Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Blotching on Cherry

Posts

Blotching on Cherry

#1

Blotching on Cherry

howard gorman

Hi All I am somewhat new to the site, but there was so much back and forth on this subject that I wanted to comment. Blotching is caused by different densities in the wood. Sanding to a very high grit will lessen it, but not eliminate it. When a pigment stain is applied, some of the blotching is lessened because more of the solids sit on the surface, whereas a NGR or water based stain penetrates more deeply and exaggerates the blotching. The best way to control this is with a wash coat of dewaxed shellac, or even the chosen sealer, just well thinned. This will reduce the penetration of the stain on the entire piece, but it will eliminate the blotching. As to whether the blotching itself is a positive feature, this is a matter of personal preference. The blotching can impart a more rustic feel to a piece, but controlling it is what you might expect to see in a more formal piece.

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#2

Don't stain cherry, the best option!

Dick Coers

I stopped building furniture for hire years ago, so was no longer forced to stain or dye the work I did. The kids understand, natural only, or go to IKEA. It's my opinion that nature gave us enough of a color palette to work with already. So the one little benefit, none of that blotching issue for me!

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#3

Re: Don't stain cherry, the best option!

paul in AZ

I'm with Dick on this one. If you want something to look like it came from IKEA or an interior decorator's showroom why start with wood that is intrinsically beautiful? Get some inexpensive wood and stain away.

I find stained cherry particularily offensive. Put it out in the sun or wait a while and let it's natural glow develop.

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#4

A cherry staining survey

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Post something you have made from unstained cherry. Below I have posted a stained bed in cherry. WC readers can come to their own conclusions on what they want to do.


Re: Blotching on Cherry

#5

Re: A cherry staining survey

Hank Knight

This hunt board has a highly figured cherry top, drawer fronts and door panels. The cherry was finished with a wash coat of 1lb cut shellac and five coats of Waterlox - no stain.

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Hunt%20Board/DSC_2018Medium.jpg.html][/URL]

Here is a better photo of the top.

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Hunt%20Board/DSC_0015Medium.jpg.html][/URL]

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#6

Re: A cherry staining survey

John in NM


Not the best pic of the design as a whole, but it does show the top nicely.

No stain, just oil varnish, probably Waterlox.

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#7

Re: Blotching on Cherry

C. John Hebert

I'm sorry but wash coats are nothing but hog wash. All it does is lighten the whole piece and never completely eliminates the blotch. The best way is leave it natural or use a water based dye stain, in my experience.

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#8

Side track.....

Barry Irby

I made that same piece out of heart pine. From Garrett Hack in Fine Woodworking, Right?

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#9

Re: Side track.....

Hank Knight

Right, Barry. It was a fun piece to build.

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#10

"Cherry" Watco + Garnet + Acrylic Lacquer

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey





Re: Blotching on Cherry

#11

Re: Hog Wash

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Using a 1/2 lb mix of fresh dewaxed shellac as a sanding sealer and then resanding will do much to control the differential wood densities as the shellac will penetrate more in spots so that when the surface is recut (with abrasives or scraper) the differences in absorption rates are reduced. This benefits both pigment and dye stains.

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#12

Re: Hog Wash

C. John Hebert

been there-done that...wasting nothing but time. Just go directly to the water based dye stain and have a near perfect desired result in both uniformity and desired color.

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#13

I agree wash coat beneficial

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


When I test stained a piece of this crotch it went almost black. I put on a wash coat of shellac, scuff sanded with 220 grit, and stained (dye stain In this case).

Personally, I have had good success with a wash coat when needed to control uptake of stain in end grain.

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#14

Re: I agree wash coat beneficial

C. John Hebert

.........ahhhh...but you used dye stain. That was the difference my friend

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#15

Re: I'm sorry

C. John Hebert

I meant...water based dye stain?

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#16

I didn't mean to make this into a contest

Dick Coers

People can easily make their own decision on what to stain. At this stage in my life, it's about respecting the gift from nature. I've not felt this over my whole life, it's come with age and experience. I'll still add surface embellishment and color to some turnings, but they sit on natural colored furniture in our home.

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#17

Re: A cherry staining survey

Alexander Grigoriev

I'm not sure whether to call that unstained cherry, but I use 1# garnet (dark) shellac to color cherry before topcoat. Do several applications, until it doesn't absorb anymore. I wipe any standing residue out. It also evens out sapwood to some degree. Make sure you wipe the excess, otherwise it will mud the sapwood grain, as little of it cherry has. I was not careful, and you can see it as blotching there.

http://i1122.photobucket.com/albums/l522/alegr42/Mobile%20Uploads/150B0F70-E878-4AE2-AA59-65FD9859FBAA.jpg

http://i1122.photobucket.com/albums/l522/alegr42/Mobile%20Uploads/26EA473D-34B5-448C-9630-D36E30FD42A3.jpg


img

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#18

not a contest....helpful information

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In fact I think it would be a nice addition to the Gallery. Under a heading for each commonly used wood people would post a picture of a finished piece of wood and the finishing schedule used to achieve the finish.

For example I don't have a schedule for white oak I am satisfied with. I could possibly go to the site, find one I liked, and buy the stuff to reproduce it.

I have been interested, and impressed, by the finishes that are showing up for cherry.

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#19

thanks

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I had never thought of using Garnet on cherry. Makes sense though.

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#20

Re: I didn't mean to make this into a contest

Hank Knight

I didn't think of my post an a competitive entry, just an example. I agree with you, Dick. My interest these days is in showing off Nature's gifts the best way I can.

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#21

Cherry crib

Dick Coers

Pre catalyzed satin lacquer, cherry with walnut accents


Acrylic modified satin lacquer, cherry and maple plywood


Acrylic modified satin lacquer, cherry and curly soft maple


Re: Blotching on Cherry

#22

Re: Blotching on Cherry

Mark P

I have been trying to get past the blotch for a long time. I've tried sanding to 400, shellac washcoats, sanded back or left alone and glue size.

The best I have come up with goes against some of the commonly expressed thinking. I sand only to 150. Then I used a glue size (1 part hide glue to 5 parts water). That is the best I have come up with. Since then I have substituted Charles Neal's redemix size and it works fine as well.

Try it on some scrap and see what you think.

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#23

Re: I didn't mean to make this into a contest

TomD

I agree, though it is off point here. I have not been disappointed with natural cherry, I suppose to some degree there is nothing to be disappointed with.. If the wood is natural it can't be improved on. Meanwhile pretty much every piece of stained furniture, by modern methods I have been around is pretty disappointing over time. I get why people change it at a point of sale, but why one would do it to onself is less clear to me. As a woodworker, like all of us here, I am pretty familiar with what wood is supposed to look like, and the photo negative effect some stains provide is ridiculous to me. At teh same time I don't know what cherry looks a like a hundred years on, or care particularly. But maybe it darkens to oblivion. Of course, as a woodworker I can freshen whenever I want to. I discovered cherry over hickory rather by accident when making a cheap piece. The base remains interesting and the top I refinishe when I like (or when the crayons dictate). Some peieces I made that wre all chery were not easy to refinish, and the bases got rather dark. Using some contrasting wood allows one some freedom to deal with the needs of different species and design elements.

Re: Blotching on Cherry

#24

charles neil blotch will fix cherry blotching

del schisler

i use his product on all my cherry and other wood's , it works for me and other's , but i guess if you want to mess around , if you have the time ? i use this and don't worry about blotching , look at this video which show's blotching on wood's , it works , just not a put up video the link

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IfCYMdrP8rM&list=UUUgl-M-8eVLCs5OwGx9CLsg