Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Pricing furniture question.....

Posts

Pricing furniture question.....

#1

Pricing furniture question.....

Barry Irby

The post about the $60 drawer pull caused me to look at their site and the piece of furniture that had the pulls. It was $9600 in oak and $9800 in walnut.

Do they really sell those pieces at those prices? Does anybody? That piece looked like Ikea or This End Up. I hope Ikea and This End Up will excuse the slander.

If those pieces sell for those prices some stuff posted here should sell for $20,000 or more. Am I so out of tune with furniture prices that I simply missed the entire market. I would be making chests of drawers as hard as I could go for half of what they are charging.

I would think this was an Internet joke, but if it is they went to a lot of trouble.

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#2

Location, Location, . . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Barry,

As a house flipper you should know better. Price points in NYC won't pass, let alone fly, in Norfolk or Baltimore. But when a 1 bedroom 600 sq. ft. apartment goes for $1.2 million plus $1800/month "maintenance", 10K for that dresser is less out of line than you would expect. Make no mistake, it's a limited market.

BTW, you might take a stroll through an IKEA store. While the materials can be poo-pooed, there's a lot of good design in evidence.

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#3

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

John E in SC

On that same site, they're selling an unfinished maple peg with about 6 inches of belt leather as a wall hook for $34. (The walnut one is $40!) Pretty sure I could whip out a few of those from wood in my scrap bin and a $2 belt from Goodwill. Crazy.

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#4

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Google "stump furniture" and then add up how much that down tree in your yard is worth sliced into 24" lengths. Load up a flatbed, find a place to park on Park Avenue in the 70's, and get ready to make some money!!! [Pssst. . . it's been done)

:D :D

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#5

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

John in NM

Yes, they can sell those pieces at those prices, with a pretty big caveat. That caveat is that the market is very limited and the buyer's choice is driven by something I have never understood (if I did I would be busy cranking out $10k dressers).

The last shop I worked for in Tucson sold at those kinds of prices. I believe the owner's success had a lot to do with his showroom and ability to infect his customers with his enthusiasm for the shop's products.

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#6

Marketing *LINK*

Dick Coers

We all have to remember the pet rock, well that is marketing. Same thing with furniture. Tell a great story, have champaign receptions at your studio (not a shop), sell with art galleries who are really master marketing agents, and only sell in major metropolitan areas. If you sell it like art, you have to charge art prices has to be their mantra. Here is my new favorite inspiration site.


https://www.artfulhome.com

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#7

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

A lot of my work sells in art galleries. All woodworkers have options of how to market their work. I prefer galleries and commissions. But unless your work is in a pricey elite gallery, the typical market won't bear the prices you mentioned.

To sell in a gallery is nice because they do all the marketing and business end. Your work gets lots of exposure to potential buyers. The downside is that you do not make as much income per piece. That is because galleries typically get 40-50% of the sale. It requires me to moderate my price to the gallery so that the retail price is at a price point that customers of that gallery will pay. So, for example, I might have a piece that I'd like to get $2,000 for. But after the gallery marks it up, it would be $4,000. That might seem too high to the customers. So it is better for me to get $1,800 for the piece and make the retail price $3,600. It is in the best interest of the gallery and me to dialog about pricing and establish realistic prices.

Someone once told me to price my work high and that doing so would psychologically inspire customers to buy it because it's expensive and "uniquely special" Sort of a snobbery thing. Well, maybe that works in the Hamptons, but not so much elsewhere.

I started out a little more ambitious with my prices. While I did sell some work, I also had work that collected dust in the galleries for too long. It was a good reality check for me. I'd rather sell more work at affordable price points than less work at high prices. Full disclosure, my work is not cheap. Ironically, I cannot afford my own work! ;-) But it's not crazy expensive either and thankfully there are still lots of folks that appreciate hand made unique furniture.

T.

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#8

Its all Image at the high end

Mike Circo

"Snobbery", "Exclusiveness", whatever it's called. Some very small subset of the world live by that credo.

Here is how to market to them.

