Am I a WWking Snob?
Alan Young
I'm working on the last details of a cabinet. The top sections' door will hold a stained glass panel. The bottom section has two doors. I am making overlays that mimic the stained glass from the upper case.
The original plan for the lower doors was to have "thick" veneers ie 3/16 glued to a colored back plane. My first attempts were rather "gappy"- but that was in fact what I was going for-trying to mimic the lead that separates the glass in the actual stained glass panel- I was suggesting either gold gilded back plane or a black back plane---
- the client wanted tighter spacing-OK- I said- that's fine I can tighten the gaps-- as we discussed this project over the phone and e-mails (This is a long -distance project) The client decided they wanted more of a "jig saw" fit---So I am working on a different method-basically I laid a full printout of the flower pattern over an Anigre veneered panel (Panel is 1/4" thick")
Then using various carving tools I cut out each individual shape.
As each shape is cut out a line or crevice is formed that defines the shape on the panel. (P.S.-This picture is some what deformed-due to camera angle I guess)
I then took the paper cut out sections and am in the process or tracing them over various veneers- Birds eye maple, Sapele, Walnut, and QS White oak. My technique is not standard marquetry/inlay but it is going to turn out OK- I think---Here's the snobby part-- As I started searching for other other inlay/marquetry/intarsia techniques- I saw examples by several craftsmen I've seen before-Including -Silas Kopf, Paul Schurch, Patrick Edwards, Craig Thibodeau-(he's posted here before-)...Their work is excellent-I saw some videos on the techniques used usually stacked cut-out technique-while I have two scrollsaws-neither is in working order so I am using the technique I described earlier..Taking forever to get to the real point--During my searches, I saw many pictures of inlay/marquetry-I was struck by how much I loved seeing the work where flowers/plants or Victorian/classic shapes were presented-But---show the same level of competence and skill only with animals or people as the subject and I am just turned off---Why is that?-These examples were executed with terrific technique and the desired end results were no doubt pleasing to the artists-But I just seem to find the "art-form" used to show faces of people or animals just un-classy-So- There you have it--- I think I am standing on someones toes with Army Boots-I can't seem to move-





