Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Oil finish for walnut floor

Posts

Oil finish for walnut floor

#1

Oil finish for walnut floor

Barry Irby

My cousin has installed some walnut for flooring. Wants a "natural" finish. Tried BLO on some oak flooring and thought it needed to be thinned. Did not want to use thinner because thinner is not "natural".

So, what would you use as natural oil? Is there any such thing as a natural thinner?

Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

#2

No....

John in NM

In a word, there is nothing that will do what he wants.

In some circles, turpentine is considered "natural" because it comes from a tree, but I call that nonsense because mineral spirits come from the decomposition under the proper conditions of marine organisms like plankton and diatoms. There is a lot of refining to get from one to the other in both cases, but really, mineral spirits is as "natural" as turpentine.

All that said, I would not recommend using turpentine as the smell will be in that house for months if not years.

Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

#3

Bart Goldberg

How about Waterlox?


Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

#4

Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Look for Gym Seal products. The best, McCloskey's, went away due to VOC regs, but there are replacements. Basically an oil poly in a satin finish (Must be stirred).

Waterlox makes a satin urethane finish but it will be a harder film as it's a soya-oil base rather than tung oil.

Thing with BLO is that it will darken, especially when getting direct sunlight. That could get to be an issue. It also takes a long time to dry and polymerize.

Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

#5

Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

Howard Acheson

Pure tung Oil is a natural finish. It is pressed from the nuts of the tung tree. Google it and you will get the details.

However, it is not a very protective finish--no oil is.

Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

#6

Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

Steve jenkins

Check out Woca oil. It is a "European long oil". We used it throughout our house and love it. Pretty much totally waterproof,easy to apply and has a nice matte finish

Steve

Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

#7

Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

Howard Acheson

None of the finishes mentioned so far are "natural". All contain petroleum based thinner additives. These additives are not considered "natural".

Tung oil comes the closest but it comes with a lot of negatives. As I said previously, tung oil is not very protective. Floors will scratch and scuff. It takes a long time to dry and cure and has what many consider a objectionable odor which lasts a long time.

Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

#8

Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

walta

The time tested natural wood floor finish is shellac.

It is applied with an alcohol carrier. All of the alcohol will off gases in a matter of days.

If you have the budget eatable shellac is doable.

If you can live with a soft oil finish I like walnut oil. I think it hardens faster and harder than Tung or BLO.

Walt

Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

#9

Sorry

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

No patience for this "unnatural" green touchy feely stuff that makes some feel good with no practical benefit. The abuse either goes into the wood or the finish. I prefer for the abuse to be absorbed by the finish and then minimalist refinishing will restore the floor.

Most varnish is derived from vegie oils. Can't get greener than that. 20 gallons of refined petroleum in the gas tank and we are to humor a desire to save the planet by eschewing a gallon of varnish solvent. I suppose one could sacrifice a pine tree and use turpentine .

Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

#10

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Agreee with...

Jesper, Denmark

....your sentiment, and as "real" turpentine is distilled from pine stumps, no sacrifices.

Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

#11

I always look at it as a start

Dick Coers

if anything gets a person to think about taking better care of themselves and the planet, at least it is a start. Maybe misguided, maybe silly, but at least they are thinking about the environment around them. That can't be all bad!

Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

#12

Re: Sorry

Howard Acheson

>>>> Most varnish is derived from vegie oils.

The oil is not the issue in "green" varnish. It's the thinners and driers added to make the varnish easily brushable and promotes smooth flow-out.

That said, I too think that long term durability is more important than "green".

Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

#13

Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

Joseph Mulherin

Barry, I vote to have the cousin cover the new floor with just a poly urethane for the strength for longer lasting durability.

Re: Oil finish for walnut floor

#14

Shellac

Brian Holcombe

I finished my walnut staircase in Waterlox, and while I like it, the stuff stinks up the house for a few days.

My brother shellacked his floor and I believe he really enjoyed shellac as a floor finish. He didn't take unusual measures to prevent wear...he moved and the house was torn down.