Artisanal Firewood:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TBb9O-aW4zI

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#9

Re: Marketing  OMG

Mike Circo

There is an item on that site. "Eyewear and Key Holder" that is going for $72.

It is a 7"x10" walnut board with a piece of bungie cord and some magnets buried in the back.

Heck. They didn't even hide the mounting screws.

By that example, my scrap pile is worth $10,000.

As a "make it yourself" person, that kind of stuff boggles my mind. But as they show "sold out" on several of the items, there are some people buying it. Maybe a "Ides of..." item for the future. What we as woodworkers take for granted.

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#10

Re: Marketing  OMG

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

And, of course, you believe that those items are actually sold out, right? ;)

Very old principle, people tend to want what they see they can't have. "Those items are sold out," ergo "the other stuff must be valuable as well so I should buy some before they're sold out as well."

Create demand by "showing" apparent demand for the item. Dr. Freud had nothing on ol' P.T. Barnum.

;)

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#11

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

TomD

"Well, maybe that works in the Hamptons, but not so much elsewhere."

It works pretty well everywhere, just not for the same products. Look at the price of a pick-up truck, there is at least 10K of BS in a Ford F-150. Or a Hotley plane would seem expensive to some.

It helps to be from the environment you are selling in. Either born into it, or never imagined another world. For the real rich 10K is change. I knew a guy who had a 15K a day expense account. He was in sales, so he had a lot of pizza and beer to buy for the sales force. But even if you spent it entirely on other people you would get a taste for it. That was in Canada in the 80s so nothing unusual about it. I remember this news story from way back where some actor got stopped at a border because their cash per diem wasn't declared and was above some money laundering limit. Nobody is surprised at the money some people have, but when it gets spent it does sound pretty odd at times.

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#12

Re: Location, Location, . . . .

Kevin French

We are climbing into the Nantucket market and running into the same problem.

Their chair in teak $800 on sale from $1065.

https://arrowheadfurniture.com/images/products/802.jpg

Our chair make from Wine Barrels $600

http://static1.squarespace.com/static/55350486e4b06c86f25c71d1/55356962e4b0866b2c1b2420/557847fbe4b0884eaa6f7ba2/1435266250325/?format=2500w

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#13

And some people just want good things

Brian Holcombe

....And are willing to pay for them.

I will never understand the lamenting of someone selling their work at a decent price.

Typically a gallery takes half, so if that 10k dresser is in a gallery that the maker earned 5k gross. If he has $500 in materials he's at 4500....unless his tools don't wear or cost money then he has other expenses. After that he has about $4300~ to pay tax on. So if he built in in two weeks then he made the equivalent of about 90k annually.....more realistically it probably took a month, so about 45k.

Ask yourself if you would design, engineer, build, finish, solicit galleries and probably deliver for 45k/year? And that wage isn't guaranteed, it's only there if you are good at all of the above.

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#14

Re: And some people just want good things

North of the Border

"probably deliver for 45k/year"

$45K/yr wouldn't be bad for many woodworkers at all; most, I would suspect, don't make that kind of money on a regular basis from making furniture.

All aspiring woodworkers -- 3 of them -- I know need a second job to support their solo furniture business and I am almost certain if they could make that kind of money a year from building furniture, they would have gone full time making furniture. That's their passion and love, but they are nowhere near making $30K annually and hence a second or part time job is in the mix.

Most established woodworkers teach or write to supplement their income if they have those skills or connections. Fine Woodworking features a lot of furniture makers and they are more the exceptions...

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#15

Re: And some people just want good things

Brian Holcombe

The point that I'm driving at is that is that everyone looks at these prices like there is a special sort of insanity involved, but really it's simply the pricing that makes it viable for all involved.

The showroom takes half, but they're paying rent to the landlord and commission to the rep. For instance I know of one shop in Soho paying $80k/month in rent plus a portion of their profit. The builder takes on the risk of speculative building guessing what will sell, etc.

