My first attempts were rather "gappy"- but that was in fact what I was going for-trying to mimic the lead that separates the glass in the actual stained glass panel- I was suggesting either gold gilded back plane or a black back plane---



- the client wanted tighter spacing-OK- I said- that's fine I can tighten the gaps-- as we discussed this project over the phone and e-mails (This is a long -distance project) The client decided they wanted more of a "jig saw" fit---So I am working on a different method-basically I laid a full printout of the flower pattern over an Anigre veneered panel (Panel is 1/4" thick")

Then using various carving tools I cut out each individual shape.


As each shape is cut out a line or crevice is formed that defines the shape on the panel. (P.S.-This picture is some what deformed-due to camera angle I guess)


I then took the paper cut out sections and am in the process or tracing them over various veneers- Birds eye maple, Sapele, Walnut, and QS White oak. My technique is not standard marquetry/inlay but it is going to turn out OK- I think---Here's the snobby part-- As I started searching for other other inlay/marquetry/intarsia techniques- I saw examples by several craftsmen I've seen before-Including -Silas Kopf, Paul Schurch, Patrick Edwards, Craig Thibodeau-(he's posted here before-)...Their work is excellent-I saw some videos on the techniques used usually stacked cut-out technique-while I have two scrollsaws-neither is in working order so I am using the technique I described earlier..Taking forever to get to the real point--During my searches, I saw many pictures of inlay/marquetry-I was struck by how much I loved seeing the work where flowers/plants or Victorian/classic shapes were presented-But---show the same level of competence and skill only with animals or people as the subject and I am just turned off---Why is that?-These examples were executed with terrific technique and the desired end results were no doubt pleasing to the artists-But I just seem to find the "art-form" used to show faces of people or animals just un-classy-So- There you have it--- I think I am standing on someones toes with Army Boots-I can't seem to move-

Re: Am I a WWking Snob?

#2

I know what you mean, Alan

Yonak

Depictions of plants seem to have an art nouveau look, possibly because of the natural curves in nature, but faces, where the demarcations are human defined, tend to look like cartoons.

Re: Am I a WWking Snob?

#3

Not at all

Craig Thibodeau

Hi Alan,

No you're not a woodworking snob, I tend to agree that flowers and plants look more interesting than people and buildings; which shows in my work. Oddly enough though, people, animals and buildings are much harder to cut and shade accurately in marquetry. Seems a wavy line in a flower is hard to notice but a wavy line in a building or legs that aren't exactly the same size on an animal are very easily picked up by the eye. You're also correct that you picked the hard way to make your panel, it really is perfect for packet cutting on a scroll saw. Maybe it's time to get one of your broken ones working and start doing some marquetry flowers?

Nice looking cabinet by the way, very complex.

Craig

Re: Am I a WWking Snob?

#4

Re: Am I  a WWking Snob?

David Bair

Jeez, the news said you died. It's got to be weird to hear your name in that context. And no, you're not a snob, just a primo woodworker.

Re: Am I a WWking Snob?

#5

Re: Am I  a WWking Snob?

Joseph Mulherin

No, Alan, you are not a snob, rather an artist who has the very good vision to cut the intricate pieces and arrange them into a very pleasing arrangement copying the upper glass panels. I liked the second picture with the darker outlines. These people you are doing the work for are to me like house seekers coming in and making the same snobby remarks like your customers and they are without the needed visionary

talent you have for making a very good piece of work. They are the snobs......

Re: Am I a WWking Snob?

#6

Re: Am I  a WWking Snob?

Joseph Mulherin

follow up: repair one of the scroll saws

Re: Am I a WWking Snob?

#7

Re: Am I  a WWking Snob?

Gary Smyth

Snob no. But perhaps not as attuned to the skill of marquetry selections as other art appreciators and/or cultures. The French, in particular, seem to love what you do not. You're no snob because you do not favor what some others do. Make your own choice and feel comfortable doing so. You're in the company of others.

Also, several Google quotes --

a "Simpsons" quote. "Marge, I may not know art, but I know what I hate. And I don't hate this.

"I don't pretend to know much about art; But I know what pleases" New York Times - May 28, 1880

Justice Stewart Potter, Jacobellis v. Ohio, 1964. "I shall not today attempt further to define the kinds of material I understand to be embraced within that shorthand description; and perhaps I could never succeed in intelligibly doing so. But I know it when I see it, and the motion picture (insert music, art, speech as desired) involved in this case is not that.

Last, Monty Python (Cleese and Idle), "The Last Supper" skit, "I may not know art, but I know what I like".


Re: Am I a WWking Snob?

#8

Alan Young

Great Quotes!

Alan Young

Gary-Another confession- When we first got married my wife pointed out to me that I didn't appreciate things that I couldn't do... ie "if I can't do it it must not be worth doing" Ok that's a bit harsh but somewhat illustrates some of my personal tendencies that I have worked hard to modify over the years- Hence my feelings of "guilt"? when I look at marquetry such as you showed- realizing the great skill and time it took to produce that scene...Just pulling of the dog is an incredible feat--I think I'm ready to take off my Army Boots!

-Alan

Re: Am I a WWking Snob?

#9

Alan Young

Re: Am I  a WWking Snob?

Alan Young

Hi Joseph-I must say these clients are very good to work with/for...They will listen to my suggestions-and give great consideration sometimes liking my idea and incorporating it sometimes not--My "snob" reference was aimed directly at myself --and yes-I need to get these scroll saws working!

Re: Am I a WWking Snob?

#10

Alan Young

The News of my demise ....

Alan Young

was just presented to me here! I hadn't heard. Years ago my parents were in Hollywood and photographed his "Star" they mounted this and gave it to me on my birthday---


Re: Am I a WWking Snob?

#11

Alan Young

Tyranny of the urgent

Alan Young

Craig- I hacked my way through the rest of the inlays this weekend- result is OK.

Certainly wasn't time wise efficient--The intricacies of this type of work are fascinating-I seem determined to find every way....OK I'll get the Scroll Saws fixed...I hope you'll post pics of that latest side board when it's finished--

-Alan