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#16

Times have changed for hand made furniture

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It has not been very many generations ago that all furniture, no matter the wealth of the buyer, was hand made. Even my wife's family, who were of modest means with 4 kids, had most of their furniture made in a small shop in Utica, NY, from mahogany no less. Most of my grandmother's furniture was hand made. It must have been that custom furniture was more affordable in the past for some reason or another. A middle class family can not furnish their house in hand made "gallery furniture" now days.

One difference is that the cabinet maker sold out of his shop. It could be that the cabinet maker in the past worked with a backlog of orders. The work didn't sit in a gallery for months awaiting a buyer. I suppose another is that the furniture was of like kind so there was little to no design cost. And it might be that furniture was built more efficiently. I know that the pieces of old hand made we own aren't built with flauntable dovetails, for example.

I see a similar situation with pottery. We need some functional bowls. "Nobody" is making functional pottery. We spent most of a day in the artsy district of Asheville looking for functional pottery, for example cereal and serving bowls. All we saw were art projects made to be gifts. Even the potentially functional mugs were mostly not. There must be a market for functional pottery because the stores sell it made in China and its readily available in Mexico.

So, is affordable custom furniture not available because there is no demand, or because the modern makers don't make functional furniture that provides no creative challenge?

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#17

Functional pottery

John K Jordan

Try Bybee pottery in Kentucky: http://www.bybeepottery.com/

The time I visited (years ago) it was all functional.

I also have a good friend nearby who occasionally makes pottery to be used. I have a bunch things he made: dinner plates, bowls, cups, teapots, mugs, butter dish, etc. Now I will say he mostly makes huge raku-fired art pieces with $15000 price tags, but he goes through functional phases and might be talked into commission work. Come visit and we can go see him.

Paul Menchhofer: http://www.paulmenchhofer.com/workshop.html

JKJ

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#18

My guess is that the 'custom' aspect was limited

Brian Holcombe

Bill,

My great grandparents bought alot of a similar style of furniture to what you're describing.

My guess is that they were working from house style patterns in order to keep it reasonable for them and for the consumer and probably buying pre-made moldings and carved legs from someone carving them in a factory. That is a bit different from studio furniture of the time. If we're talking about early 1900's then we should probably compare to Stickley, G&G, etc which I'm certain was not inexpensive at the time.

In my location a lot of people own Nakashima furniture, and in his younger days before becoming incredibly famous he was building furniture for about the same cost as the top end of manufactured retail furniture, at least that is what I have gathered from meeting and conversing with many of his early clients that were buying in the 50's and 60's or those that inherited furniture from their parents buying in that same time period and kept the bill of sale.

I'd imagine Maloof's early days were quite similar and the same with the other greats of the studio furniture movement.

So, to compare apples to apples, I find that studio furniture on the whole hasn't deviated very far in pricing from top end retail furniture (Knoll, HM, Cassina, Denmark majors, etc). For example, a Florence Knoll credenza runs about 14k at the moment, that same money will go pretty far with most studio furniture makers if you want a similar cabinet.

So these makers that everyone is pointing at aren't really carving out a new niche of really expensive studio furniture, they're simply continuing what has been going on for many many years. You could say royalty has been patronizing the equivalent of 'studio furniture' for centuries.

FWIW Japan makes functional pottery at what I consider to be reasonable pricing. Tokoname pottery is mostly very reasonably priced. They do the same with coopered wooden containers, very reasonable considering its handmade.

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#19

that's nearby

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I drive through there on way to daughter's house. Will stop next time.

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#20

The other way of looking at it...

John in NM

I don't think I'd say people look at this as insanity - some do, but most are just marveling at a world outside of their own.

Most of us build stuff because we like to, or because it is the only way to place that stuff within our limited means. The life of a person who could pay multi-thousands for stuff we could ourselves build is as foreign to us as the places they often live.

At the same time, we think nothing of major tool purchases when those are within our means - because few of us could build a table saw. A person not interested in shops would probably look at the thousands I've spent on tools over the years and marvel that someone would do that.

Re: Pricing furniture question.....

#21

Great points!